Do you want Lilly to return in Season 3?
I hope she returns. It would be VERY interesting. Even if she killed Carley/Doug, she still was one of my favourite characters during Season 1 and I would like to see her more (or at least something that might tell us if she's alive or not).
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
nah at this point i don't want any other returning characters with the exception of molly
and now that kenny can be dead for some one of the most interesting parts of her returning is gone
honestly if telltale wanted to bring her back they should have done it in like episode 3 instead of introducing jane and they should have done the last choice like this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Toin2jXIrAA&list=UU1MgHZggpKRh4Gb9p-RP4pA
Not really I just hope we pass by some horrible raider camp and see her head on a pike.
Do I want to see her? HELLS YEAH!
I want to see her again just as much as I want to see Bonnie, Mike, Arvo, and also Nate again.
Which basically means, hell fucking yeah I want to see Lilly again.
No because I don't see why people like her so much. I feel they had nothing to think about and just thought, oh yeah, Lily, the minor character from Season One, let's ship her and make her famous!
Lily wasn't that minor in Season One. She was the de facto leader of the group. The whole Kenny/Lily conflict drove much of the story line.
agreed
Yes, yes, and yes.
Seeing old characters return on TWD is always an event. It adds anticipation to the wait. That's one of the reasons why Kenny was the only member of the original cast (besides Christa and Omid) Telltale brought back in season 2...it's gotta be a special thing, and it has to be done carefully. Considering how brutal the world of TWD is, learning that a familiar face from the past has even managed to SURVIVE carries more emotional impact than it would in any other game.
With Kenny's story resolved - as far as we know - Lily should be the next prime candidate to make an epic comeback. Kenny's RV showing up in episode four has to be mean something other than a recycled model.
Telltale, if you have seen this thread then please consider it!
I'd like to see her, but only if she's remorseful for what she did. I expected to see her in Ep 5, though
I'd imagine she would be, otherwise people wouldn't really like her
I hope her horrid looking manface was dismembered from her body by a raider's sharp axe, and her body left in a deep dark forest for the feral dogs to feast on her rotten flesh, and after the dogs are done, her only proof of existence will be her bones, which later turn to dust.
So no.
Yes, I want to see Lily's reaction when Clem tells her Lee is dead. (Depends on how you treated her tho)
I would like to at least get some finality/confirmation of what happened to her. Maybe if we play as her, she could run into Christa (I'm hoping she's still alive, and hasn't just given up after having lost everything), Christa could say she doesn't have time for this, she's looking for a little girl named Clementine, Lilly would go, "Wait, I knew her!" And then they could share stories about how they met her group, etc. Lilly would probably be sad upon hearing about Lee's death, regardless of how he treated her. She would want to know what happened to Kenny, Christa would tell her that she believes he is dead since she last saw him disappear after saving her/Ben. She would probably go "heh, good" but then be surprised that he was selfless enough to save someone at the cost of his own life. We could have the option to be straight with Christa about why Lilly left the group, or bend the truth a bit. I don't know, then maybe we could reunite with Clementine and whoever we ended the season with at the very end of Episode Five. That way, our choice at the end of Season Two would not be completely void, and we would still play as someone who we already have some connection with.
Yes! bring her back!
As much as I like Lilly, even after what happened in Episode 3, I don't want her brought back in any shape or form.
There's no point in bringing her back for the sake of demonising her further and fulfilling the wishes for those who want her dead. Unless the writing in future episodes are more tasteful about bringing back a controversial character and is more reasonable about giving them more depth as a character, I'd rather Lilly's fate remained unknown.
Imagine if the dlc was Lilly. After being alone for say a week or so, she wants to find the group. And since she knows they were heading towards the coast, she goes to Savannnah, and ends up finding Lees corspe.
I can imagine for all of us that would be a tear jerker seein him again.
If they decide to do this they HAVE to learn from series 2
the story plot cant role around 2 characters and the new characters don't get and time to develop. the player wont see the character point of view so if they snap (which Lilly is likely will, she is like Kenny in that regard).
Is Lilly the Lilly from the prison in the comics or not?
Originally was. When I first played the TWD when it came out one of the achievements was on the road to Woodbury, but they changed it later.
Leaving her on the side of the road or her getting away in the RV, Lilly could have gone back to the motel now filled with dead bandits and staggler zombies. Grab some supplies left behind and the guns just lying around (it's what i would do). Lilly is a smart lady, I believe she could survive. Plus stories like these mean if a character does not die on screen probably not dead.
But not anymore? She certainly looks dead like the comic book character.
Yes.
Yeah. Not anymore. I think it was so she could appear again and no one would question how she could come back after the events in the comics at the prison.
Originally Lilly from the game was meant to be the same character from the comic but then The Road to Woodbury book came out and changed comic Lilly's backstory.
My fav character
Of course I want her to come back 
If i had the choice, and it was my decision to cast S3, i would start with a new cast and start over. That would be fine, if they made Lilly the star of her own series, as long as they don't try to connect it to Clementine's story. When they Kenny the game, it makes me mad.
I'd like to see Lilly come back. I enjoyed her rather complex and flawed characterization.
Yes I do want Lilly to return for season 3. Though she wasn't one of my favorites. I still would like to see her at least make a cameo appearance even if it's a "400 Days" style cameo.