I think ***** was the one that died.
I think Negan killed Daryl. These are my clues:
- It definitely wasn't Rick or Carl, because of what Negan said. "Anybody moves, anybody says anything, cut the boy's other eye out and feed it to his father, and THEN we'll start.
- It wasn't any of the women, because he loves women, or he at least dosen't allow rape.
- If it was Glenn, Maggie woulda said something RIGHT AWAY.
- If it was Abraham, Sasha woulda said something because they formed a relationship.
- If it was Eugene, he wouldn't "take it like a champ", according to what Negan said.
- I think Daryl woulda taken it more like a champ than Aaron (Aaron was barely scared of Negan waving Lucille at him)
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
There's a better chance of them ending the whole show then Daryl dying ever. Don't know why people buy into it. The POV shows a clear view of Negan (Daryl's hair comes down to his eyes). It also shows someone to the right side of Carl. Daryl is safe.
The one that was to the right of Carl was Aaron. So you think Aaron was it?
I thought it was Daryl but then if they kill Daryl off fangirls will start a riot and whatnot and Aaron isn't a MAIN main if you get what I'm saying so it's probably Aaron.
It's most likely Daryl or Aaron. Hopefully Aaron.
I've narrowed it down to Maggie, Daryl and Glenn. It can't be Rick or Carl because of what you said above, they wouldn't give the legendary death to Aaron, Sasha, Rosita or Abraham unless Gimple was stupid, Eugene has just started to develop, so it has to be one of those 3.
Maggie - My chips are on Maggie because she's finally blossoming into a leader and a fighter. Her character has made a huge growth this season, but with the baby that's clearly having problems and Negan already breaking his rule in the comics and killing a kid (as mentioned in Season 6 Episode 11 by the returning Hilltop survivors), there will be plenty of a chance for Negan to take out Maggie, especially since Glenn has shown his love for her and how important she is to him. He'd love to break Glenn's mind, I'm sure.
Daryl - He's got 2 new shows and a movie coming up, he's a legendary character, He'd fight back if he got the shit beaten out of him (See Season 2 Episode 5 for an example) which would fit with the "Taking it like a champ" line, as you've mentioned, and if they were ever gonna kill him off, this is the only way they would do it. The next shot at him having a worth while death would be the decapitation involving the deaths of Rosita, Ezekiel and others when Alpha comes into the picture. But that probably won't be for several seasons. This is the only chance Daryl has at death.
Glenn - It's kind of his death. The only reason they'd do it is to pay homage to the comic books.
I think the reason they didn't show any hair is because it'd be way too easy if they made a realistic point of view. No other characters can really be seen and no features of a character can either. It helps with the mystery so nobody cracks the case too early. If it were an accurate POV shot, we'd be able to see the bridge of the character's nose in his eyeshot. It's easy to see. Plus, blood doesn't flow that easily in real life either. Although I don't know why I'm comparing a show about zombies taking over the world to real life logic.
at first
after reading
when are people gonna realize that the taking it like a champ line means nothing? they are just taking it straight from the comic if we are going by this logic then i would have never expected the guy negan killed in the comic to take it like a champ
anyway i have this feeling that it will be either glenn, daryl or abraham
Not sure what the second meme is supposed to be.
Aaron is great, one of the few good-hearted people, dont know why you want him to die. Or maybe you meant that if it has to be one of these 2 you would choose him. Just sounded like you dislike him. If I had to choose someone I would choose Rosita, so far we never really get to know her, she dont really has much of a personality imo. But I think its Eugene, one thing I recognized is Negans shadow in Ricks face. He walks to the right side where Sasha, Aaron and Eugene are. And seconds later he has chosen someone. If this scene is logically elapsed it has to be one of these 3.
Well i think its anyone other than Rick & Carl like you said. What hes saying wouldnt add up if he killed them.
Also Rick & Carl are very important to the story. Without them large chunks would be missing. I'm very excited to see Carl in season 7.
Most likely Daryl, but it's still all speculation!
It's Aaron but I don't have a evidence. And Im 100% confidently sure its him.
I think it's either Glenn or Daryl.
I don't WANT Aaron to die, but better him than Daryl.
Sorry just sounded like you dislike Aaron and I was curios why
Dem low standards for loving women :P
I think it'd be a very bad move if it was Aaron. It should be someone from seasons 1, 2 or maybe three. The whole point of the scene was to introduce Negan by brutally killing someone who's been around for ages, to show no-one is safe now.
I wouldn't be too sure about that since TV Show characters don't always match up to their Comic counterparts, especially with how different TV Show Governor was portrayed as in comparison to the original character, so the TV Show Negan may not be 100% identical to Comic Negan.
I'll admit that it's a baseless theory, though.
I don't think it was Daryl. They already cliffhangered him in the previous, twice is just not right, it would just make that cliffhanger at the end of Ep 15 pointless. Besides, he was already wounded. Would Negan kill a wounded person?
Exactly! That's what I've been telling people since the finale! It should only be Glenn or Daryl, Maggie has too much development left and Michonne needs to meet Ezekiel. It isn't Rick or Carl because that's obvious. Sasha, Aaron, Rosita or Eugene wouldn't be a sad enough death to hit the viewers. MAYBE Abraham but Kirkman said he wants him to live until 'All Out War' so that's unlikely.
Aaron would be an awful choice, probably the worst choice actually.
Calling up AMC for if they do that bullshit
Well, we ARE talking about Negan :P
I so want darryl to bite the dust, please kill his pansy ass character for GOOD.
Maggie getting executed by Lucille would have the highest emotional impact for Glenn and could put him at odds with Rick and Daryl possibly. Creating an interesting inner side conflict story with the group.
Think Kirkman may had mentioned something about this happening in the comic once but scraped the idea.
Then that would have made Maggie's pregnancy pointless.
Exactly.
Yah well ya know not each and every event, detail and action in the show, game, or comic has to have some william shakespearean purpose or motive every time.. which has been demonstrated time and again by the writers of all 3 medias. The show is supposedly to be remixed quite a bit differently from the comic.. yet not drastically different from the storyline. And in the show the point might be to make the Lucille death that much more shocking and horrifying. TV Negan would know nothing of the pregnancy and if he wouldn't consider offing Maggie or any of the women then why even include the females in the line up? Is that not a pointless move as you call it in and of itself? Lori and Judith died by Lilly (from telltale) j/k. at the command of the Governor. Doesn't mean Lori having the baby in the comic meant nothing. If anything it means Trojans are few and far in between supply runs.lol
Maggie, Glenn, and Daryl each have equal chances of getting it if AMC is going for a hard to watch heartwrenching death.
Rick and Carl are most likely safe along with Michonne while....
And Abraham, Aaron, Sasha, Eugene, Rosita,.etc would be the cheaper kind of cop out deaths. Though some say Abraham but I doubt it since he was willing to sacrifice himself and Kirkman always regretted the death he gave him in the comic and also I've heard he wanted to use Abraham for a much more fitting role in the upcoming All Out War saga.
you do know that they edited the scene and made jump around a million times, right?
Daryl has way too much use for AMC for games, t-shirts, other merchandise.
And based on your "if so and so kills this, then so and so would scream"
Rick and Daryl are like brothers, he'd probably say something too.
They probably edited out all the screams or most of them.
It really looked like Abraham, he was one of the few strong enought to stand up for a shot, the last few episodes give a bit more focus to him then they did before and he is a pretty important character, but I can also see it as being Daryl since he is also strong, and that he is doing some other movies and may need to get out of the series ( also being a stupendously important character ), I don't really think they would do gleen ( even trought that's what happened in the comics ) or Maggie.
Ok, I will think Daryl will die then...
Everyone was screaaming when someone died. Maggie and Abraham screamed Glenn and Carl said No. But Glenn was freaking out. Abraham saw him after the first hit. That is why he screamed for him to stop. Abraham is one of the only people there that could take it like a champ. Also If you didn't notice Daryl had hair in his eyes. The POV didn't. Abraham, Sasha, Aaron, Maggie, and Carl didn't. We already know it is not Carl, Sasha, or Maggie and Aaron is a wimp. So that leaves Abraham.
Actually, I just spotted this. I think Glenn was the one that died now.
enter link description here
I dont know why people are analyzing it so much, when it comes back they could switch everything round
hair in his eyes...
Honestly, I don't think they left any clues and they will probably just pick someone at the last minute.
I'm still not confident they've actually decided. I think they'll retcon where everyone was located and I think it's Glenn in the end.
I hope it wasn't Michonne
I don't agree with your premises 2-4.
Firstly, I don't think it was Daryl as Daryl is just as synonymous with the TV as Rick Grimes. Hell, he's the face of all the TV show related merchandise.
Now, both Maggie and Sasha are strong women. As you pointed out, no one is to make a peep otherwise Carl's good eye gets fed to Rick. With that in mind, Sasha and Maggie wouldn't do anything to endanger Carl.
Agreed. I feel like the show keeps killing off good characters and leaving annoying ones and Daryl is one of the few good ones left. To kill him would be completely and utterly pointless at this point in the show.
Heh, that's funny. Daryl is on my "over-the-top and annoying" list, while a lot of the relatively new ones are in my "interesting and with potential" list.