Choices that you're suprised the majority made

1246

Comments

  • edited September 2014

    Yesterday I played S1 E1 and only 30 % saved Duck, I mean WTF!

  • Nothing good ever comes from lying in these games... Except for lying about not having any weapons when confronting the stranger.

    OzzyUK posted: »

    In 400 days i'm surprised most people lied to Leland, to me it seemed more logical to be honest with him.

  • I just thought she'd be able to pick the damn berries by herself ;-; guess i overestimated her...

    DoubleJump posted: »

    I've seen stats in my game where people just didn't bother helping out Sarah at all (at the cabin and Carver's camp). I mean c'mon Clem needs a friend and Sarah seemed nice.

  • edited September 2014

    How in the hell does a 15 year old not know how to pick berries? God, anyone can take cutters and cut them and order them.

    (I still helped her though)

    That1Guy posted: »

    I just thought she'd be able to pick the damn berries by herself ;-; guess i overestimated her...

  • 75% of Doug is loveless.

    dojo32161 posted: »

    I was surprised that barely anyone saved Doug. TeamDoug

  • I know she was freaking out at the time but still! She even eventually did get to doing it, but she cut off live branches! I still feel bad for not helping her but come on! ;-;

    bloop posted: »

    How in the hell does a 15 year old not know how to pick berries? God, anyone can take cutters and cut them and order them. (I still helped her though)

  • People are trying different thangs. And take comfort in the fact that the initial percentages of the first week or so are immortalized on the wikia page.

    Yesterday I played S1 E1 and only 30 % saved Duck, I mean WTF!

  • It's not that hard to tell live branches from dead branches.

    That1Guy posted: »

    I know she was freaking out at the time but still! She even eventually did get to doing it, but she cut off live branches! I still feel bad for not helping her but come on! ;-;

  • about 80% or so of the players cutting Sarita's arm off.

    People thought she was gonna generate a new arm or something xD

  • edited September 2014

    I'm surprised that most people left the girl in the street to suffer and die. Is it because she was bit?

  • The Carly/Doug choice was made to heavily favor Carly. Didn't like Telltale admit that?

    dojo32161 posted: »

    I was surprised that barely anyone saved Doug. TeamDoug

  • Cutting Sarita's arm in the middle of zombie herd.

  • Not at all, telltale intended for it to be a 50/50 choice, thinking a good bit more people would choose Doug, they then discussed it and regret not giving the player more reason to save Doug.

    remorse667 posted: »

    The Carly/Doug choice was made to heavily favor Carly. Didn't like Telltale admit that?

  • She was beyond help and the people I was trying to help were not. I felt I had enobled her last moments by giving her death a purpose (diversion.)

    bloop posted: »

    I'm surprised that most people left the girl in the street to suffer and die. Is it because she was bit?

  • The decision to chop Lee's arm off or not, Not suprised the majority of people went with the chop off option and the statistic always seems to favour that decision. Everytime i came across that choice in my playthrough's i always clung to the false hope that Lee would survive regardless of knowing chopping it off would be in vain. I just didn't want the legend to die and leave poor Clementine alone, I guess people must feel the same.

  • It's basically what Lee said, ''Even if it just slows down the process, i'd be happy.''

    xClementine posted: »

    The decision to chop Lee's arm off or not, Not suprised the majority of people went with the chop off option and the statistic always seems

  • True, but i just really wanted him to survive it. :)

  • I think she just couldn't hear Reggie's instructions over all the shock and anxiety that was flooding her mind

    That1Guy posted: »

    I know she was freaking out at the time but still! She even eventually did get to doing it, but she cut off live branches! I still feel bad for not helping her but come on! ;-;

  • After looking at the Doug infographic above, I'm not surprised I was one of the few to feed Ben. It wasn't a popular decision. I'm not that surprised more people fed Larry than I expected. Between the pro-Larry camp that I'll never fully understand, and people like me, who figured the elderly man probably needs it most, it adds up. I was fairly surprised only 19 of 20 fed Duck, but that's almost all of us.

    But the big surprise, even though its the most decisive margin I've seen TTG keep track of, is that some people, any people, didn't feed Clementine! Who didn't feed Clem? Why not? I'm genuinely asking. Please explain.

  • In my badass Lee playthrough I didn't feed Clem. And I always give Larry the apple, though it's not the best choice to fix the relationship, because I think being on diet is better for his heart condition.

    After looking at the Doug infographic above, I'm not surprised I was one of the few to feed Ben. It wasn't a popular decision. I'm not that

  • edited September 2014

    Lol. I always feed Larry, too, because its the noble thing to do. With an inner cringe, every time. And he's a horse's ass about it, every time.

    But I can always take solace in the fact that in a few days, crushing his crotchety old carcass with a 200 lb block of compressed salt will be the noble thing to do.

    24601 posted: »

    In my badass Lee playthrough I didn't feed Clem. And I always give Larry the apple, though it's not the best choice to fix the relationship, because I think being on diet is better for his heart condition.

  • edited September 2014

    Sorry replied the wrong comment

    24601 posted: »

    I mean that objectively Lee can get more benefit from Carley than from Doug... But Jesus, I really like that guy. I can't stop shipping Douley...

  • I still don't see how some people can hate Sarah so much

    DoubleJump posted: »

    I've seen stats in my game where people just didn't bother helping out Sarah at all (at the cabin and Carver's camp). I mean c'mon Clem needs a friend and Sarah seemed nice.

  • She was dead already but i think it was cause it would make more noise and give you less tim to get the supplies (which in the end don't even matter). Is hot her, i thought it was the right thing to do.

    bloop posted: »

    I'm surprised that most people left the girl in the street to suffer and die. Is it because she was bit?

  • k

    ps3gamer095 posted: »

    Sorry replied the wrong comment

  • SUPER MEGA ULTRA MOTHERFUCKING K

    i know you'll reply with k, or wont's reply at all

    k

  • I was surprised with how many people watched Kenny kill Carver.

    I watched a video later, but for my playthrough there was no way I wanted Clem to see him beat dead like that. I did tell Luke to shoot him though :)

  • k

    ps3gamer095 posted: »

    SUPER MEGA ULTRA MOTHERFUCKING K i know you'll reply with k, or wont's reply at all

  • I helped kenny dispatch larry, but it was without question the most difficult decision of the 2 series combined, it really screwed my head up that one....

    I think it was the fact that I thought i hated his guts, but when it came to it ........ it was a lot harder than I expected, in all fairness, I think most of the head fuck was lilly and not larry, it wasnt easy watching her...... very well acted by lilly..

    But Larry was a hulk in human form I couldn't risk him turning in there, especially with clem in there also, saltlick it was.....

  • just wondering whats "badass" about not feeding children, dont you mean "Asshole"

    24601 posted: »

    In my badass Lee playthrough I didn't feed Clem. And I always give Larry the apple, though it's not the best choice to fix the relationship, because I think being on diet is better for his heart condition.

  • Yeah! You get it right. This Lee is trying to do whatever he could to get hate.

    just wondering whats "badass" about not feeding children, dont you mean "Asshole"

  • ahh, okay, most people who do that, call it their "asshole" playtrough

    24601 posted: »

    Yeah! You get it right. This Lee is trying to do whatever he could to get hate.

  • Now I'm curious, 24601. Who did you decide would make you the biggest jerk to feed? You can't eat more than one thing yourself, can you? I don't think I've ever fed myself, so i wouldn't know

    ahh, okay, most people who do that, call it their "asshole" playtrough

  • Unfortunately, these don't take into consideration how many people offered Doug the right fuckin' piece of food for him to accept. There is no percentage indicating how many people offered Doug something that wasn't a part of his apocalyptic slim-up-quick diet. Those are the kind of statistics we need: how many of the people who chose X also chose X. Example: percentage of the people who chose to show the bite actually let anybody come with them. Or percentage of the people who chose to watch Carver die also tried to get Kenny to stop whaling on Arvo.

    Seriously Doug, if you want the fucking apple, then take the fucking apple, I still fucking have it.

    dojo32161 posted: »

    I was surprised that barely anyone saved Doug. TeamDoug

  • edited September 2014

    Ben, Doug/Carley (he or she WON'T be angry WITHOUT food), Lilly (if you didn't side with her when she was arguing with Kenny she will say that it doesn't change anything), Lee

    After that Kenny and Larry will be mad at you. Mark will look at you with sad eyes. I can't remember exactly, but it seems that Clem will also get a sad face and tell you that she's very hungry.

    PS. It's actually a job more difficult than pleasing every side.

    Now I'm curious, 24601. Who did you decide would make you the biggest jerk to feed? You can't eat more than one thing yourself, can you? I don't think I've ever fed myself, so i wouldn't know

  • Seems that way. I'm already confused. Doesn't siding with Lilly and Larry make you the WAY bigger asshole?

    Hold up, I figured it out while I was writing, I think. That conversation is your best chance to really good and piss those two off, but Kenny you can piss off all season at the drop of a hat by as little as not immediately backing his every questionable stance. Is that it?

    24601 posted: »

    Ben, Doug/Carley (he or she WON'T be angry WITHOUT food), Lilly (if you didn't side with her when she was arguing with Kenny she will say th

  • edited September 2014

    Er... sorry but I don't know why siding with Lilly can make Lee a bigger asshole... For example, my asshole Lee helped kill Larry. I know that it will get Kenny's side, but I think it's more important for an asshole to hurt little girl Clememtine...

    Seems that way. I'm already confused. Doesn't siding with Lilly and Larry make you the WAY bigger asshole? Hold up, I figured it out whil

  • edited September 2014

    Well, becuase arguing to throw Duck to the walkers right in front of his parents is pretty gulderned indefensible. Like always feeding Larry and the kids, I can never bring myself to be all, "Yeah! Boot that litlle bastard! He ain't MY kid. Who gives a crap what happens to him?" which is essentially Larry's stance.

    24601 posted: »

    Er... sorry but I don't know why siding with Lilly can make Lee a bigger asshole... For example, my asshole Lee helped kill Larry. I know that it will get Kenny's side, but I think it's more important for an asshole to hurt little girl Clememtine...

  • edited September 2014

    <=======

    I like Duck too much for that. Plus, its evil.

    Well, becuase arguing to throw Duck to the walkers right in front of his parents is pretty gulderned indefensible. Like always feeding Larry

  • 1st, I don't think siding with Lilly means that you have to agree with everything Larry raises. 2nd, sorry that I can't get all your meanings due to the grammar...I'm not a native English speaker so I can't understand it when it's too colloquial.

    Well, becuase arguing to throw Duck to the walkers right in front of his parents is pretty gulderned indefensible. Like always feeding Larry

Sign in to comment in this discussion.