When did you realize Sarah was not
CrazyGeorge
Banned
savable?
It was right after Jane and Clementine saved her from the trailer park, She made a comment how "as soon as her dad gets there, they can leave." At that moment, i knew she was done. There wasn't anything Clementine could do, because she was completely lost. When she fell off the bridge, i hesitated pulling Jane up, i thought for a split second about trying to save her, but ultimately made the choice to save Jane. I didn't want to give up on Sarah, but sometimes you can't save everyone.
I liked that goofy kid. Oh well.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
All the adults weren't looking after her at all so I did everything I could to help her. Rebecca tried a bit but she was having a baby so I don't blame her.
when a canon buckeled under it's own weight smashing the wooden planks that it was placed on....happens to all the tourists who visit the civil war site...
What happens if you try to save sarah? I helped jane
Sarah stil dies
I felt bad. I decided to leave her in the trailer at first, but when she said, "Clementine?", I just thought, "SHIT I SCREWED UP I NEED TO REPLAY THAT!" But when Jane told me that she's not gonna change and that she's completely lost it, I felt even worse because I'm letting a tortured person continue living on and it made me think, "I probably should've left you in there." Then when the option to save Sarah or Jane at the deck came up, I instantaneously chose Jane. But I do have to admit, what a poor way to take Sarah out. Even after all that convincing, she still died.
So many Bens in the game >_<
Why did they have to make her death so sad? She was screaming for Clementine to help her and pleading to the walkers not to eat her. That was the first death in season 2 that I teared up.
There was just no saving her. Jane was right about her, sucks to say that but its true.
I didn't. Even if she was broken mentally, I still wanted to save her. Maybe I'm too nice. Carlos was right - she literally did need him.
Right when the camera focused on the plank from the conservatory deck. I knew that was going to interrupt Jane's attempt to save Sarah.
If only Jane hadn't hesitated and just went straight down to save her...
Sarah's been gone since Carver beat her dad and she blamed Carlos. The kid has poor comprehension skills. She truly did not fall off at that moment, but it signaled undesirable mentality.
Just blame Carlos for sheltering his daughter instead of making her toughen up.
It was a really sad scene. I saved Jane but I was not even thinking about it, was on auto pilot. The worst thing was that for once, it was not Sarah's fault she fell off. I could not stay mad at Sarah because she is just a kid. Though I gave her gun training would have been nice to see her use it.
if you choose to save her, clem tells stupid jane to go and try to save sarah. She tries to move the wood, but the zombies prevail and end up munching on her face. Pathetic though, she was technically savable if everybody jumped and sliced away.
What are you talking about? Blamed Carlos for what?
I didn't fully realize it until her final death scene where Jane jumps down only to be unable to save her, but trying to get her to leave at the trailer park was one of the hardest things to do, since it felt like there were more options to give up on her and leave her, than actually try and help her, so I thought it was like they wanted us to leave her behind... maybe I should've seen that as a sign she was doomed no matter what. I found it sad and knew Sarah just wouldn't last too long when she said she was waiting for Carlos to come back so they can go back to the cabin though. But I still wanted to give her a chance. Poor Sarah, there was nothing we could do for her in the end.
think Carlos done a pretty good job as a one parent family keeping Sarah pure when others were going to extreme lengths,if he would of Lived Longer no doubt he would of taught Sarah more about what was happening around her.
I saved Jane, but I would have thought that both die since later on in my playthrough Jane leaves. Would have been a convenient way to get rid of two characters and offer the player some choice.
But if Jane is stil alive in every scenario, she might still come to the rescue.
I tried to save her up until the end because I hoped, I just hoped, that Telltale wouldn't let us save her life and then just unceremoniously murder her in the very same Episode. Especially after how they fucked Nick over. If I had to pick the moment I realized she'd die no matter what, it would be when the board hit Jane in the face when she was trying to save her.
In a way Sarah is probably one of the most believeable characters. I know someone who suffers from depressions and there is absolutely no way to get through to that person or to offer help.
I could relate to Sarah's lacking will to live. I still fought for her at the trailer and to see her die such a cheap death made me sad (although by that point I already opted for Jane).
The scene where 'saved' Sarah dies is pathetic. They're slowly advancing towards Sarah, but Bonnie only kills the first two for Jane, then just lets them reach Sarah and eat her. You'd have thought Mike - the guy who has been shown to be strong - would head down to help as well.
When she made that comment about her dad, I kinda knew deep down that she was not going to be OK. Despite this, I tried my very best to save her and motivate her, holding on to the hope that she might eventually recover. Was disappointed when she met her fate, to say the least.
Also the fact you WATCH her die, and she didn't get eaten by one walker a ton of walkers.
Also her first death it looks like the walkers are beating her up
Wow, she still thinks her dad is alive if you save her? Feeling better about leaving.
Tell me one thing, if clem knows she´s dieing and she can´t help her why is there unstead of mercy shot some stupid talking wtf?![Same like you did with Ben if he get stab on that iron tube She could just shot her...Luke or Jane could broke her neck it would be easier it was just innocent girl. But no.... seriously why was there choice leave sarah...who could do that? someone heartless probably...
I think this version would be better.
C: We´ll just take you to your dad. I promise it won´t hurt just close your eyes and breath
S: okay,closing her eyes
C: shot
I know, right? I honestly would have preferred that.
I liked sarah at the start but she does nothing for the group nearly got luke killed by being loud shouting attracting walkers and basically got carlos killed and sarita.I saved her the first time but didnt even try the second time she had plenty of time to toughen up didnt even try was carlos fault aswell for babying her so long she would of only got more people killed if she stayed alive sad to say but its the truth
Right when I realized she was put into a bad situation.
That was her character. Can you imagine her NOT screaming and hollering for someone to come and save her? That just not her character, she was too scared and panicky.
That was very sad! I wish Sarah had survived, the girl was completely messed up in the head, but I had hoped that she would gradually get back on track... I convinced Jane to try and take her from there, but unfortunately it didn't work..
R.I.P Sarah. ;..(
Two questions:
Jane always leaves the group after what happens to Sarah, or is there any chance she stay with us?
Is it really possible to leave with Jane (leave the group)?
I realized it the same time you did. Man that was sad. She really ceased to function.
I realized too late. I wanted to jump down there and help Sarah up, but I couldn't. I had to watch her die, and even though it happened to everyone, I can't help but feel like it's my fault.
You know telltale.
Question 1: Nope.
Question 2: Nope.
I would've left her. She was a danger to everybody in the group. Nobody wants to take care of a girl that old who refuses to believe the things around her. I actually like the death scene, it's more dramatic and her shrieks invoke catharsis.
As soon as her fate was determinable, because we all know determinate characters die later on anyway.
I just didn't expect it to be in the same episode.
I think that we're going to see that Carver was right about everything he said. "...stop coddling that girl!" Was the best thing he could've said to Carlos, but he didn't listen. He's been right about numerous other things too.
They really REALLY needed to atleast give her a fighting chance. I wish a gun fell down with her when she fell and she tried to shoot but found it empty/or she can't aim properly. It would have atleast made our decisions worthwhile and the situation more believable. Poor Sarah... I wanted to give her a pinky promise one more time...
Sarah died because nobody cared about her life.
Luke did, yes. Even I don't like him (bring me downvotes if you want), he's good man, I have to admit that. He went after Sarah to save her. But when they made back to the meeting place - what's happened in my playthrough - Luke's Rescue was done. "Everything will be fine". Then Jane happened.
Rebecca did for a short while, but she simply couldn't devote herself - considering she was getting into labor soon.
Kenny just lost Sarita, and he was busy looking after Rebecca and the baby.
Jane? Why? Sarah reminded her of Jaime and Jane didn't expect this.
Mike? Bonnie? Nope. They barely even knew her.
People easily forget that Clementine is just a little girl. The toughest one I know, but still.
When i saved her and she never talked afterwards and nobody even seem to know she was there.
I was like "Yep, she's gonna die soon"
Actualy i disagre with you about Bonnie. She kills 2 walkers to save her but she was out of ammo (PROBALY). Also, in the herd she started to kill walkers with her gun to protect Sarah. Plus she knew Sarah, since Bonnie stated that she wanted to go with the group but she chickened out