did Telltale want people to Pick Jane?

13»

Comments

  • call him ECIT

    'ECIT' has four letters.

    Thank you for that, Time

    'Time' also has four letters.

    4 = 4, both nicknames are the exact same character length. So what are you talking about?

    dan290786 posted: »

    call him ECIT, it's easier than saying his full username lol

  • ECIT is quicker than saying or typing Everyone'sClemInTime

    call him ECIT 'ECIT' has four letters. Thank you for that, Time 'Time' also has four letters. 4 = 4, both nicknames are the exact same character length. So what are you talking about?

  • I guess also i think my nickname for you sounds better

    call him ECIT 'ECIT' has four letters. Thank you for that, Time 'Time' also has four letters. 4 = 4, both nicknames are the exact same character length. So what are you talking about?

  • He didn't say Everyone'sClemInTime, he called me by a shorter name.

    Thank you for that, Time

    dan290786 posted: »

    ECIT is quicker than saying or typing Everyone'sClemInTime

  • For future reference i guess then

    He didn't say Everyone'sClemInTime, he called me by a shorter name. Thank you for that, Time

  • Yeah as is my opinion with what i said.

    The reason i think he is the most interesting is the reaction his character has got. I have never known a game character to divide people so much. And as i said, whenever he appears in a scene, things happen that are usually memorable, amusing, shocking or just in general something that people talk about

    prink34320 posted: »

    he is the most interesting character created Interesting, definitely, but I wouldn't go that far xD I personally think that the most interesting characters are the ones I know only a small amount about, but that's my opinion.

  • edited October 2016

    I have never known a game character to divide people so much.

    There is Jane lol

    And as i said, whenever he appears in a scene, things happen that are usually memorable, amusing, shocking or just in general something that people talk about

    Same thing is said for every other character, I get what you mean but I'm just saying that as I've been here, I've seen people discuss every scene from every character, it wasn't until Season 2 Episode 5 that people focused on discussions around Kenny and Jane.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Yeah as is my opinion with what i said. The reason i think he is the most interesting is the reaction his character has got. I have never

  • Also, Molly, Nate, Ben, Sarah, and by technicality, Lilly, Luke, Carver, and Arvo.

    prink34320 posted: »

    I have never known a game character to divide people so much. There is Jane lol And as i said, whenever he appears in a scene,

  • There is Jane lol

    Yep but in my opinion not to the extent of Kenny, plus I don't find her as interesting.

    Same thing is said for every other character,

    Not as much as Kenny though and that's kind of a fact to be fair because there are a hell of a lot more topics here that involve Kenny as he has been around since the beginning and is in most of those memorable scenes and most discussions/arguments occur when he's brought up compared to other characters. Granted, yes things exploded after the season 2 finale but there are many other discussions that involve Kenny and not just the Jane/Kenny scene at the end.

    prink34320 posted: »

    I have never known a game character to divide people so much. There is Jane lol And as i said, whenever he appears in a scene,

  • Not as much as Kenny though and that's kind of a fact to be fair because there are a hell of a lot more topics here that involve Kenny as he has been around since the beginning and is in most of those memorable scenes and most discussions/arguments occur when he's brought up compared to other characters. Granted, yes things exploded after the season 2 finale but there are many other discussions that involve Kenny and not just the Jane/Kenny scene at the end.

    Please don't be one of those people that create assumptions and look at them as facts, it's entirely possible that most of the posts are about Clementine herself or even Lee - as those threads are still popular, even then I'm not sure what the frequency of a character being discussed has to do with how interesting they are, especially when it's often the same people discussing those characters either in defense or in comparison of another character.

    But I think having this discussion about interest is pointless so I will not comment on it any further, to each their own.

    dan290786 posted: »

    There is Jane lol Yep but in my opinion not to the extent of Kenny, plus I don't find her as interesting. Same thing is said f

  • Jesus christ! It seems like i am not entitled to an opinion at all without someone getting pissed off for fucks sake! It was my opinion that it was a fact and if you don't like that then tough! You seem to argue with any post i make these days anyway, i've noticed that for a while actually. I'm not perfect by any means but i will say what i feel and that's that so please don't tell me not to say or do something like you just have.

    prink34320 posted: »

    Not as much as Kenny though and that's kind of a fact to be fair because there are a hell of a lot more topics here that involve Kenny as he

  • Why the hell does it bother you anyway?? Most topics i have seen always involve him anyway, that is a fact whether you like that or not dude, sorry but i didn't make the telltale games

    prink34320 posted: »

    Not as much as Kenny though and that's kind of a fact to be fair because there are a hell of a lot more topics here that involve Kenny as he

  • I know I said I would not comment on it any further but now this discussion feels to have transpired to something unintended.

    Firstly, you are entitled to an opinion, I never stated you weren't and I'm not pissed, not sure where that came from...

    Secondly, I don't dislike nor like most opinions, I don't dislike yours either - I just don't like it when people spew 'facts' unless they have evidence to back it up. As I have stated, I agree that Kenny is an interesting character, I just don't agree on your stance of him being the most interesting.

    Thirdly, I don't argue with every post you make, I only go on specific threads that interest me but if I disagree with many of your comments that is probably because I, well, disagree with them as you have disagreed with mine as well.

    I am not perfect either but as you freely state your opinions and oppositions towards others' opinions, I will continue to do the same as everyone in these forums is allowed to so, so long as they follow the rules.

    P.S. I'm not telling you to do anything, I'm asking you not to spew 'facts' without evidence, I'm sorry but I really dislike it when attach 'fact' towards a subjective but I meant no disrespect by it!

    dan290786 posted: »

    Jesus christ! It seems like i am not entitled to an opinion at all without someone getting pissed off for fucks sake! It was my opinion that

  • It doesn't, not sure why you think it 'bothers' me, commenting and disagreeing is not the same as being 'bothered'.

    Welp, of course I can't deny it's a fact since you speak only of what you have seen. I'm not annoyed or disagreeing with you, I'm just saying that talking about a character more than others doesn't determine that they're more interesting.

    I'm not sure why you're annoyed at my responses, have I said something that provoked you? If so then I apologize - that is never my intent when forum-ing.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Why the hell does it bother you anyway?? Most topics i have seen always involve him anyway, that is a fact whether you like that or not dude, sorry but i didn't make the telltale games

  • I'm just saying that talking about a character more than others doesn't determine that they're more interesting.

    Perhaps not to you which is fine but i feel as though if there is more to talk about with a character, there are just more things interesting that can be discussed, thus finding more things interesting good or bad about them.

    I'm not sure why you're annoyed at my responses, have I said something that provoked you? If so then I apologize - that is never my intent when forum-ing.

    I've just read your other post and ok that's fine and i apologise too. The reason i said i felt it was a fact is because the evidence from my viewpoint is that Kenny is discussed a lot more than other characters and i consider him to be the most interesting character due to how often he is discussed. Perhaps I shouldn't have said fact because people on forums seem to hate that word but i'm just saying that i see it as a fact in my opinion. It's not right or wrong and shouldn't make a difference. I felt you got annoyed by it when you told me not to create assumptions but it's just how i see things.

    Again sorry for being defensive. I guess you know how i am

    prink34320 posted: »

    It doesn't, not sure why you think it 'bothers' me, commenting and disagreeing is not the same as being 'bothered'. Welp, of course I can

  • Out of interest then, who do you find to be the most interesting character in your opinion?

    prink34320 posted: »

    I know I said I would not comment on it any further but now this discussion feels to have transpired to something unintended. Firstly, yo

  • This doesn't mean, though, that all who disagree with what he's done haven't evaluated it multiple times—just that some of those who disagree are shallow and fail to think about it twice.

    I strive to be the former.

    dan290786 posted: »

    You know, be violent and have a short temper and stuff. Things which most people would just hate him for without actually thinking about why

  • It was my opinion that it was a fact

    This statement contradicts itself so much.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Jesus christ! It seems like i am not entitled to an opinion at all without someone getting pissed off for fucks sake! It was my opinion that

  • In all honesty? I'd actually pick Sarah - she was individual whose 'problems' related back to mental disorders that seemed to make her fear any sort of danger, yet, she knew she had to learn how to face danger and even tried to learn how to conquer that fear. Sarah's character is presented as weak but with the incentive to become strong and that really interested me about her character.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Out of interest then, who do you find to be the most interesting character in your opinion?

  • edited October 2016

    When i think something is a fact, that in itself is an opinion right? It's not right or wrong

    It was my opinion that it was a fact This statement contradicts itself so much.

  • Ok fair enough

    prink34320 posted: »

    In all honesty? I'd actually pick Sarah - she was individual whose 'problems' related back to mental disorders that seemed to make her fear

  • I'm pretty sure they could've done

    • Luke vs. Kenny
    • Mike and Bonnie vs. Kenny
    • 400 days crew vs. Kenny
    • Carver vs. Kenny
    • Arvo vs. Kenny
    • The russians vs. Kenny
    • A walker vs. Kenny

    And I still wouldn't have picked Kenny.

  • I think telltale intended for us to like both Kenny and Jane so that it would be a hard decision when you decide whether to kill Kenny or let Kenny kill Jane. That obviously didn't work how they had planned bc people usually either really hate Kenny or really hate Jane so it wasn't a hard decision for them. For me it was difficult to decide at the time bc I liked both of them, but Kenny is my favourite so I let him kill Jane. But I think people are suppost to let Kenny kill Jane to get to Wellington bc I feel like that is the place where you should be at the end. But It should have been Luke instead of Jane, I felt like they was planning to have a big fight at the end with Luke and Kenny throughout the whole game bc they literally hated each other from the first conversation they had. But back to the topic, no I don't think telltale wanted us to pick Jane, but I do see your point there should have been different dialogue options so that you could chose to dislike Jane in the game.

  • edited October 2016

    Agreed. I kinda want to create a thread talking about this general topic, but in a world where everyone is expected to be a stoic badass who gets things done and saves lives, having someone who isn't any of those things but is self-aware enough to want/need to become that is what makes characters like Clementine, Arvo, Nick, and Sarah inherently more interesting to focus on and develop than just having characters like Javier(presumably), Carver, Luke, and Jane(to a slightly lesser extent) be instantly hyped up as something special, when really their barely any better than anyone else and in fact, worse in certain aspects. Most people liked this series because its about real people over the odds of an unfair world, not ideal paragons kicking ass and almost nothing else.

    Though, funnily enough, I've pointed out before that that might be because Sarah was essentially set up to be this Season's Kenny to Clementine's Lee.

    prink34320 posted: »

    In all honesty? I'd actually pick Sarah - she was individual whose 'problems' related back to mental disorders that seemed to make her fear

  • Why a walker?:lol:

    GiantKiller posted: »

    I'm pretty sure they could've done * Luke vs. Kenny * Mike and Bonnie vs. Kenny * 400 days crew vs. Kenny * Carver vs. Kenny * Arvo vs. Kenny * The russians vs. Kenny * A walker vs. Kenny And I still wouldn't have picked Kenny.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.