Choices that you're suprised the majority made

1235

Comments

  • That's exactly why I didn't shoot. I figured calling for help might get more people's attention. There's quite a few times I chose to do something for a specific reason, but the game took the decision to mean something else entirely. The only real problem I have with this game is that motives for decisions aren't really taken into account. Hopefully they'll find ways to improve on that in later games.

    I shot her, for AJ's sake, but I'm guessing that most who didn't were trying to avoid the bloodbath they accurately predicted would ensue if

  • Here's what I do in the asshole playthrough:

    1.Try to frighten Clem by being silent in the first meet.

    2.Freeze when Duck and Shawn need help.

    3.Say that Lilly is a bitch, but agree to throw Duck out.

    4.Don't save Clem.

    5.Speak ill of Larry when talking with Mark.

    6.Try to remain neutral when Kenny and Lilly start to argue. It will disappoints both of them.

    7.Feed people like above.

    8.Kill the crazy woman, Larry, St. Johns.

    9.Let Larry and Clem eat the dinner.

    10.Steal the supplies and give Clem the coat. (I think teaching her to steal and not respecting her will is worse than letting her suffer from the cold weather.)

    11.Don't put the girl out of misery, and take nothing while searching for the drugstore.

    12.Don't tell anyone Lee's past.

    13.Torture Ben/Carley and then abandon Lilly.

    14.Keep remind Kenny that Duck is dying. Let him kill his son.

    15.Push Omid, then don't help him or Christa.

    16.Say to Kenny that you'll end the little-boy-walker's misery, and then give the gun to Kenny.

    17.Don't take Clem to Crawford and don't give her the gun.

    18.Shoot Molly and drop Ben.

    19.Don't show the bite. Then be alone to find Clem.

    20.Do nothing when the walkers are intruding the house.

    21.Lose your temper when Kenny raise "Larry situation".

    22.Don't ask Christa and Omid to take care of Clem.

    23.Don't give up all the weapons, or tell Clem to use the chopping knife to attack the stranger.

    24.Tell Clem don't trust anybody and to shoot you.

    25.Lie, to Vernon, to Christa, to Clem,etc, as much as you can.

    It's the asshole playthrough, so...Sometimes it hurts me to see someone hurt by my asshole Lee. But to know how people will react I carry on with it.

    <======= I like Duck too much for that. Plus, its evil.

  • I did it because he was an asshole.. xD

    MayorMilk posted: »

    I was kind of surprised more people didn't help Kenny kill Larry, sure I felt bad about it, and regretted it a bit, but I did it for Clem's safety.

  • i think that is more asshole leave duck to turn and leave kenny with the zombie in the attic

    24601 posted: »

    Here's what I do in the asshole playthrough: 1.Try to frighten Clem by being silent in the first meet. 2.Freeze when Duck and Shawn ne

  • edited September 2014

    I didn't really get that vibe. Maybe it's another lee and Clem situation, a man who considers himself a 'dad' to a child that became an orphan. Also when the 'mother' gave Jane a grateful hug, it seemed genuine to me. But what do I know. In real life, I make excuses for strangers I don't know too, just b/c I don't know what battles this person has faced/is facing.

    ABigBadWolf posted: »

    That people let the family in in the Jane ending. They seemed so suspicious to me, I dunno.

  • I don´t know, there was something raising alarm bells in the way he kept reaching behind his back. I might be wrong, we won´t know till S3, but for now I´m satisfied I sent them away.

    Aamna posted: »

    I didn't really get that vibe. Maybe it's another lee and Clem situation, a man who considers himself a 'dad' to a child that became an orp

  • Steal the supplies and give Clem the coat. (I think teaching her to steal and not respecting her will is worse than letting her suffer from the cold weather.)

    You just made me feel like an asshole.

    24601 posted: »

    Here's what I do in the asshole playthrough: 1.Try to frighten Clem by being silent in the first meet. 2.Freeze when Duck and Shawn ne

  • Keep in mind that not everyone actually took the photo. I didn't take the photo, so I wasn't going to take blame for something Sarah did.

    I'm surprised that most players didn't take blame for the photo.

  • Yes another Avatar fan! have you seen the the last season of Korra

    ps3gamer095 posted: »

    She was dead already but i think it was cause it would make more noise and give you less tim to get the supplies (which in the end don't even matter). Is hot her, i thought it was the right thing to do.

  • I completely forgot you don't have to take the photo.

    Tyranniac posted: »

    Keep in mind that not everyone actually took the photo. I didn't take the photo, so I wasn't going to take blame for something Sarah did.

  • YOUR EVIILLL!!......EVIILLLL!!...

    24601 posted: »

    Here's what I do in the asshole playthrough: 1.Try to frighten Clem by being silent in the first meet. 2.Freeze when Duck and Shawn ne

  • edited September 2014

    I'm in the half of Book 3 right now.

    joshua007 posted: »

    Yes another Avatar fan! have you seen the the last season of Korra

  • I have =D

    joshua007 posted: »

    Yes another Avatar fan! have you seen the the last season of Korra

  • In my first play through I actually tried to save Larry. I did it for Lilly's sake in hopes that you could have a relationship with her later down the road. The third episode really surprised me considering Lilly still goes mad no matter how close you are with her.

    I didn't have my Clem watch Kenny kill Carver the first time. I also didn't chop off her hand either.

  • I chopped off the arm out of panic. My instinct said, "Hey Reggie survived, why can't she?" So I did what I did and soon enough I realized we were still surrounded by walkers. XD

    Brownsa posted: »

    I was suprised at how many people chopped of Sarita's arm. I mean, you're in a storm of walkers where you need to be quiet andno medical equipment to stop the bleeding.

  • What do you mean he could barely speak English? When he was interrogating Christa, his English was perfect. The only reason it sounded broken was because he was weak.

    Tinni posted: »

    He could barely speak English though..I doubt he understood what Clem was asking him.

  • I saved her because the camera panned on her first, so I thought, "Ok, I'll save you."

    bloop posted: »

    If I remember correctly, most people chose to help Christa onto the train instead of Omid, c'mon, the guy has a broken leg.

  • I agreed with Kenny on that one. It gave us more time to collect more stuff. Besides, she was dead anyways.

    bloop posted: »

    I'm surprised that most people left the girl in the street to suffer and die. Is it because she was bit?

  • Ah man, that made me crack up bad.

    Potential boyfriend? To who? Lee XD

  • I was really surprised that most people accepted Nick's apology on episode 1.

    You have to think back to the situation. Nick had only had one scene before the apology and he was actively hostile and rubbish toward Clementine. Almost shot and killed her, was being a dick to other people in the group, and lead Clementine to the "shed of doom" with weapon drawn. I personally told him where he could shove his apology.

  • I won't tell you that my asshole Lee tried to chop David's leg for twice and then leave him there, ;)

    xClementine posted: »

    YOUR EVIILLL!!......EVIILLLL!!...

  • Lol, you should looter. The other part of that is that now the stranger's alot more justified and you much more to blame for his part in the story. Its YOUR fault that Clem gets taken.

    Steal the supplies and give Clem the coat. (I think teaching her to steal and not respecting her will is worse than letting her suffer from the cold weather.) You just made me feel like an asshole.

  • edited September 2014

    Can't really blame him, he was paranoid and had to kill his mom who turned into a walker, at least he apologized, and I could understand where he was coming from, I'm sort of nice like that. :)

    I was really surprised that most people accepted Nick's apology on episode 1. You have to think back to the situation. Nick had only had

  • edited September 2014

    You didn't know at the time of the choice though. So I just saw him as a trigger happy asshole...

    J-Master posted: »

    Can't really blame him, he was paranoid and had to kill his mom who turned into a walker, at least he apologized, and I could understand where he was coming from, I'm sort of nice like that.

  • In that moment he could barely speak English, he was about to die. I mean to say there was no point in giving him water if he was delirious to the point he wasn't able to speak proper English, not to mention he caused Christa and Clem to get separated. I'm glad I gave him nothing, for if I had given him water, I wouldn't have been able to give any to Uncle Pete.

    What do you mean he could barely speak English? When he was interrogating Christa, his English was perfect. The only reason it sounded broken was because he was weak.

  • Why?

    supersagig posted: »

    i think that is more asshole leave duck to turn and leave kenny with the zombie in the attic

  • We can't know everyone from the very beginning. Remember how Lee distrusts Chuck (asking Clem if the candy tastes funny and being mad at what Chuck tells Clem)? Remember how we trust Vernon? And Nick seems to be honest when he's making apology. So that's why I forgive him.

    You didn't know at the time of the choice though. So I just saw him as a trigger happy asshole...

  • Carver's such an idiot for wasting Reggie's life and labor to prove a point. He could've been Omid #2. But I did accept the fact that Sarah couldn't function normally and people gave her so much grief for it.

    Joweh3010 posted: »

    I think she just couldn't hear Reggie's instructions over all the shock and anxiety that was flooding her mind

  • Oh ok that's what you meant. Yea, I regret giving him the water every time now. I thought if I hadn't, it would come around and bite me in the ass. Knowing nothing wrong will happen, screw him! :D

    Tinni posted: »

    In that moment he could barely speak English, he was about to die. I mean to say there was no point in giving him water if he was delirious

  • edited September 2014

    I won't criticize running for cover. I get it. But why in the world would it be surprising that my first concern was AJ? That's strange to me.

  • The moment Carver's agony came, I was out of character, I didn't think of Clem but I "my real life self" wanted to see it out of curiousity how that fucking ****would suffer.

  • Your Clem is (was, at least) in a much healthier headspace than mine.

    I wanted to watch IC and OOC.

    Web Head posted: »

    The moment Carver's agony came, I was out of character, I didn't think of Clem but I "my real life self" wanted to see it out of curiousity how that fucking ****would suffer.

  • Yeah, I very much frowned upon Carver's way's of leadership through fear and manipulation, Reggie seemed like a decent guy. I think in fictional apocalyptic stories like these It's nice and easy to say you'll be strong and push forward, possibly being bad ass and getting through it all with macho scar's and what not but in reality there would for sure be people like Sarah overwhelmed with anxiety, heck people in real life are like that without any damn zombies! That's why I sympathized with her and did all I could to help.

    Carver's such an idiot for wasting Reggie's life and labor to prove a point. He could've been Omid #2. But I did accept the fact that Sarah couldn't function normally and people gave her so much grief for it.

  • I NEED BOOK 4!!!

    Bane: than... You have my permission to die

    Me: huh?

    Bane: shit time to go throws smoke bom

    ps3gamer095 posted: »

    I'm in the half of Book 3 right now.

  • Kenny killing Carver... I was a little bit surprised that so many stayed and watched

  • Yeah book 3 was awesome! can't wait for the next one! XD

    joshua007 posted: »

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A0UBbzeFc74 KorraNation

  • edited September 2014

    You tried to save larry in the hopes of getting laid latter on????????....... maaaaan thats colder than smashing larrys head in lol

    Saloon posted: »

    In my first play through I actually tried to save Larry. I did it for Lilly's sake in hopes that you could have a relationship with her late

  • Are you joking?

    A pissed Kenny with crowbar = best entertainment since breaking bad... hehehehehehe

    joshua007 posted: »

    Kenny killing Carver... I was a little bit surprised that so many stayed and watched

Sign in to comment in this discussion.