I think it's because some people thought that by giving him water he would have the strength to give at least a hint (one or few words) on what might have happened to Christa.
I was surprised that more people chose to give that bandit water. Why would I give the guy who got Clem and Christa separated anything he wanted? For all we know Christa could be dead because of that douche. I let him suffer.
I did it, because Kenny's death hurts me. I want to build something new, not like Crawford, not like Carver's community, where no one need to repeat that old man's tragedy.
I did it, because at that moment I just can't make any other choice with Lilly calling for my help. Then I learnt from somewhere that CPR alone can't save people from heart-attack, but I don't know if that's true. Anyone know something about that?
I was surprised, nay, floored by this one, and also surprised that noone's brought it up yet. Having Clem stick around for Carver's brutal and cold-blooded murder. I didn't hesitate about it. I was positive at once what I wanted MY Clemmie to do, gung ho even. However, I certainly expected to be in the minority, and by leaps and bounds. She is an 11 yr old girl, after all. Imagine my surprise when it turned out only 1/5-1/4 or so of us had allowed her to be led away.
EDIT: So apparently my XBOX tried to load all 3 pages as 1 giant one, and left much out. It IS a bit clumsy with the internet alot of the time. This was apparently one of the first things mentioned in the thread.
I was suprised at how many people chopped of Sarita's arm. I mean, you're in a storm of walkers where you need to be quiet andno medical equipment to stop the bleeding.
I shot her, for AJ's sake, but I'm guessing that most who didn't were trying to avoid the bloodbath they accurately predicted would ensue if anyone, at that point, fired a shot for any reason. Remember, you get the option to call for help. You don't know at that point that Kenny's going to start a shootout if you don't.
I was pretty surprised at how many people didn't shoot Rebecca. I mean, I get it might have been confusing but this far into the ZA you should know you have to put her down.
The "Q" sign starts to fade when you still need lots of Q to kill him. So in my first playthrough I strangled him, and in my 2nd one, when I know that it's possible for Lee to not kill the stranger (I don't know that Clem will do that), I think may be stop at that point will get the stranger fainted but not killed... Then when my Clem shot him I stop the game and rewind.
I was a little surprised that the majority had Clem shoot the Stranger instead of Lee strangling him, though that is kind of a hard QTE to p… moreull off the first time, since you have to mash down the X or A button hard to get Lee to successfully strangle the Stranger.
I was surprised too. I kept the arm cuz I figured I was dead anyway, and that, you know, having two arms might make fighting zombies and climbing ladders easier.
I was surprised that most people cut off Lee's arm. I thought that most people knew that wouldn't work, unless it's immediately after the bite happened.
I think it's because some people thought that by giving him water he would have the strength to give at least a hint (one or few words) on what might have happened to Christa.
loosing an arm and a lot of blood seemed to me more dangerous (especially since i imagined i had to climb up an elevator shaft) and the infection had obviously already spread all over lee's body.
I think it would make most sense to try anyway, even if you know you've gone past the point where it'd effectively save you. The nastiness i… mores in the blood, but the stuff infecting the bite is still in the bite, so in the event bleeding out can be managed and prevented, I think most people would rather get rid of the bite if they had the stones to do it themselves or if someone else was around who could. It doesn't save you, but it does help the body in a way. Lee blacked out less after the amputation.
loosing an arm and a lot of blood seemed to me more dangerous (especially since i imagined i had to climb up an elevator shaft) and the infection had obviously already spread all over lee's body.
I was surprised that the majority didn't abandon lilly. I really liked her til that point but when she shot carls i had such a rage inside me i didn't even think about it i just left her on the side of the road
True, but you never know these things immediately when you're playing for the very first time.They could have made it where he at least tried to say something about the ambush rather than "thank you." before passing out/possibly dying.
Doug= a very neutral lovable guy + bromance + sacrificing himself to save Ben is a way better death than just being shot in the head for no reason (imo)
i guess boys/guys will always save the girl first, its some sort of instinct. since most people who play games are guys there will be a higher number of people who saved the girl (no sexist)
PS: maybe folks thought that she might be pregnant, i don't know
I've seen stats in my game where people just didn't bother helping out Sarah at all (at the cabin and Carver's camp). I mean c'mon Clem needs a friend and Sarah seemed nice.
i guess boys/guys will always save the girl first, its some sort of instinct. since most people who play games are guys there will be a high… moreer number of people who saved the girl (no sexist)
PS: maybe folks thought that she might be pregnant, i don't know
I've seen stats in my game where people just didn't bother helping out Sarah at all (at the cabin and Carver's camp). I mean c'mon Clem needs a friend and Sarah seemed nice.
Doug= a very neutral lovable guy + bromance + sacrificing himself to save Ben is a way better death than just being shot in the head for no reason (imo)
I've seen stats in my game where people just didn't bother helping out Sarah at all (at the cabin and Carver's camp). I mean c'mon Clem needs a friend and Sarah seemed nice.
Comments
I think it's because some people thought that by giving him water he would have the strength to give at least a hint (one or few words) on what might have happened to Christa.
I did it, to let him tell me what happened to Christa... Then when Uncle Pete got no water in his last few hours I regreted...
I did it, because Kenny's death hurts me. I want to build something new, not like Crawford, not like Carver's community, where no one need to repeat that old man's tragedy.
I did it, because I think Duck will get his father's help.
I did it, because at that moment I just can't make any other choice with Lilly calling for my help. Then I learnt from somewhere that CPR alone can't save people from heart-attack, but I don't know if that's true. Anyone know something about that?
Perhaps it's because Kenny prefers a violent way.
I was surprised, nay, floored by this one, and also surprised that noone's brought it up yet. Having Clem stick around for Carver's brutal and cold-blooded murder. I didn't hesitate about it. I was positive at once what I wanted MY Clemmie to do, gung ho even. However, I certainly expected to be in the minority, and by leaps and bounds. She is an 11 yr old girl, after all. Imagine my surprise when it turned out only 1/5-1/4 or so of us had allowed her to be led away.
EDIT: So apparently my XBOX tried to load all 3 pages as 1 giant one, and left much out. It IS a bit clumsy with the internet alot of the time. This was apparently one of the first things mentioned in the thread.
Someone did that says it's a respect to Carver... It may be respectful but I wonder why they want to show respect to that villain?
PS.It's a pity that Carver is not "mixed" enough. Everything he did seen by us just makes him a villain.
Lee + Reggie = when you want to save someone from the bite, do it as soon as you can.
To pay back. Without him Clem would be abandoned in the wood.
I shot her, for AJ's sake, but I'm guessing that most who didn't were trying to avoid the bloodbath they accurately predicted would ensue if anyone, at that point, fired a shot for any reason. Remember, you get the option to call for help. You don't know at that point that Kenny's going to start a shootout if you don't.
The "Q" sign starts to fade when you still need lots of Q to kill him. So in my first playthrough I strangled him, and in my 2nd one, when I know that it's possible for Lee to not kill the stranger (I don't know that Clem will do that), I think may be stop at that point will get the stranger fainted but not killed... Then when my Clem shot him I stop the game and rewind.
Let your Lee talks about it with Kenny in the train cab before Lilly steals the RV. You'll get a reason.
Why not?
In 400 days i'm surprised most people lied to Leland, to me it seemed more logical to be honest with him.
I was surprised too. I kept the arm cuz I figured I was dead anyway, and that, you know, having two arms might make fighting zombies and climbing ladders easier.
Well I didn't think Bonnie would actually go if I said no...
He could barely speak English though..I doubt he understood what Clem was asking him.
i was surprised anyone would not steal them.
I'm surprised that most players didn't take blame for the photo.
loosing an arm and a lot of blood seemed to me more dangerous (especially since i imagined i had to climb up an elevator shaft) and the infection had obviously already spread all over lee's body.
not only claiming it was sarah's idea was considered blaming someone else.
telling carlos he told you to keep her busy seemed like a legit reaction.
And that's perfectly okay. It's your arm, you get to decide what to do with it and why.
I was surprised that the majority didn't abandon lilly. I really liked her til that point but when she shot carls i had such a rage inside me i didn't even think about it i just left her on the side of the road
True, but you never know these things immediately when you're playing for the very first time.They could have made it where he at least tried to say something about the ambush rather than "thank you." before passing out/possibly dying.
I was surprised that barely anyone saved Doug.
TeamDoug
Carley = a shooter + romatic relationship + having a chance to tell others Lee's past.
If I remember correctly, most people chose to help Christa onto the train instead of Omid, c'mon, the guy has a broken leg.
Doug= a very neutral lovable guy + bromance + sacrificing himself to save Ben is a way better death than just being shot in the head for no reason (imo)
i guess boys/guys will always save the girl first, its some sort of instinct. since most people who play games are guys there will be a higher number of people who saved the girl (no sexist)
PS: maybe folks thought that she might be pregnant, i don't know
I've seen stats in my game where people just didn't bother helping out Sarah at all (at the cabin and Carver's camp). I mean c'mon Clem needs a friend and Sarah seemed nice.
The way she talked about things, episode 4 especially, gave the vibe that she was pregnant. She was, and Lee figured it all out by himself.
exactly
i don't get this, first you say that you were surprised that people helper her, but now you're saying that, that is what you think is most logical
I mean that objectively Lee can get more benefit from Carley than from Doug...
But Jesus, I really like that guy. I can't stop shipping Douley...
Lots of people seem to forget that Sarah help save Clem's ass when she was left in the goddamned shed.
I was happy to see that most people did that(I was one of them.) It make's me glad that the "dick move" can be the most popular choice.
Team DOULEY
I didn't realize she was pregnant in episode 3, then as we went on in episode 4, she gave that vibe.
ahh, i catch your drift now