Kenny=Rick Grimes and Joel
For anyone that didn't agree with Kenny killing Jane, imagine this, let's replace Kenny in that scene with another man.
Rick Grimes would have killed Jane if she told him she killed Carl. Joel from The Last Of Us would have killed Jane if she told him she killed Ellie.
So stop saying Kenny wasn't justified with what he did, he was. Kenny is a strong man, thats who you want looking after Clementine. Kenny loves her as family while Jane is manipulative, backstabbing, cold and would ditch Clementine if it meant saving her own skin, while Kenny would do and give anything for Clem. I left Wellington because that was the right thing to do. My Lee said he wanted Kenny to look after her, and he is fulfulling that promise.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
yeah basically kenny is like rick grimes, not a bad guy, but he will do what has to be done, even if that thing is bad
In the comics Rick's group came to the prison and some of the prisoners were there, one of them was a psychopath and harmed Ricks group and he pulverized him in front of everyone and he never touched Carl or Lori, Rick brutally murdered the hunters which wasn't even shown in the comics as it was too brutal. Kenny lost his friends was imprisoned and lost his eye and beat carver to death. Kenny lost Katjaa, Duck, and Sarita and kept going, Rick almost completely slipped off the deep end after Lori. Rick brutally murders the hunters and it's all fine and dandy but when Kenny flips shit for a random person showing up with his gang and nearly killing the entire group it's wrong, beating Arvo for Luke's death I agree it was his fault. Finally if anyone were to kill Carl or make him think they did like what Jane did to Kenny, Rick would probably be even more violent than Kenny was. I love both Rick and Kenny but both have done pretty messed up shit to people who have endangered his family or groups life, I still love their characters.
Don't even think of comparing Kenny to the awesome Rick.
Rick would never have killed Jane, he would have maybe hit her or yelled but he doesn't kill for fun or to satisfy anger management issues.
If anything Rick would have killed Kenny the moment he started going insane as he's a threat to everyone and causes the group to go to heck.
Also, Jane didn't say she killed the baby. She said it was an accident and the baby was gone. Stop trying to twist things, Kenny lover.
Yeah, Kenny seems like a combination of TV series Rick and Joel to me as well.
He's nothing like those characters, they actually know how to think and don't treat murder as a game or an outlet for anger issues.
You're right..Both Kenny and Rick do what has to be done.
Parts of Kenny remind me of Rick and Joel, perhaps I should have made myself more clear first time. I'm not saying he is fully like them, just there's a few things about him that remind me of those characters. Still, none of them are as angry as Kenny XD
Cold blooded murder is not justifiable and Kenny was getting way too comfortable with it if you ask me.
Rick bit someone's throat out to protect Carl... if someone even hinted toward hurting Carl or Judith, I would not want to be close to Rick at that time.
I agree. Joel, Rick, and Kenny all know whats need to be done and they do it, despite some people will hate it.
You think him killing Jane needed to be done?
i bet you think we are talking about tv rick lol comic rick is very much like kenny in terms of when he gets mad tv rick is nothing compared to comic rick
Yup. She was a manipulating bitch who left a baby in a car with an open window in the winter with walkers outside. She might have cared about Clem for a while, but if it was a choice between her own life and Clem's, I highly believe she would have left Clem in a heartbeat.
Well, I disagree with you. I dont think any of that is any reason to stab her to death without even listening to her explanation. I also think that the she has shown that she cared about Clem by coming back and has formed an attachment to her. I think between that and losing Luke, she had changed from that cold, self-protective person she was.
If Rick would first heard that something happened to Carl then he definitely would beat a man responsible to the death. Kenny really cares about Clem and AJ and it isn't up to the debate. If someone hurt them then he/she is going to end up dead. Same with Rick about Carl because if I remember correctly then Rick once said that he's willing to do anything, anything to protect people close to him, especially his son Carl.
Yeah.
Even Kenny said that he can be a real ******* sometimes but I know what you mean. Kenny cares about Clem and AJ as much as Rick about Carl or Joel about Ellie. They're similiar characters not the same, of course but still similiar. 
Well, imagine Rick or Joel were going fucking crazy and singlehandedly destroyed the group with their selfishness and stubbornness. And someone, who deeply cared about Carl, stayed behind to show them the dangers they were facing.
Maybe so but put yourself in the position of the man who lost EVERYTHING. He lost his family, his friends (Lee for example), other people that he cared about as much (Sarita) and all that remains (xd) for him is Clementine and little AJ now. So like I said put yourself in his shoes - he lost everything and he see that Jane is next to him without the baby so he thinks something happened to him. I also thought that Jane really abandoned AJ (which means he was dead in that moment because what are the chances for such little baby to survive on his own? None). Kenny was angry. Wouldn't you be?
I'm not saying that what he did was good or bad. People just do crazy things sometimes. I also like Kenny but in the first moment I wanted to shot him. I couldn't do it, When I was going to shot him I just couldn't click this stupid button so just before time for choice ended I clicked "look away". I just couldn't shot Kenny. I'm glad that I didn't though because I like my ending with Kenny more than others.
She stabbed Kenny at the stomach.She could've said that AJ was ok when kenny was about to kill her but no,she was too selfish and she'd rather die than seeing clem still being with Kenny.Sick..Kenny wasnt good either,he should've listened to her but it was impossible.I thought Jane let the baby for the walkers so she can get away.I'd kill someone for doing something like that
There was no explanation to be heard. She was trying to challenge Kenny to a death match. She got her wish. In my playthrough she also got her wish when she asked me to stay out of it no matter what. I did, she died, and then I found out she was a manipulative psycho.
Ah yes, your name just reminded me. Kenny, Rick and Joel all have beards.
Lee also had beard. Coincidence? I don't think so!
Oh so I guess that a reason to kill makes it alright? No it doesn't! Kenny had no right whatsoever to choose Jane's fate, neither did Clementine have the right to choose Kenny's fate, although he does agree with Clementine's decision to do so. Jane lied and Kenny got mad at her, we saw what Kenny was capable of, Jane obviously didn't try to get Kenny killed intentionally, Jane may have hid the baby, but she didn't kill the baby, she doesn't even state whether she did so or not, all she said was that she didn't kill the baby and that it was an accident, her lies contained the truth, Jane may be guilty for her actions, but Kenny is too. The thing is that Jane DIDN'T kill the baby, it was only implied that something happened to the baby, you can't say what Rick or Joel would do since they have never truly been in a situation like this one. Also, how exactly can we blame Jane if we haven't lived through life the same exact way she did it, if we saw the situation in Jane's perspective, some opinions would change.
Does anyone remember that Joel possibly killed the last possible saviors of humanity (the brain surgeons who were about to cure humanity) when they were about to operate on Ellie? And some people are comparing Kenny to him for killing Jane for wanting to fight him in a death match, and she lost.
Yep. I'm done.
So was Jane. She slashed him across the stomach for fuck's sake. She had no qualms about murdering him.
It was Jane or Kenny. I stayed with Kenny.
You can literally tell who has Clementine's well being as a high priority depending on who you save. If you decide to leave Jane she'll bawl and confess she needs you for whatever BS and selfish reason.
While if you decide to leave Kenny he'll understand and will tell you how right you are. Whatever you do next is for the best and he just wants what's best for you. ALSO HUG!.
i think he is talking about comic rick because that rick has done worst shit than kenny when someone like carl was threatened
She taunted an unstable man who lost everything he had and SHE KNEW IT by making him believe AJ was dead. One of the two people Kenny cares about the most!. She intentionally planned all of this to prove that a broken man is indeed broken.
Way to go Jane!.
She got what she deserved for being a lying, manipulative, disgusting person. A knife in the chest.
At what point does Kenny treat murder a game?
Jane lost everything she had too, everyone has lost the people they loved, Jane never actually said AJ was dead, she may have implied it but she even said that she DIDN'T kill AJ, Kenny accused her for killing the baby when she didn't(it was at least obvious for me that Jane was hiding the baby). She didn't intentionally try to kill Kenny, her intention was to convince Clementine to leave with her and not with Kenny, she obviously knew what she had done and that she didn't truly mean to get Kenny killed. So what if she lied? Most of the characters have lied, does that mean they deserve to die? Allot of characters manipulated others, does that mean they deserve to die? Anyone who resorts to killing a living being is disgusting, but do they still have to die for that? All of these traits are similar to many other characters, including determinantly Clementine AND Lee, Kenny himself has lied, used manipulative tactics and did disgusting things, so I guess he deserves a knife in the chest too... Kenny and Jane caused each others deaths, Clementine was in the middle of their feud.
So he's an angry, middle-aged white guy who does lots of shitty things but gets love from fans because he's never wrong?
Sounds about right.
So much wrong with your comment. Rick wouldn't have killed Jane? The fuck? Have you read the comics? Also Kenny didn't know that she didn't kill it, she tried to provoke him... Rick has beaten people to a bloody pulp infront of his people, he bit a bandit's throat because he tried to rape Carl, he tried to fight Negan WITH ONE ARM, infront of all the armed Saviors. Yup, sounds like Kenny.
Well, he was attacking her.
Yeah, I would be angry but when Clementine told me to listen to the explanation, I wouldn't shove her to the ground so I could keep trying to attack Jane. I would listen and try to understand what happened. After that, we'd see what happened but Kenny was just in a murderous rage at that point.
I seriously doubt she'd rather die than see Clem with Kenny. She was fighting pretty hard for her own life. And Kenny said himself he wasn't going to listen and he wasn't backing down. I dont think this was a great plan on her part, it was dangerous to everyone involved but she did prove her point. Kenny's rage was overcoming him. He had very little control over himself at this point.
I still prefer Jane.
I think there was an explanation to be heard since the baby wasn't actually dead. He might have found that out if he'd stood down.
I didnt choose any of those so I cant comment.
She was as much in that fight. She provoked it, she brought the knife in, she refused when Clem told her to run. She got to finish that fight and that ended up with her dead.
She said it was an accident. But Kenny came to the conclusion that the survivalist decided the baby was dead-weight at the best opportune time.