How would you feel if Clem died determinantly?
Would it take away from the experience? Because when you think about it, this isn't like all the other determinant deaths. This is Clementine, the main character in Telltale's The Walking Dead across all 4 Seasons. Me personally, I don't like the idea of several endings for Clementine, but that's just me and I know people will disagree. It just feels too much like 'this is my ending!' you can have your own version too!' and that's not my favourite, but at the end of the day this is still a Telltale Game, a very special type of choice-based game where choices don't matter, but it's not a movie and I'm sure people would like having their own end for Clem. Also, a lot of cool discussions can come out of it, why players chose certain endings, why they think their choice is right, etc. I have a feeling there will be 3 endings.
- Clem lives but AJ dies
- Clem dies but AJ lives
- Both live but they don't live at the school anymore (not really sure about this one)
And I think that after the game ends there will be a special cutscene for each ending, most likely a timeskip, if both Clem and AJ live then it'll probably be the Happy Dream with all the legacy characters that's so popular on these forums, and with that there'll be some ambiguity because you don't know if Clem and AJ survived.
Anyway, back to the question, how would you feel if Clem died determinantly?