The Telltale forums are now read only. Past posts will stay available to browse, but new posts and replies have moved to our official Discord.

Join the conversation on Discord

One Last Time...Rank Every Season of TWDG

Now that everything is completely finished, seems like a good time to drop this thread one last time.

«1

Comments

  • My EXTREMELY controversial list goes like this
    1. S1
    2. ANF
    3. TFS
    4. S2
    5. Michonne

  • Again?

    Season One;
    Season Two;
    ‘A New Frontier’ / Michonne;
    The final season.

  • At least we both have no shame. ?

    Cdognkal2 posted: »

    My EXTREMELY controversial list goes like this 1. S1 2. ANF 3. TFS 4. S2 5. Michonne

  • Please explain to me how ANF is better than TFS and season 2

    Cdognkal2 posted: »

    My EXTREMELY controversial list goes like this 1. S1 2. ANF 3. TFS 4. S2 5. Michonne

  • Ikr.

    Please explain to me how ANF is better than TFS and season 2

  • Uh-oh: a storm has hit. ?

    Please explain to me how ANF is better than TFS and season 2

  • Season 1
    TFS
    Season 2
    ANF
    Michonne

  • 1.TFS
    2. Season 1
    3. Season 2
    4. ANF
    5. Michonne

    I spent some time with TFS and Season 1 to truly understand my feelings for them. I've come to the conclusion that Season 1 is unquestionably the better story in my eyes. But I have a deeper love for TFS that's simply hard for me to put into words. I guess you could say I feel whole when I play it and I don't even really know what I mean by that. All I know is I love the feeling. And since it's ended, it's been the only thing I could think about.

  • Aww.

    Sarunas21 posted: »

    1.TFS 2. Season 1 3. Season 2 4. ANF 5. Michonne I spent some time with TFS and Season 1 to truly understand my feelings for them. I'

    1. Season 1
    2. The Final Season
    3. Season 2
    4. Michonne
    5. A New Frontier
  • 2>1=4=Michonne>3

  • I just felt more attached to the characters and the story than in S2 and TFS. Dont get me wrong though, I loved both those games too.

    Please explain to me how ANF is better than TFS and season 2

  • Agreed

    Season 1 TFS Season 2 ANF Michonne

    1. S1
    2. S2
    3. 400 DAYS
    4. ANF
    5. MIchonne
    6. TFS
  • wait a min! i rank the Walking Dead pinball 6! so TFS 7! xD

  • Wow, you did not like it either?

    Clemmy1 posted: »

    wait a min! i rank the Walking Dead pinball 6! so TFS 7! xD

  • Hell to the yeah.

    Agreed

  • Is this a new thread?

  • 1 -S1
    2- TFS
    3 - ANF
    4 - Michonne
    5- S2

    1. Season 1
    2. The Final Season
    3. Season 2
    4. A New Frontier
    5. Michonne
  • edited March 2019

    Season 1
    Season 2 (I think TFS is technically better, but my rose tinted glasses won't allow me to rank it higher than Season 2. At least not yet.)
    The Final Season
    A New Frontier
    Michonne

  • Are you a fan of Sarah? If so, I liked her too.

    ralo229 posted: »

    Season 1 Season 2 (I think TFS is technically better, but my rose tinted glasses won't allow me to rank it higher than Season 2. At least not yet.) The Final Season A New Frontier Michonne

  • Really now? :open_mouth:

    Are you a fan of Sarah? If so, I liked her too.

  • Well, guess what? I liked Sarah too

    Are you a fan of Sarah? If so, I liked her too.

  • Why do you act so surprised? ? Queen Jane still rules. xo

    DabigRG posted: »

    Really now?

  • I think they treated her character poorly.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Well, guess what? I liked Sarah too

    1. ANF.
    2. TFS.
    3. Michonne.
    4. S2.
    5. S1.
  • Season One is last?

    Linkyop posted: »

    * ANF. * TFS. * Michonne. * S2. * S1.

  • Yes.

    Season One is last?

  • How come? I am surprised is all.

    Linkyop posted: »

    Yes.

  • What, did your phone turn the list underside down? :lol:

    Linkyop posted: »

    * ANF. * TFS. * Michonne. * S2. * S1.

  • ‘A New Frontier’ is awesome, okay?! Anyone who has a problem with that can deal with my love for Halestorm. xo

    DabigRG posted: »

    What, did your phone turn the list underside down?

  • You cant just drop a list like that without explaining why?

    Linkyop posted: »

    * ANF. * TFS. * Michonne. * S2. * S1.

  • I can. And i will.

    Cdognkal2 posted: »

    You cant just drop a list like that without explaining why?

  • Nope.

    DabigRG posted: »

    What, did your phone turn the list underside down?

  • The mystery behind this one is killing me

    Linkyop posted: »

    * ANF. * TFS. * Michonne. * S2. * S1.

  • Probably in terms of being more lighthearted and less dragged out.

    Melton23 posted: »

    The mystery behind this one is killing me

  • edited March 2019

    1: Surprise surprise: Season 1.
    2: The season that grew on me even with its flaws: Season 2.
    3: The season that still gets shit on regularly for almost 2 years and a half because it's what the cool kids do nowadays: ANF.
    4: The season that you'll get called an edgelord pointing its negative sides and saying telltale messed up this one too: TFS.

  • Same!

    Hersani posted: »

    1: Surprise surprise: Season 1. 2: The season that grew on me even with its flaws: Season 2. 3: The season that still gets shit on regular

  • 1
    2
    4
    3 (Javi & Kate are still some of my favorite characters despite the low ranking)
    Michonne

Sign in to comment in this discussion.