Did you kill them? (Spolier Warning, Beware!)
Did you guys kill Badger and Max? Or did you just kill Max? Or did you just kill Badger? I actually left Badger to turn and I spared Max.
What about you guys?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Did you guys kill Badger and Max? Or did you just kill Max? Or did you just kill Badger? I actually left Badger to turn and I spared Max.
What about you guys?
Comments
Spared max cause he was the one always cutting us slack except for the start of ep3 and then I left Badger to Conrad and it was cool to see
I did the exact same thing. Badger looked like he was too eager for me to kill him, so I was disappointed when I didn't see a pained expression when I said, "let him turn."
Max is just a stupid-yet-useful redneck.
Bashed badger to death. Spared max because I could forsee the cringy scene of the leaders not believing us if I did
I lucilled the shit out of Badger. I wanted him out of the story ASAP.
I killed Max too. He wasn't that bad but he was going along with Joan's plans. Not taking any chances.
I killed them both. They're responsible for a lot of dead people. Badger is scum and although Max is likeable, that doesn't change his involvement nor the fact that he tried killing David.
Since I am playing Javier as quite aggressive, I killed them both.
Never missed a Q on Badger. Executed Max. Lonnie is next.
Apparently you could kill Badger quick somehow, which I would have preferred, but I never found the option, it seems the option wasnt very clear, since only 4.5% of people killed him quickly, or people are just very vengeful
Edit: man, I triple-posted by accident.
I think you hit him with the baseball bat about 3 times and he's dead quick, but other people just kept hitting him.
Its possible killing him quickly is just bashing his head once till he dies and not keep bashing it over and over but im not sure.
I tend to spare lives whenever possible. I wasn't comfortable with beating Badger to death so I didn't pick anything and Trip put him down with his knife.
I beat the holy fuck fucking fuckity fuck out of Badger and spared Max. Somewhere inside me I like to think I saved him because he seemed to be nice to us and has some what of a conscience, but it's really only because he could help us.
Blow his brains out with a gun. Having the gun is determinant but the scene is worth it.
I went fucking Negan on Badger and it felt so glorious. I let Max live and use him to back me up.
Me to Badger.
I finally understands why Negan loves bashing heads.
I killed them both, but i got upset that i killed Max, when i saw other people choosing [Spare Max] in the end Max stood up for you and David. So yeah.. i wish i hadn killed Max.
In the case of Max, I realized that he was more useful alive than dead. I knew we would need help to try and convince Paul and Clint of what Joan was doing, so having him would provide us with the information we would need, especially since the alternative is having Lonnie lie and say it was all David. Plus, despite what Max has done, he still doesn't seem like a bad guy entirely, he did show some signs of remorse in Ties That Bind, so I gave him a chance. As to how this may help or hurt me in the future has yet to be seen, but at the moment, he was more useful alive than dead.
As for Badger, I beat the ever living shit out of him and had no qualms about doing so. I've been wanting to do that since Mariana, and you bet your ass I hit him as much as the game would allow me.
Me too, it's fun as shit.
I let Conrad handle Badger and saved Max. If Conrad had not been there I probably would have let Badger turn.
I may be a monster but I brutally executed them both, after a while I hated myself for it kinda...
I demolished Badger's head and skull and let Max live.
Oops, I did 4 times until I stopped. So that's how I got it.
I preffer Conrad s Execution .
Conrad: ´´ You re not a man. You re nothing´´
´´Points Gun at badger and Shoots him´´
i Told Conrad to Kill him so that he could get Revenge for his wife then i spared Max.
Yeah it was cool
I tried taking mercy on Badger since he looks a lot like Eddie from 400 Days and I thought they may be one in the same... No such luck... I spared Max as he tried to be helpful and maybe he'll return the favor down the road
Let Conrad kill him figured I owed him that much.
I'm thinking of doing the same despite really liking the option to let Conrad do it.
Lucille'd (or can we say Mariana'd? I want to name the bat Mariana) the shit out of Badger, exhausted that Q key. If I had Conrad I would've let him shoot Badger, it reminds me of Jules from Pulp Fiction and that's my favorite movie. I spared Max because he didn't shoot me and wasn't content with letting Badger gut Prescott even though it happened anyway. It seemed to pay off too, Max came clean. I hope he joins the group, I like that guy.
When they gave the option of killing Max, I was like, "Hmm, should I kill him, since I didn't kill Badger?" But I just ended up sparing Max. I think it was a good choice in storyline.
Okay, not gonna lie, that sounds badass!
"Now, allow me to introduce you to...Mariana!"
Same. Hopefully, Joan won't do anything to him for talking.
I let Badger turn because you have no idea how much it hurts when you are dying alive with guts shot out, executing him would end the pain fast. I hope I will utilize Max. Max is a coward so I doubt he's that evil maybe he redeems himself to us by sacrificing himself when he realizes what he has done and my reaction to him in spite of it all (condoning Marieanna's execution and me sparing him for it).
I "Lucilled" Badger and spared Max's life. I liked Max, and I wanted to kill him, but he could be used to expose Joan.
But I'll kill max in the next episode.
Max didn't know about Mariana's death because he wasn't there and will react accordingly if you bring up up during your trial with the Leaders.
I killed both. Why?
Leaving Badger to turn is super stupid. By leaving him like that, he would still be a danger to other people. What if Undead-Badger kills the next scavenger that passes through? No, destroying the head is essential in order to erase his existence once and for all.
Max was part of Badger's group and basically his personal lapdog, took Javier as a hostage over some gasoline that (my) Javier wanted to give back as soon as he found out it belonged to TNF. Max also didn't really try to stop Badger at Prescott and attacked Javier and Co. first in the warehouse in episode 3. Even begging for his life didn't save him. I've seen it often enough that the person who "surrenders" still stabs you with a knife the second you reach out to or turn your back on them. By taking him out, I made sure he couldn't hurt or betray anyone else ever again.
But by leaving Badger to turn, you still let him be a danger to other people. Isn't that reckless?
I hit him three times, got the "he's had enough" comment, and stopped. It still said that I didn't kill him quickly.
I kinda thought so as well. But then again, with your decision, you made sure Max could never hurt or betray anyone else ever again. He was Badger's lapdog and really no good person. Javier had no reason to take Max's words for it. Max could've been lying just to save his ass and betraying you again the first chance he gets. He was not worth the risk imo.