Who do you feel safer with? Kenny or Jane

If you were actually Clementine, who would you feel safer with and to hold your back?

Kenny
or
Jane

«134

Comments

  • Kenny because he hasn't abandoned Clem. Hasn't used the kid as a weapon and actually wants the best for Clementine. Jane just wants to use you as a substitute sister.

  • If i was CLementine, i'm going forever alone.

    Anthorn posted: »

    Kenny because he hasn't abandoned Clem. Hasn't used the kid as a weapon and actually wants the best for Clementine. Jane just wants to use you as a substitute sister.

  • Neither. Both of them are detriments to Clementine's survival in the long run, and if it were up to me I would have left them as I cannot find it in myself to trust them to watch out for the group without stirring up needless drama.

  • edited July 2015

    Jane's more mentally stable and knows how to survive through extremely dire situations like Walker herds so i'd say her. If I was at Wellington because of Kenny then i'd pick him since i'm safe and not alone with him, but on my own with Kenny in the wild? Yeah no.

  • Anthorn posted: »

    Kenny because he hasn't abandoned Clem. Hasn't used the kid as a weapon and actually wants the best for Clementine. Jane just wants to use you as a substitute sister.

  • Kenny cause all he is trying to do is to keep Clem and AJ safe. Jane put Clem in danger a lot.

  • Kenny gets you to wellington which ensures safety

    RichWalk23 posted: »

    Neither. Both of them are detriments to Clementine's survival in the long run, and if it were up to me I would have left them as I cannot find it in myself to trust them to watch out for the group without stirring up needless drama.

  • I feel safer with both of them dead, their reanimated bodies freezing in the snow

  • I'd feel safest in Wellington.

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator

    Anyone but Kenny.

  • edited July 2015

    "...." because silence is a valid option.lol I say Clementine is in good hands with Kenny just like Allstate. Because ya know..you Gotta keep away from mayhem.... like Jane.

    Honestly in truth I could see Jane actually leaving/ditching Clementine and AJ to their death as walker bait, only to escape being trapped with a horde of zombies herself, if it came to that..as such a extreme life or death situation and as the stone-cold hardcore survivalist she is. Yeah she'll likely feel awful and guilty, then get over it.. being the cold loner type and all which would just make her even colder. This would be an interesting approach should they actually decide to shockingly kill Clementine off midway into season 3.. to show the possibly horrendous consequences of the Jane finale followers. But I see the exact opposite as opposed to Kenny whom may not think twice to lay down his life, especially if it meant to save the lives of Clementine and AJ. Perhaps some can simply take from that whom Clem is safer with in the long-run.

    Time and again we have seen Ken's sacrifice of his life or at least put it down on the line for loved ones and others of the group and even those he has hated with the likes of Ben, Larry and Lilly. ( I guess if you count scavenging for supplies with Lee in ep.3 of S1 and kind of helping Larry find heart pills after getting into a brawl with him). Only person he couldn't forgive was Carver I would obviously suppose since he killed Carver brutally which was actually kind of a fitting end for such a brute.

    I must add that Carver's in-game fate was about one of the very few things I could applaud TTG for with Season 2. But back on track,.. Kenny and Jane like mostly everyone else in the game.. cares about Clementine's well being. But even so I'd say with no doubt that Clem is safer with Ken than Jane. Even Carver was a tad fond of her and his awful sidekick Troy saved her life as well, in spite of them both roughing her up a bit.

    But ya know perhaps Clementine is not safe at all no matter who she is with.. from the notorious R.Kirkman and highly dangerous Telltale storyboard writers. :D

  • edited July 2015

    Jane, without a doubt. I can understand why some people dislike her over the AJ incident, but you can't expect people to make the right decisions all the time, that's just not how life works, and I can't see her putting Clem in harm's way more times than Kenny; who can make a bad situation happen a lot faster than Jane. She's a loner, a survivalist, and cares deeply for Clem (you don't soften yourself up to just anybody if you've been hardened, and closed that part of you off); as Kenny does, too. There's no debate on that: they both care for Clem.

    Kenny has some good qualities, I won't pretend otherwise, but he's a loose cannon, which can be dangerous. Disagree with him once, and all of the sudden, you're the bad guy. Season 1, Larry in the meat locker, anybody? It's his way or the highway, and I'm a natural loner, so I can better relate to Jane. I try to play my Clem that way if the option allows it. So, like I said: Jane, without a doubt.

  • Neither. I feel like Jane will eventually leave Clementine and A.J, and Kenny is just crazy. I went with the alone ending, because I honestly don't believe staying with them is safe. I still believe leaving with Bonnie and Mike should've been an option even though I hated them. But I definitely feel much more safer with them rather than staying with Kenny or Jane.

  • Both have their ups and downs. Kenny, while mentally unstable, has proven he will do anything to protect the people he cares about, and while Jane is more mentally capable of keeping a group safe, she has shown that she is more interested in saving herself than helping others. With that being said, I'd go with Kenny.

  • Even Satan himself?

    dojo32161 posted: »

    Anyone but Kenny.

  • Even Carver was a tad fond of her and Troy saved her life in spite of them both roughing her up a bit.

    Lol what on earth are you talking about? Who ever said Carver was fond of her or that Troy and Carver roughed her up? What?? This is just flat out false.

    Ladariel posted: »

    "...." because silence is a valid option.lol I say Clementine is in good hands with Kenny just like Allstate. Because ya know..you Gotta kee

  • I just know I'm not choosing the Jane ending ever again, I don't care how "good" her intentions were, you do NOT endanger a helpless baby like that. For all his flaws, I can't see Kenny doing something as awful as that. Clementine would definitely be safer with Kenny, and in Wellington.

  • Kenny, he would do anything for his family.

  • edited July 2015

    Well...LOL I'm only talking about episode 3 LOL In Harms Way dear LOL.. But anyhow.. I noticed you left out that essential key adjective tad, You even copy and pasted what I said yet rewrite it differently to imply I'm saying Carver loved and adored Clem as if she was his granddaughter, rather than just minimally liked her ways or admired her strong spunky attitude. Which I'm pretty much just referring to that little principal office scene with her and Carver talking about how it falls to the strong tough minded people like the two of them to lead their group to safety, with Alvin beaten half to death in bad shape off to the side of their conversation.

    In addition yes Troy and Carver did rough her up a bit. Perhaps not as badly as some other folks of the group but Carver (dependent on your response to him back hands Clem to the dirt at the beginning of ep.3 for being sassy or smart.. he said something like "you don't want to don't test me, I'll pass every-time" Also in episode 2 Carver i think elbows or punches Clem in the stomach/chest/abdomen or whatever for her courageous yet vain attempts to help rescue someone in her group at the Lodge. and Troy dependent on your response punches/smacks her across the face in that small comic shop then palms her by the back of the neck and shoves her around.. not to mention butting her in the cheek with the end of his rifle for trying to help Kenny in his beat down. But at least Troy does rescue Clem from one walker.

    P.S. I know most say episode 3 sucked but perhaps it'd do your information some good to replay just that entire episode again..

    sialark posted: »

    Even Carver was a tad fond of her and Troy saved her life in spite of them both roughing her up a bit. Lol what on earth are you tal

  • Lolol omg never mind I just completely read that wrong. xp I thought you had meant that Carver was fond of Jane and that Carver and Troy had roughed up Jane lol never miiind. xp And I do remember that stuff happening with Clem lol, my bad.

    Also I very much disagree with you on Jane abandoning Clem and AJ. It's not going to happen again; it's just plain not. I trust her; there's not really anything that makes me think she'll want to abandon Clem again. Jane's been showing as the season progresses that she has more and more faith in others, and that she'll help people in need or give them a chance rather than abandon them.

    This would be a interesting approach should they actually decide to kill Clementine off midway into season 3 to show horrendous consequences of the Jane finale followers.

    That's kind of harsh of you to imply. Are you suggesting that those who got a season 2 Jane ending will find halfway through the season that they chose the "wrong" season 2 ending? Because that's ridiculous.

    Ladariel posted: »

    Well...LOL I'm only talking about episode 3 LOL In Harms Way dear LOL.. But anyhow.. I noticed you left out that essential key adjective tad

  • edited July 2015

    It's true Kenny would do anything for his family. Just make sure you're always in his family and never do anything that he disagrees with, or he'll yell obscenities at you and abandon you in a walker herd right after traumatizing you, is all (remember after Sarita's death?). Also even if he considers you his family, you'd have to witness all the probably innocent people he'd probably end up maiming or killing to "protect his family at all costs" I'm sure.

    Kenny's main flaw was his anger and his violent ways. Jane's main flaw was how she didn't want to trust people or be in a group to begin with. By the end of the season, Jane has shown she can change in terms of her flaw. She comes back for the group; she saves Clem from the ice; she lets the family in at Howe's. Kenny however didn't show any change in his flaw. In his endings he shows he still cares about Clem and AJ yes, but he doesn't show any signs of bettering his anger management. If they'd shown him trying to control it through the season, e.g. Sarita suggesting he should watch his temper, Kenny counting to ten or taking deep breaths, and if this had actually worked for him at some point then that would've been great. But it didn't. And so I'm still worried Kenny will still see red again and kill people over misunderstandings in the future because frankly he hasn't proven that he can control his anger or his violent ways at all. Hence, I don't trust him, and will always go with Jane. ^_^

  • Kenny. Jane just gonna make me worry too much.

  • Wellington lol

  • How do we know that Wellington is safe? We haven't even got the chance to look inside and see for ourselves before the game ends.

    Miny77 posted: »

    Kenny gets you to wellington which ensures safety

  • Kenny. I trust him and I know he'd never let anyone hurt Clementine. Kenny is my family, and I'm with him until the end.

  • Kenny. I know he has many flaws, he's unstable and his methods might look as cruel but at the same time I know that all he really wants is to keep his family safe. Yes, his real family is dead but.. let's look on this sitation from this perspective - Kenny is like Morgan. Not exactly, just hear me out. Both man lost everyone they knew and cared about. Rick is the only person still alive that Morgan knows and he traveled across few states to find him. Clementine is the only person still alive that Kenny knows and really trust. He was with her and Lee at the beginning. After he lost his family Kenny was an the edge and I think there were moments when he considered taking an easy way out if you know what I'm talking about. Then Sarita found him and he found a purpose to stay alive and try to keep going. Then he met Clementine but not long after that we know what happened and he was again in this dark place and he probably wanted to die a few times. Yet again, he found a purpose not to and it was Clementine. The only person still alive that he knows, trusts and care about deeply.

    Long story short - I'd feel safer with Kenny. His methods may seem brutal and all but at the same time I know that he only wants what's best for Clem and AJ. Jane left us and she even wanted to left AJ because "Kenny would never let him go." She always was worried that Clementine would get too attached to AJ and in her eyes it wasn't a good idea.

  • That Wellington ending was too convenient. Solo is the best way for Clementine to develop herself until she finds a decent group that doesn't start shit.

    Miny77 posted: »

    Kenny gets you to wellington which ensures safety

  • Jane, probably more emotionally stable and that's saying a lot during a zombie apocalypse. Also less prone to murder rampages, haha.

  • THIS.

    The biggest difference between Kenny and Jane in the final episode is that Jane shows she is at least capable of overcoming her flaws, whereas whether Kenny can is still a massive question mark.

    sialark posted: »

    It's true Kenny would do anything for his family. Just make sure you're always in his family and never do anything that he disagrees with, o

  • If it wasnt safe why would they be so strict on security and supplies? They obviously try to protect themselves and make sure everyone has enough inside - a place which doesnt care about that would just let anyone in.

    RichWalk23 posted: »

    How do we know that Wellington is safe? We haven't even got the chance to look inside and see for ourselves before the game ends.

  • Considering that they're happy to give out supplies to wandering strangers they refuse to let in, that doesn't really sound strict and secure on their own supplies to me.

    And if they do take Clementine and AJ in, why is one extra person not allowed? This seem to imply that either Wellington is very overcrowded and the amount of people will be a huge drain on their resources, and that's not even counting the part where they'll give away their own supplies to strangers, or they're incredibly strict on the amount of people staying in the place to the point where they'll split visiting groups apart from each other and cause emotional problems in the future.

    Miny77 posted: »

    If it wasnt safe why would they be so strict on security and supplies? They obviously try to protect themselves and make sure everyone has enough inside - a place which doesnt care about that would just let anyone in.

  • edited July 2015

    Kenny, Kenny thinks alot more than just himself. He thinks about family and the things he cares about aka Clem and AJ (All that he really has left) The ending and how he wanted to go to Weligton (A long term solution) Showed he wants Clem and AJ to be safe because his life is all about them. Kenny does anything to keep his family and group alive, Now why not go with Jane? Left a baby in a car to prove a point. nearly got are entire group killed by threatening arvo even if I didn't take his meds. So yeah Id go with Kenny. I understand if people go with Jane but for me? Id go with Kenny, that dude will literally die for Clem and AJ, its all he has left. But if you went with Jane and you hate Kenny I'd understand, everyone played the game differently. EDIT: Also Kenny is loyal, Jane already left us once and left AJ in a car. Kennys loyal and weather you hate him or not you cant deny that.

  • They would only give one, refusing to give another and even states because they have to think of THOSE INSIDE first, the woman broke that rule by giving them a second. That might also imply they have a rather big supply but dont want to over do it. You're right, they wouldnt give it away if they were TOO limited - thus obviously they werent.

    No, that implies that its bordering on over populated. They're aware of their own limits and keep it there to make sure they DONT go over. They didnt turn them all away, they turned just kenny because she knew they could still take her and the baby.

    RichWalk23 posted: »

    Considering that they're happy to give out supplies to wandering strangers they refuse to let in, that doesn't really sound strict and secur

  • To be fair, Kenny put Clem In Harms Way (No episode pun intended) Just as much as Jane.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Kenny cause all he is trying to do is to keep Clem and AJ safe. Jane put Clem in danger a lot.

  • But yes, Kenny is trying really hard to Protect her, and I appriciate that of him. He's a cool dude in the end. I just feel he's coming unhinged.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Kenny cause all he is trying to do is to keep Clem and AJ safe. Jane put Clem in danger a lot.

  • That... Is one way to do it...

    Clemenem posted: »

    I feel safer with both of them dead, their reanimated bodies freezing in the snow

  • THIS. This is the answer to the entire Flame war, And nobody wants to hear it. RyGuy, You have all the answers. XD

    theRyGuy posted: »

    Jane, without a doubt. I can understand why some people dislike her over the AJ incident, but you can't expect people to make the right deci

Sign in to comment in this discussion.