This Thread is going to end the Marlon feud once and for all
Marlon did some pretty shitty things, but he's still a kid. Clem has done some pretty shitty things too. Does that make her a bad person? Clem let Jane die (kinda shitty) or she shot Kenny (also kinda shitty). My point is that if you guys can forgive Clem for her actions, then can't you find it in your hearts to forgive Marlon. To Marlon, Clem and AJ were nobody. He could've passed by the car crash but he didn't. He stuck his neck out for two people he didn't even know. Before giving Marlon shit, remember that Clem and AJ would've died agonizing deaths if he didn't help them. Plus if Clem died, the raiders would've found the school anyway and taken everybody. So in a way, Marlon saved the school by saving you. If he hadn't saved you, all the kids would've been killed. Violet and Louis would be dead if not for Clem. And Marlon is the only reason Clem is alive.
Comments
Marlon pointed a gun at everyone, and would’ve killed Clementine. The boy deserved it.
i'm having a hard time trying to tell if this thread is sarcastic
Jane hang herself and abandoned Clem and AJ. Or Clem followed what Jane said, to keep out of the fight no matter what, also Jane started the fight with the only purpose was to kill Kenny. How is that shitty from Clems part?
As for Marlon the only reason he saved Clem and AJ was to trade them (probably). The raiders already know where the school was, Clem didn't show them anything.
What Clem did was different from what Marlon did. She didn't start the fight. It was Kenny who was committing murder. Clem could either stop him or let him kill Jane. It was a difficult choice for her because she loved Kenny so much. No matter what she chose, she wasn't the one to blame. As a bystander, she might've shared some responsibility for not intervening, but ultimately it wasn't her fault.
You can argue that what Marlon did was of the same nature when he traded off the twins. It was the raiders who started all the trouble. Marlon had no choice but to make a difficult decision. He wasn't entirely at fault here. I'll give you that. But what he did after that was completely fucked up. He lied and concealed this fact from other kids for a year, and at the same time, he verbally abused Brody. He killed Brody by accident and tried to frame Clem for her death. Clem never did something like that.
It's true that he saved Clem from the car crash, but it's possible that he did it so he could trade Clem and AJ to the raiders later. Brody did say Marlon intended to do that.
(Jane started the fight with the only purpose was to kill Kenny. How is that shitty from Clems part?)
cause celm didn't knew at that moment that jane was lying are you saying that you let jane die because you knew she hid a baby to start a fight or you let her die because you didn't want to kill kenny you action considered to be shitty depending on your thoughts/intentions at that moments when you made it not on what comes next.
(As for Marlon the only reason he saved Clem and AJ was to trade them)
excuse me WHAT where and when did that have been stated. i know you hate marlon i am not a fan of him too but don't just made up some bullshit without knowing for sure what it was marlon's intentions when he decided to help Clem.
Is there really a feud worth trying to end?
Maybe it's just the majority drowning out other discussions, but I seldom see more than an occasional randy talk about Marlon under that belief or in general.
For what it's worth, that seemed like something Marlon came up with the night everything came to a head, as it was specifically a solution for dealing with the raiders again once it became clear they really might be back.
Brody's freakouts over the evening and arguing that Marlon just tell everyone what really happened instead were also a direct reflection of that.
All they had to do was make him determinant lol
Good point. Come to think of it. If Marlon knew raiders would return beforehand and he told Brody about it, Brody wouldn't have been able to keep her cool. She lost her head only after Clem told her about Abel. So either Marlon saved Clem out of kindness or he planned it but didn't inform Brody.
Marlon did terrible things but I don't think he deserved to die.
He deserved to be kicked out not killed but it happened,life is not fair.