If you were in Negan's shoes, who would you have killed?
I'd kill Sasha, honestly. She's been absolutely useless ever since Tyreese died. She's also the reason Abraham and Rosita broke up. She's basically Andrea 2.0. Who would you have killed?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Rick probably. Not cause I hate him but because that'd be a really interesting twist.
I wonder who would be the leader, if that happened.
I'd kill Carl. Not that I dislike him, but if I want them to learn, I'll start by showing that I am not going soft on children. If I've learned something in this world, it's that most are really sensitive when it comes to children, even when these children basically act like adults. They're supposed to work for me after, so I won't touch Rick who is supposed to be the leader ( assuming he would work for me after I broke his son's face ), Abraham or Michonne who are confident enough to stare right back at me or Daryl if I have already heard of his skills.
NEGAN! :P
I would kill Rick, because he 'was' the leader and that would give a HUGE moral impact to all of them, as well as de-stablising their community, making it much harder for them to retaliate in some way.
If I was Negan, I wouldn't know that Sasha has been useless and that she's the reason a couple broke up—which I partly disagree with, but that's another debate. With that aside, I think that from his perspective, I'd ask Rick who the second in command is, and Lucille the crap out of them.
From a story-telling perspective, I'd go with Abraham.
Oh yeah. WTF am I thinking?
Glenn and Abraham. If I was Negan I would've had Dwight end Glenn after jumping up like that. He must have a ton of experience at this though("The 1st one's free"). After that, I would've made everyone calm down, and killed Maggie, Daryl, and/or Rick if they couldn't. Then I would do the eeny, menny thing but knowing that I'll land on Abraham. He's too big. He's like a human truck.
Sorry, you can only choose one.
Daryl because it would have the biggest impact
I kinda did. Glenn gets an arrow through the skull via Darryl's bow, and I, as Negan, Lucille Abraham. It's a double whammy. Accept my submission, I command you!
If not then Abraham. Strictly on a 1st impressions type of thing. He showed no fear, while the others were scared shitless. Except for Carl, who looked more pissed than anything.
I would kill Abraham. Daryl would be a great choice b/c he's such a beloved character, but Daryl is just as synonymous with the show as Rick or Michonne. However, I think the show should stick with the comic story and kill Glenn. If they want to have a huge impact w/o killing Glenn or Daryl, a female is the best option. I guess what I'm saying is I have no idea.
All of them
I think Negan made a pretty good example of not being soft on children when he threatened to have Carl's other eye scooped out and fed to his father.
With the one that put on a front the most. Not as in they're just "acting hard", but that this is their general front when it comes to new people.
So either Michonne or Abraham.
Because let's be real, Rick was scared shitless.
Anyone but Rick, purely because Negan explains the 'Martyr' situation. But I'd go with Daryl. It's about control - he needs to break the leader so the whole group falls in line.
Daryl. I wouldn't be so heartless to kill Glenn or Maggie, I wouldn't kill the leader, I wouldn't kill Carl, but Daryl seems like a veteran, someone who's been through a lot of shit and is a beacon of hope for their group. If I wanted to scare them, I'd kill the one guy who gives them the most hope. And after all, killing the unkillable really would make me the Big Swinging Dick, now wouldn't it?
Hey guys, I just spotted this. Would you have preferred this over that bullshit we got?
enter link description here
I would kill Sasha, not because I hate her, I just don't care much about her. I didn't like how Abraham broke Rosita's heart for her (Sasha).
We would do the same thing, for the same reason
So...wouldn't that make it Abraham's fault for breaking Rosita's heart, and not Sasha?
It's both of their faults, but mostly Sasha's.
Mind telling me how it's more Sasha's fault? Did she deliberately allure Abraham away from Rosita, knowing that he was with her, or did Abraham simply ditch Rosita for Sasha?
I've stopped watching the show at early Season 4, so I don't know the full story here.
I would just go on whoever the 'Eeny, meeny, miny, moe' landed on.
Don't get spoiled then
i
?????
what
How is it Sasha's fault that Abraham broke Rosita's heart? Because she existed? That's not how it works.
No, Sasha hasn't been anything but friendly to Abraham. No flirting, nothing sexual at all. She was just around him more because of their shifts, and he started to like her.
I want to be spoiled, that's why I'm asking.
Rick
Considering that Rick's group have killed dozens of saviors, I would have killed most of them, specially Rick. Come on, it's stupid to let people as dangerous as them alive, Negan already know what they are capable of. He is gonna regret killing only one.
Ah, I see.
Sorry, you can only pick one.
Watch the last 2 seasons and you'll get it.
So...Rick?
It'd be easier and faster if you could explain what exactly was going on in the love triangle between Abraham, Rosita, and Sasha.
Watch the show and you'll understand better. IDFK how to explain it in a way you'll understand.
Fair enough, I tried.
Maggie. She has become so annoying please get rid of her.
I'd kill Rick easy. He's the problem in this situation. It's not about taking control but knowing your place. Rick has been thinking he's the shit since he took over Alexandria. Thinking he can kill whoever he wants because his life is more valuable.
And best thing is even if they rise up and somehow stop me, it's not like I'm fighting maniacs anymore. If Abe leads them they'll be an army but an army with more compassion and tactics then I've ever seen in Rick. I'd personally like to see Morgan lead the group as he'd be the most human one and it'd probably flourish the quickest in my opinion.
And Carl losing his dad like that. Would be perfect
Yeah, and guess what? He got it all wrong. He tried to break Rick, and he just made him more determined to bring him down. He tried to break Dwight and, by his own admission, it turned out to be a terrible mistake. Negan's smart, but way over his head. He should've killed Rick and made Spencer the new leader of Alexandria, but he actually did the opposite, and that's what brought him down.