I think I would prefer to know what happened to Lilly over Christa.

Since Lilly from the game is apparently not supposed to be one in the same with the comic's Lilly that shot the Governor's face (although I still like to imagine that it is). Which character's fate would you rather learn about from season 4 before the series wraps up? Christa or Lilly?.... I mean yeah Christa was sort of there and cool but I'd sooner accept that she just got shot in the head in the woods off screen than whatever happened to Lilly on the road which is truly a mystery since she was not ever in the comic unfortunately due to Kirkman and never heard from or seen again. They did this same thing with Molly too but I'd accept her fate before still being clueless of what became of Lilly.

«13

Comments

  • edited October 2017

    Which character's fate would you rather learn about from season 4 before the series wraps up? Christa or Lilly?

    If you mean show up, then Lily. Otherwise, it should probably be Christa.

  • edited October 2017

    turns out Molly and Lily meet and had the most awesome tag team ever. that be cool

  • Yes show up and explain what they went through since their last confirmed sighting. Christa wouldn't make since because even if the first shot didn't kill her then that bandit had more than one bullet most likely to try repeatedly if she ran away. I think it's not likely she made it just like it should have been highly unlikely that Kenny made it throughout that back alley infested with walkers. If you had Ben in episode 5 of S1.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Which character's fate would you rather learn about from season 4 before the series wraps up? Christa or Lilly? If you mean show up, then Lily. Otherwise, it should probably be Christa.

  • For what it's worth, her disappearance was indeed supposed to be a recurring mystery. And it's very likely that she did manage to at least get away considering Mike was supposed to be the "Ralph" the third bandit scarred by friendly fire, captured by Carver, and would have to ally with Clementine to help her group escape.

    Also, the Kenny thing just gives it more precedent.

    Ladariel posted: »

    Yes show up and explain what they went through since their last confirmed sighting. Christa wouldn't make since because even if the first sh

  • I figured, that's why the bandit looks similar to Mike without the Tyson ear. Wish they kept each seasons original script. Except season 1 because originally Clem was suppose to have a older bro and be white or either be cut from the game altogether. Makes one wonder if Lee still would have lived or not if Clem got cut off from ever being in the game.

    DabigRG posted: »

    For what it's worth, her disappearance was indeed supposed to be a recurring mystery. And it's very likely that she did manage to at least g

  • Yes I recall saying something similar, and the fact that they would both have history with Clementine, Lee and Kenny but not each other until present and be allies. Both are no nonsense characters except with Lilly being more of a hot head than Christa.

    jdgjordan posted: »

    turns out Molly and Lily meet and had the most awesome tag team ever. that be cool

  • I figured, that's why the bandit looks similar to Mike without the Tyson ear.

    enter image description here

    Wish they kept each seasons original script.

    Eh, agreed with asterisks.

    Except season 1 because originally Clem was suppose to have a older bro and be white or either be cut from the game altogether. Makes one wonder if Lee still would have lived or not if Clem got cut off from ever being in the game.

    Very good question. Hard to really think about, though.

    Ladariel posted: »

    I figured, that's why the bandit looks similar to Mike without the Tyson ear. Wish they kept each seasons original script. Except season 1

  • I think Telltale would have a field day with possibilities of what happened to Lily. Like her story is just all over the place, and with that, there's so many smart ways Telltale could reintroduce her. And this may be small, but I hope the game designers do it right and don't fuck up her character design/look like Jane & Kenny. Personally I say this all the time, but I'd love to see Lily become some kind of leader of a community. But I see it ending up like Joan's story that's why I'm pissed she didn't appear in ANF, she would've fit perfectly in that group.

  • Uh, actually, he said Molly.

    Ladariel posted: »

    Yes I recall saying something similar, and the fact that they would both have history with Clementine, Lee and Kenny but not each other unti

  • Christa, definitely.

  • Ah I see now, at the time I read it quick and responded quick and forgot the comment said Molly not Lilly. Though my comment about Lilly and Christa would still be something I'd personally prefer to see than Molly returning. Although Molly and Jane would of sounded like a much better pair up due to their similarities.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Uh, actually, he said Molly.

  • I bet Lilly and David would probably had liked each other somehow then you'd have David with the affair while Kate wouldn't care. I also think Lilly either wouldn't have let Clem get banned from the group or if Lilly agreed with Dave that he was right for kicking out Clem then that would put Lilly at odds with Clementine. Fun to think about. Sometimes mixing old and new character confrontations can get interesting.

    I think Telltale would have a field day with possibilities of what happened to Lily. Like her story is just all over the place, and with tha

  • Though my comment about Lilly and Christa would still be something I'd personally prefer to see than Molly returning

    Agreed. Molly should have her own spinoff if she ever returns.

    Although Molly and Jane would of sounded like a much better pair up due to their similarities.

    Eh...if you say so.

    Ladariel posted: »

    Ah I see now, at the time I read it quick and responded quick and forgot the comment said Molly not Lilly. Though my comment about Lilly and

  • > Eh...if you say so.

    So you prefer the lone wolves to stay lone wolves? Wouldn't Jane and Molly naturally befriend each other since Jane was basically a duplicate character of Molly? Maybe Molly liked kids better I guess might be the main difference.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Though my comment about Lilly and Christa would still be something I'd personally prefer to see than Molly returning Agreed. Molly s

  • Lilly and David would probably had liked each other somehow

    Oh yeah they definitely would've hit it off big time lol.

    Sometimes mixing old and new character confrontations can get interesting.

    And that's true, it sucks to think about all the things Telltale could've done with past & present characters. ANF would've had so much potential. Like it's funny sometimes to think about it too, like we're all just fans and these guys run the company and we come up with some theories/ideas the devs can't even come up with :D

    Ladariel posted: »

    I bet Lilly and David would probably had liked each other somehow then you'd have David with the affair while Kate wouldn't care. I also thi

  • edited October 2017

    Lilly and David would probably had liked each other somehow

    It would probably turn out to be an unhealthy relationship if the two did hook up or befriend each other, considering that Lilly's father was once part of the military much like how David once was, and that both of them had serious anger issues and didn't treat their relatives as well as they could have done. David and Larry had the best intentions with protecting their families, but they had trouble expressing it and did let their anger and violent streak get the best of them at the worst of times.

    Wouldn't Jane and Molly naturally befriend each other since Jane was basically a duplicate character of Molly?

    I doubt it. Jane is more or less the opposite of Molly in some ways, and I'd imagine that the two would not get along at all, especially when it comes to how they dealt with their respective sister's fates. Molly would definitely be disgusted at Jane's mindset when it comes to how she perceives disadvantaged individuals, since Molly did rebel against Crawford for carrying the same ideology.

  • edited October 2017

    Well, it's possible for lone wolves to work together with others if they feel like it.

    What meant is that I don't really see them getting along. For as much as Telltale seemingly tried to invoke Molly with Jane and people tend to refer to the latter as just a clone of Molly, they are actually pretty different from each other past the badass zombie killing tomboy with a dead/missing sister thing.

    Maybe Molly liked kids better I guess might be the main difference.

    .

    @RichWalk23 I doubt it. Jane is more or less the opposite of Molly in some ways, and I'd imagine that the two would not get along at all, especially when it comes to how they dealt with their respective sister's fates. Molly would definitely be disgusted at Jane's mindset when it comes to how she perceives disadvantaged individuals, since Molly did rebel against Crawford for carrying the same ideology.

    Exactly. ,

    Ladariel posted: »

    > Eh...if you say so. So you prefer the lone wolves to stay lone wolves? Wouldn't Jane and Molly naturally befriend each other since J

  • Mike with the Tyson ear probably was no coincidence on Telltale's part anyway. When they could of named that guy with thousands of other names with a deformed ear. They at times enjoy dropping Easter eggs in their games.

    DabigRG posted: »

    I figured, that's why the bandit looks similar to Mike without the Tyson ear. Wish they kept each seasons original script.

  • You think she made it alive out of the woods ?

    Christa, definitely.

  • Definitely. Not only was Lilly a far superior character to the somewhat likeable-ish, though otherwise forgettable Christa, but her exit in the game left the character open to far more possibilities and potential than her counterpart.

    The only reasonable possibility for Christa after the event with the bandits and this is in no offence to anyone that likes her, is six feet under with a bullet in her head.

  • Well the devs aren't really fans for the most part. They are workers whom are most likely way more concerned with getting a paycheck for little work as reasonably possible than concern over happy and unhappy fans..

    Lilly and David would probably had liked each other somehow Oh yeah they definitely would've hit it off big time lol. Sometime

  • edited October 2017

    I agree though some imply. That if Kenny could make it out of season 1 with impossible odds (back alleyway with impaled Ben) then so could Christa.

    OneWayNoWay posted: »

    Definitely. Not only was Lilly a far superior character to the somewhat likeable-ish, though otherwise forgettable Christa, but her exit in

  • Oh, yeah, she definitely could, but there's only so much Telltale can rely on the suspension of disbelief when bringing characters back since they already did it with Kenny. Christa's better off unknown, leaning on death, rather than having an "oh so shocking" return, especially when I don't believe there's all that much potential for her, anyway.

    Ladariel posted: »

    I agree though some imply. That if Kenny could make it out of season 1 with impossible odds (back alleyway with impaled Ben) then so could Christa.

  • Yeah, although I don't necessarily think that she survived for long. I'm guessing there's a 50/50 chance we find her alive/dead/undead elsewhere in this season. (For all we know, it could happen in a flashback.)

    Ladariel posted: »

    You think she made it alive out of the woods ?

  • edited October 2017

    The only reasonable possibility for Christa after the event with the bandits and this is in no offence to anyone that likes her, is six feet under with a bullet in her head.

    I think reasonable possibilities went out of the window a long time ago when it comes to characters surviving against all odds.

    If Kenny can escape from his predicament at the end of Season 1 without being bitten once and then miraculously found by Sarita, then why can't Christa do the same?

    Even Clementine, an eleven year-old, managed to stay alive after falling into a river with strong currents. And then goes to survive an encounter with a vicious dog a few hours later, and doesn't die from her wounds after being refused treatment for some time after being encountered by the Cabin Group.

    Christa's better off unknown, leaning on death, rather than having an "oh so shocking" return, especially when I don't believe there's all that much potential for her, anyway.

    You may not see potential in Christa, but there are others who believe that Christa should return to help fill in the relationship between Clementine and Christa, especially when Clementine seems to have completely forgotten about her when Christa was her guardian who was guaranteed to have been watching out for her the longest out of everyone.

    There's also how her return would also help give her more character and background, especially when it comes to the loss of her partner Omid and her unborn child. I doubt keeping her status unknown would help build her character at all if the writers have no interest in bringing her back into the story in some form.

  • Even Clementine, an eleven year-old, managed to stay alive after falling into a river with strong currents. And then goes to survive an encounter with a vicious dog a few hours later, and doesn't die from her wounds after being refused treatment for some time after being encountered by the Cabin Group.

    Also got shot in the chest by Arvo and lived like 9 days until Wellington or Howes. Fell into a sub zero temperature lake as well if you made choices accordingly.

    They have a bad habit with making character scenes unbelievable.. Like Clem taking down a huge tree to stop a truck was crossing the line for me.

    RichWalk23 posted: »

    The only reasonable possibility for Christa after the event with the bandits and this is in no offence to anyone that likes her, is six feet

  • Oh yeah, falling in was optional. That explains why it (it being her hypothermia) was glossed over so quickly.

    Ladariel posted: »

    Even Clementine, an eleven year-old, managed to stay alive after falling into a river with strong currents. And then goes to survive an enco

  • She was shot in the shoulder, not the chest.

    Ladariel posted: »

    Even Clementine, an eleven year-old, managed to stay alive after falling into a river with strong currents. And then goes to survive an enco

  • edited October 2017

    I want to say in between shoulder and chest like a couple inches next to her armpit I guess worth checking out again on YouTube. Still quite close to the heart, arteries and lungs which should put any real human in Jeopardy of their life without medical intervention. No internal bleeding or joint/bone damage not even much pain or complaints about taking a nice sized bullet that went through her. Even if through the shoulder I'd imagine she'd be in as much trouble with loss of blood as from that dog attack.. So Clem had a plot armor vest underneath the jacket.

    No matter the excuse it can never make much sense and plenty other illogical scenes have played out in these games. Like dragging a grown man atleast triple her weight in center of a herd of walkers. Fending off grown men much stronger and faster than her. No one on Clem's group getting shot at during the Russian shoot out etc.. It's not a surprise for me.

    Fangirl101 posted: »

    She was shot in the shoulder, not the chest.

  • edited October 2017

    In addition to this before someone says "oh shucks well ole Lukey boy got popped in his leg" I meant fatally shot..

    Ladariel posted: »

    I want to say in between shoulder and chest like a couple inches next to her armpit I guess worth checking out again on YouTube. Still quite

  • Ya know, if they had kept Sarah and/or a mute Nick around, we wouldn't have that problem. Not as badly anyway.

    Ladariel posted: »

    In addition to this before someone says "oh shucks well ole Lukey boy got popped in his leg" I meant fatally shot..

  • I just thought of something. What if Nick died during the bandit shootout because he was afraid of shooting another human being again? Some sort of PTSD or something keeps him from pulling the trigger this time.

    Eh? I know I'm no expert fanfic writer, but I think that works pretty well.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Ya know, if they had kept Sarah and/or a mute Nick around, we wouldn't have that problem. Not as badly anyway.

  • Seems kinda random, but okay.

    Louche posted: »

    I just thought of something. What if Nick died during the bandit shootout because he was afraid of shooting another human being again? Some

  • Random? There's nothing random about it. Nick never does any fighting in episode 3. You can easily have him still be shook up by what happened to Mathew so that he delays pulling the trigger with the Russians... why? Because he's worried they won't actually shoot and he will have made another huge mistake.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Seems kinda random, but okay.

  • I say it's random in part because of Character Development. He still helped Carlos defend the Ski Lodge from the walkers, even if he apparently pussed out and later got himself deadlocked with a walker. And he presumably helped fight off walkers after Carlos got shot and helped chase after Sarah before eventually getting bitten in the released version.

    And while I know there's technically a difference between undead walkers and vengeful Russians, his group is still in blatant danger there. And if there's one time I wouldn't expect him to freeze up, it's in that type of situation.

    Louche posted: »

    Random? There's nothing random about it. Nick never does any fighting in episode 3. You can easily have him still be shook up by what happen

  • Eh. I still say it's a better death than what he got. I think it could play out in a way that makes sense, if it gets the proper direction. I'm a fan of ironic deaths. What's ironic about Nick getting caught on a fence and dying like an idiot? And considering the awkward way that herd scene played out, I wouldn't be surprised if he just stood still until his obligatory appearance running with Luke. Can you even see Nick fighting during that scene?
    I only saw Bonnie and Sarita.

    DabigRG posted: »

    I say it's random in part because of Character Development. He still helped Carlos defend the Ski Lodge from the walkers, even if he apparen

  • getting a paycheck for little work as reasonably possible than concern over happy and unhappy fans..

    The ugly truth..

    Ladariel posted: »

    Well the devs aren't really fans for the most part. They are workers whom are most likely way more concerned with getting a paycheck for little work as reasonably possible than concern over happy and unhappy fans..

  • Nothing. He just ran out to get Luke and Sarah help and ended up dying from being bitten before he reached the exit.

    Only Jane is visible fighting in the background. Because of course she is.

    Louche posted: »

    Eh. I still say it's a better death than what he got. I think it could play out in a way that makes sense, if it gets the proper direction.

  • edited November 2017

    I thought Christa was an awesome character and survivor, she is someone who you would want to have around in your group. She took care of Clementine for over a year and deserves more credit when it comes to helping Clem becoming a survivor. I wish we saw more of that and hopefully we can see her again.

  • edited November 2017

    damn, this format is annoying me

Sign in to comment in this discussion.