I tried my best to avoid hitting him during the fight sequence, but it looks like I had to kill him in the end after all. I left him because "Make him suffer" was a different option, so I thought "Leave him" means he'll stay alive,
I left him. I didn't think he would die, and I worried someone might find out, but I figure my case is slightly better if I'm not seen plunging a sword into him, or pushing him off the Wall.
I left him... Why would I want to kill him? His death would not benefit me in any way, it would only make things worse for me. But ye he dies no matter what. (F you plot)
I wanted to kill Britt, I'm glad I killed Britt, but I tried so hard not to kill Britt.
I really didn't want to let Jon down, I gave him my word and swore an oath.
I was even hesitant about leaving the Nights Watch to find the North Grove, because it was like I had a new start in life, a clean slate and I had 'brothers' since I managed to befriend both Cotter and even Finn.
When Duncan tasked me to find the North Grove I felt quite conflicted, I had taken the Black yet I still felt loyal towards House Forrester.
None of that really mattered anymore when it came to fighting Britt, I told him I didn't want to fight him, that he wasn't worth it, that I swore an oath not to kill a brother, unlike him I actually tried to uphold my oath.
But the teaser shows no matter what my intentions the Nights Watch will want my head, I doubt anyone will even believe me when I say it was self-defence, and I can't believe Finn betrayed me like that.
I didn't let him suffer, I really wanted to make him pay for what he did to Gared's sister and father, but I wanted to get rid of his body as soon as I could, not that it really mattered since Finn saw me anyway.
Still, now I have an excuse to forsake the oath, now I'm no longer conflicted about my loyalties, I know my destiny is to protect House Forrester.
It would be cool to meet Mance Rayder... and Whitewalkers, maybe even children of the forrest.
I drew the sword first at the beginning. I even let him pick up his sword in the middle of the fight. And slashed his arm in the end. But, as much of a little shit he is, I walked away from him. At that moment, all I could keep thinking was that I didn't want to give in to vengeance.
I found it oddly satisfying that I killed him not out of revenge but self-defense. I gave him every chance to give up, he was just too dumb to take it.
i told him i wouldn't fight him, attempted to get him to stop, and then i walked away. annoying that he died anyway but there wasn't another option, he would've killed me. plus now i can say it was self defense/he was attacking me and not get called out for lying.
I left him... Why would I want to kill him? His death would not benefit me in any way, it would only make things worse for me. But ye he dies no matter what. (F you plot)
I tried not to kill him, because I figured he wouldn't give up and I decided that the best course of action was to claim that it was self defense. For that reason I didn't push him off the wall. I mean, my characters are not above vengeance or watching people like Britt fly. But I had to make my defense believable, so I walked away. Also, I had promised Jon and I thought it'd help me to stick with that promise.
I gave him every chance to back down and took every opportunity I got to tell him that I wouldn't kill him. I came out of that as spotless as possible and Britt died. Win win.
If the bastard had survived I probably would have killed him the next chance I got, though.
And next playthrough I'm totally going to make him regret what he did.
I started the fight and then made him suffer. Also, I loved how terribly one-sided the fight felt. Most Telltale fights give that illusion that the two fighters are equals and that it could go either way but with this one Britt didn't seem like he ever had any chance at winning.
Oddly I spared him as I wanted to follow the vows and what Jon said and it only slashed his arm, (but he died anyway). But in the next episode's "previously on Game of Thrones" it showed Garred stabing him through the chest and in that episode he clearly had a hole where he had been stabbed.
that pissed me off as I never Stabbed him, just tellTale covering tracks and a lazy way of making sure you got the blame.
yup I did the same thing as regraham. I kept telling Britt that I wouldn't fight him and only defended myself and when I was given a choice decided to slash his arm so he wouldn't be a threat anymore and yet the next episode acted like I had fucked him up good in the chest instead. I was similarly pissed.
Was proper crap that wasn't it, I mean i know my choices don't matter as much as the game suggests they do, but this blatantly ignored my choice and replaced it with it's own event. WTF!
yup I did the same thing as regraham. I kept telling Britt that I wouldn't fight him and only defended myself and when I was given a choice … moredecided to slash his arm so he wouldn't be a threat anymore and yet the next episode acted like I had fucked him up good in the chest instead. I was similarly pissed.
I wanted to kill him to get revenge for my family, and it didn't matter what anybody said or what the consequences would be to me, so I made the cock-sucking cunt suffer, and have no regrets whatsoever.
Normally I feel constricted (even a little oppressed) by Telltale's rigid storytelling structure, but this was the first time where I thought the game developers cheated outright. I mean, how could stabbing Britt in the arm kill him? At least, right away?
Either Telltale should have included an explanation about the brutally cold environment of the Wall coupled with Britt's injury caused him to expire, or just removed the "stab arm" option entirely. If they HAD to make Gared abandon the Night's Watch, they could have done so without insulting the players who wanted to remain loyal.
My first play through I honored my vows... And when telltale slapped me in the face and gave him the stab wound anyway... I said eff it my second time around.
Comments
Really?
So do I, but the gods decide that he died no matter what. (gods=pigs in the farms)
Nope, my bad. You can "leave him be" which means he'll just bleed out from his wounds in front of you, rather than you speeding the process up//
Made him suffer.
I thought let him suffer meant he would bleed out. It was bitter sweet though.
I left him. I didn't think he would die, and I worried someone might find out, but I figure my case is slightly better if I'm not seen plunging a sword into him, or pushing him off the Wall.
Me too it look like the right thing to do.
Not everyone is willing to do that... (I know the plot demands it...)
I left him... Why would I want to kill him? His death would not benefit me in any way, it would only make things worse for me. But ye he dies no matter what. (F you plot)
I wanted to kill Britt, I'm glad I killed Britt, but I tried so hard not to kill Britt.
I really didn't want to let Jon down, I gave him my word and swore an oath.
I was even hesitant about leaving the Nights Watch to find the North Grove, because it was like I had a new start in life, a clean slate and I had 'brothers' since I managed to befriend both Cotter and even Finn.
When Duncan tasked me to find the North Grove I felt quite conflicted, I had taken the Black yet I still felt loyal towards House Forrester.
None of that really mattered anymore when it came to fighting Britt, I told him I didn't want to fight him, that he wasn't worth it, that I swore an oath not to kill a brother, unlike him I actually tried to uphold my oath.
But the teaser shows no matter what my intentions the Nights Watch will want my head, I doubt anyone will even believe me when I say it was self-defence, and I can't believe Finn betrayed me like that.
I didn't let him suffer, I really wanted to make him pay for what he did to Gared's sister and father, but I wanted to get rid of his body as soon as I could, not that it really mattered since Finn saw me anyway.
Still, now I have an excuse to forsake the oath, now I'm no longer conflicted about my loyalties, I know my destiny is to protect House Forrester.
It would be cool to meet Mance Rayder... and Whitewalkers, maybe even children of the forrest.
I made him suffer, then gave him a base jumping lesson, without a parachute. Felt good.
I drew the sword first at the beginning. I even let him pick up his sword in the middle of the fight. And slashed his arm in the end. But, as much of a little shit he is, I walked away from him. At that moment, all I could keep thinking was that I didn't want to give in to vengeance.
When the option appeared, despite being adamant on not killing him I decided "Fuck it" and disembowelled him.
I found it oddly satisfying that I killed him not out of revenge but self-defense. I gave him every chance to give up, he was just too dumb to take it.
Well to be honest, we all did kill him. He was just a plot device for us to desert, silly telltale.
i told him i wouldn't fight him, attempted to get him to stop, and then i walked away. annoying that he died anyway but there wasn't another option, he would've killed me. plus now i can say it was self defense/he was attacking me and not get called out for lying.
That's why making him suffer is the best option. You'll kill him anyway, but making him suffer is more enjoyable.
Always kicked him off the wall.
@Finnisher
No, it's 89. 100-11=89.
REKT REKT REKT
(Just kidding, fella.)
I tried not to kill him, because I figured he wouldn't give up and I decided that the best course of action was to claim that it was self defense. For that reason I didn't push him off the wall. I mean, my characters are not above vengeance or watching people like Britt fly. But I had to make my defense believable, so I walked away. Also, I had promised Jon and I thought it'd help me to stick with that promise.
I gave him every chance to back down and took every opportunity I got to tell him that I wouldn't kill him. I came out of that as spotless as possible and Britt died. Win win.
If the bastard had survived I probably would have killed him the next chance I got, though.
And next playthrough I'm totally going to make him regret what he did.
I kicked him off the wall.
THIS IS SPARTA!!!
I made him suffer and i do it every time
I started the fight and then made him suffer. Also, I loved how terribly one-sided the fight felt. Most Telltale fights give that illusion that the two fighters are equals and that it could go either way but with this one Britt didn't seem like he ever had any chance at winning.
Britt suffered! He was just looking for trouble.
Oddly I spared him as I wanted to follow the vows and what Jon said and it only slashed his arm, (but he died anyway). But in the next episode's "previously on Game of Thrones" it showed Garred stabing him through the chest and in that episode he clearly had a hole where he had been stabbed.
that pissed me off as I never Stabbed him, just tellTale covering tracks and a lazy way of making sure you got the blame.
yup I did the same thing as regraham. I kept telling Britt that I wouldn't fight him and only defended myself and when I was given a choice decided to slash his arm so he wouldn't be a threat anymore and yet the next episode acted like I had fucked him up good in the chest instead. I was similarly pissed.
Was proper crap that wasn't it, I mean i know my choices don't matter as much as the game suggests they do, but this blatantly ignored my choice and replaced it with it's own event. WTF!
I noticed the same thing and was annoyed. I also noticed a similar false previously-on later, though I don't recall where.
I kicked him off the wall.
Walked away. I played Gared as super honourable--so he wouldn't break his vows, or the promise he made to Jon Snow.
A shame, really, since none of that matters. Like, even a little bit. Otherwise, without a doubt I would have made him suffer
Twisted my sword in his gut, it felt so satistfying!
I wanted to kill him to get revenge for my family, and it didn't matter what anybody said or what the consequences would be to me, so I made the cock-sucking cunt suffer, and have no regrets whatsoever.
Made him suffer by sticking that sword into him for a solid few seconds then kicked him off the wall, lmao.
I don't usually do that sort of dark thing, but that bastard deserved it.
Normally I feel constricted (even a little oppressed) by Telltale's rigid storytelling structure, but this was the first time where I thought the game developers cheated outright. I mean, how could stabbing Britt in the arm kill him? At least, right away?
Either Telltale should have included an explanation about the brutally cold environment of the Wall coupled with Britt's injury caused him to expire, or just removed the "stab arm" option entirely. If they HAD to make Gared abandon the Night's Watch, they could have done so without insulting the players who wanted to remain loyal.
Kicked him off the wall mainly to destroy the evidence. Didn't know making him suffer would end up having Britt thrown off the wall.
I made that little prick suffer. If someone did that to my family, they would wish they were dead by the time I was done with them
My first play through I honored my vows... And when telltale slapped me in the face and gave him the stab wound anyway... I said eff it my second time around.
I wish I could have crotch stabbed him like Brienne did to that one guy.
THIS
IS
NIGHT'S WAAAAAAATCH!
...That's what I did with him.
Made him suffer. He said that he gutted Gared's dad so I figured he should 'feel what it's like' too.