What if Nate was Clementine's caretaker instead of Lee?

13

Comments

  • I could see that too, he would probably force her to do it a couple of times as to get rid of the feeling of guilt before eventually ending his life.

    Onmens posted: »

    I can see Nate putting a gun in Clems hand and try to make her shoot somebody, and I can see Clem turning the gun on Nate and shooting him instead. And feeling guilty afterwards.

  • edited January 2014

    I think Danny (despite his past) would still pwn Nate at caretaking Clem in a zombie apocalypse. Nate's just not totally likeable...
    Alt text

  • Clem won't have a caretaker, cause that's actually the point with this season.

  • How about this dough GIF?!
    Alt text

    dat gif dough.

  • And someone else will be all: Alt text

    DomeWing333 posted: »

    She'd be all: And he'd be all:

  • Negan has some good traits, like when he stops Holly from being raped by his men.

  • Remember, we don't know anything about Nate before the events of 400 days, and one of his friends was killed right in front of him by Eddie, which probably made him lose it a little bit. I think she could change him.

    Antero posted: »

    Clementine is smart enough to the point where she would have rejected learning anything from someone like Nate.

  • That's what I'm saying, his sanity became unhinged during the events of the game, I Can see him turning Clem into a badass!

    ruairi46 posted: »

    To be fair, we don't know what Nate was like Pre-murder of his friend that eddie shot so he could of been 'sain' at one point. If he was good friends with whoever got shot in real life that'd effect you pretty bad.

  • Good guy Negan: taking the though stance against raping prisoners of war.

  • Being badass is still different from being gorked. Very different.

    Scytheslay posted: »

    That's what I'm saying, his sanity became unhinged during the events of the game, I Can see him turning Clem into a badass!

  • It would have been really interesting. I think I agree with the whole, he would have manipulated her with her parents and forced her to stay with him. But she's a kid, and we know next to nothing about Nate. Maybe he would have taken care of her, maybe he would have pawned her off as soon as he could. Either way, I think she would have survived (him, too) if he taught her how he knew how to handle things. He was built for the apocalypse, and in times like that you cannot be a lovable, forgiving person. You can't just let everyone live, people have to die, whether they've done something against you or not. (In Nate's defense, the old couple /did/ shoot at them) I think in season 2, Clem would be pretty much the same. Obviously, Omid and Christa have taught her how to harden her soul and heart, whether she wanted to or not. She's not that scared to speak her mind, she's barely even a child now. If Nate had taught her, though, I think she'd be just under bandit-level of surviving.

    That all being said, I hope he shows up in Season 2 at some point. I'd really love some interaction. I'd hate it if it we had the option to kill him, though, unless it was a quick time event. Ah well, I'll stop rambling and let everyone get back to the topic.

  • If Telltale aren't already throwing Nate in Season 2 I hope the fact that a character who got 20 minutes of screen time is intriguing to so many people makes them think about it.

  • Lets add lee to the creepy face list..

    Alt text

    DomeWing333 posted: »

    She'd be all: And he'd be all:

  • She'll become like Harley Quinn. Oo

  • They could make a "what if" dlc for it

    zyoxo posted: »

    If Telltale aren't already throwing Nate in Season 2 I hope the fact that a character who got 20 minutes of screen time is intriguing to so many people makes them think about it.

  • I approve.

    How about this dough GIF?!

  • It will be interesting to see Nate interact with Clem in S2

  • Clem: (runs)

    Hostage 1: Get in the car! Quick!

    Hostage 2: (opens door for clem)

    Clem: (rushes into the car)

    Hostage 1: C'mon man, let's go!

    Hostage 2: Aight.. let's tom cruise outta here! (starts car and drives away)

    Nate: (starts shooting at the car)

    Nate: (rushes into his truck and tails the car)

    ???

    * Nate and Clem conversation: * Nate: Hey kid you wanna see something cool? * Clem: What is it? (Shows Clem two hostages tied up)

  • Great minds think alike.

    Not so great minds as well it seems. :)

    Lol read my comment Nate and Clem conversation. It's in this thread

  • Lol people are funny haha. If Nate was a Rapist he would have rapped Russel and he didn't. He just witnessed his friend get killed by Eddie which gave him a psychological thinking. Anyone who see's their friend or family die in front of them is tramatizing. He got the feeling he can't trust anyone that's why he asked Russ if he was a thief. Eddie and Wyatt killed his friend and stole from him that's why he acts this way. Nate trusted Russ because he seemed cool. He will just think your a punk or pussy if you dont agree with em. There's no sexual content in this game so. Winston who died in episode 1 he seemed more of a Rapist. Nate can be a cool guy if you get to know em. Him and Clem will connect because they both lost a friend they loved and going through hard times. Nate will ask Clem about Lee and she will tell em. He will then tell her how he lost his friend to two idiot friends Eddie and Wyatt. Russ will tell Clem how Nate killed two old people at the gas station and stole their stuff.

  • edited January 2014

    Dude.. your thumb pic...
    Alt text

    Onmens posted: »

    Great minds think alike. Not so great minds as well it seems.

  • Alt text

    Onmens posted: »

    I can see Nate putting a gun in Clems hand and try to make her shoot somebody, and I can see Clem turning the gun on Nate and shooting him instead. And feeling guilty afterwards.

  • Thnx bro

    Nice...

  • Don't mention it.. but did you draw it tho? Cause i'd give this a hundred likes if I could.

    Gengar posted: »

    Thnx bro

  • what if clems caretaker was danny?

  • he would rape the shit out of clem and possibly kill her/eat her later

    Legendary12 posted: »

    what if clems caretaker was danny?

  • I did, i kinda drew it in a hurry though XD

    Don't mention it.. but did you draw it tho? Cause i'd give this a hundred likes if I could.

  • Awesome. :D

    Gengar posted: »

    I did, i kinda drew it in a hurry though XD

  • edited January 2014

    Hostage 2: God this is so fucked!

    Hostage 1: Why the hell did you shoot the guy? What the hell WAS that?

    Clem: I didn't mean to do it! It just happened, okay?

    Hostage 2: Where were you with the warning?

    Clem: Me? You're putting that on me now? I was too worried he was gonna pull a gun on you two or--

    Hostage 2: Shit, how'd he catch up to us?

    Hostage 1: Who gives a shit, just--

    (Nate shoots)

    Hostage 1: Hurry up Eddie!

    Hostage 2: Here man, shoot. Get 'em man.

    (Nate's truck's headlight gets shot and loses control of truck)

    Clem: Did you get 'em? Is he back there?

    (silence)

    Hostage 2: ...Wyatt? Is he back there? ...Wyatt, talk words at me, man!

    Hostage 1: Fuck if I know!

    To be continued...

    Clem: (runs) Hostage 1: Get in the car! Quick! Hostage 2: (opens door for clem) Clem: (rushes into the car) Hostage 1: C'mon man,

  • Oh, sorry, it's a what if topic... I didn't read it well :( My bad!

    Nate is really scary, for the simple reason I can't decie if he's a bad guy or a good guy that just lost it a little bit... I honestly wouldn't have liked Clem to be with him :p

    AnTea posted: »

    Clem won't have a caretaker, cause that's actually the point with this season.

  • I'd like to think Clem would be his Caretaker xDD

  • Seriously? Dude, that was in the past - it was a 15 year old skank and Danny obviously regretted everything in the prison bus. And he had never killed anyone intentionally, and never would have nor would he want anyone to die. He has morals, man. It would be better than having Nate instead, a shitload better...

    vivec posted: »

    he would rape the shit out of clem and possibly kill her/eat her later

  • I guess even evil has incredibly low standards then.

    Good comment, I was about to say the same thing.

  • edited January 2014

    He wouldn't be able to rape Russel. He knew that. And nobody who's not a potential gorked psycho would be tempted to try and kill anyone.. and it's likely that Eddie shot Nate's friend in self-defense, probably because they were gonna get mugged for their stuff. And I don't see Nate being in deep sympathy with anyone, either. I didn't remember him seeing himself in Russel's position. He was a go-mad fella.

    Lol people are funny haha. If Nate was a Rapist he would have rapped Russel and he didn't. He just witnessed his friend get killed by Eddie wh

  • That would be very weird...

    Scytheslay posted: »

    I'd like to think Clem would be his Caretaker xDD

  • How? He seems unstable at times and she could serve as a moral compass like she did with Lee.

    That would be very weird...

  • I don't think Nate listens to anyone...

    Scytheslay posted: »

    How? He seems unstable at times and she could serve as a moral compass like she did with Lee.

  • I would too xD Just to see how things would play out

    NideX posted: »

    Would honestly enjoy playing that :$

  • Not enough reason to be crazy. Nate and his pal were probably mugging Eddie and Wyatt. Eddie probably did it in self defense...

    Okay let me set the record straight here. Nate is like Negan from the comics but much nicer. Nate might be a crazy dude but theres reasons for

Sign in to comment in this discussion.