If Jane dies in Season 3

124»

Comments

  • Leader of Cluke? Did he work for Subway and go to jail or something?

    the leader of Cluke Don't say her name! You will bring her back from the grave!

  • No and it's SHE btw.

    Kennyftw posted: »

    Leader of Cluke? Did he work for Subway and go to jail or something?

  • I don't care if I remind you of freaking Hitler, I will still keep loving Jane and hating Sarah. I flagged your post for insulting me so I hope the mods will actually do something about this.

    AronDracula posted: »

    What does Cluke have to do with Jane? Still won't say her name but she ships Cluke a lot, she thinks Luke is not dead and considers

  • This doesn't help anything. You brought me into this. You should never have bothered talking to me in the first place. Also, you're saying some things that are not completely true.

    DarkViolet posted: »

    I don't care if I remind you of freaking Hitler, I will still keep loving Jane and hating Sarah. I flagged your post for insulting me so I hope the mods will actually do something about this.

  • I will still keep loving Jane and hating Sarah

    When did I say you should hate Jane and love Sarah, huh? >:(

    DarkViolet posted: »

    I don't care if I remind you of freaking Hitler, I will still keep loving Jane and hating Sarah. I flagged your post for insulting me so I hope the mods will actually do something about this.

  • Dude, I have been on this forum for 2 years and I don't even know you. I have never said a rude word to you. I never even use bad language because I am aware of the fact that this forum is mostly used by kids. And you insult me for what? Hating that slow waste of space named Sarah? Please ignore my posts from now on.

    AronDracula posted: »

    This doesn't help anything. You brought me into this. You should never have bothered talking to me in the first place. Also, you're saying some things that are not completely true.

  • Off, I'm saying again, you brought Sarah into my comment for no reason. I wanted people to think what they have to say about Jane's fate having a similar one to Noah's death, if they agree or not.

    DarkViolet posted: »

    Dude, I have been on this forum for 2 years and I don't even know you. I have never said a rude word to you. I never even use bad language b

  • [removed]

    AronDracula posted: »

    Off, I'm saying again, you brought Sarah into my comment for no reason. I wanted people to think what they have to say about Jane's fate having a similar one to Noah's death, if they agree or not.

  • edited February 2016

    Oh, I apologize, I missed her first comment. Although reading all the comments, it's rather hypocritical of you to complain that someone brought in another character to a discussion when you yourself brought Lee in to a discussion you were in - either way though, there's nothing wrong with bringing other characters into a discussion, it usually helps expand the discussion.

    AronDracula posted: »

    How are you so inattentive? She is the one who mentioned Sarah first. But that's the way Sarah died. I don't want death scenes to get repetitive.

  • I thought you were defending her when I started nothing but glad you realised

    prink34320 posted: »

    Oh, I apologize, I missed her first comment. Although reading all the comments, it's rather hypocritical of you to complain that someone bro

  • edited February 2016
  • To be honest, I didn't like her at first either. She has grown on me by the end of the fourth episode though, and has become my favorite character in the finale.

    Flog61 posted: »

    So much love for Jane, a real nice change from a year and a half ago.

  • What do you care what he was going to do? I remember you from a long time ago. You said you would leave the baby behind to die. Who are you to take the moral high ground?

    zykelator posted: »

    Speculation? Theres something wrong with your eyes. Kenny charging at her while she was on ground is a fact also, but sure, you can speculate what kind of horrors he was planning to do, but i doubt he was trying to help her get back up.

  • edited February 2016

    No, the only thing Kenny knew was that AJ was not with Jane and that was enough to drive him crazy (of course, other previous factors also influenced this).

    I recognise that Kenny though she left the baby to die, which is terrible since she claimed that it was an accident.

    Jane did play a dangerous game but she didn't think it was that dangerous. She claims that she had no idea that Kenny would go that far. So Jane after all didn't though that there would be a fight to the death. Kenny provoked that fight, not Jane.


    Kennyftw posted: »

    He knew she was lying about the baby being missing. He knew she didn't have it. He knew nothing happened to it by accident. He was right

  • edited February 2016

    k

  • Because she had to use the knife for self defense? She was on ground and bigger male opponent was charging at her.

    Why are you going off-topic?

    In my opinion, its better to look after yourself, than risk your life for some random baby that will most likely cause you to die. Ofc some wont agree with that and argue that every human life is precious, but that just an opinion and it shouldnt be forced on others.

    Kennyftw posted: »

    What do you care what he was going to do? I remember you from a long time ago. You said you would leave the baby behind to die. Who are you to take the moral high ground?

  • So much love for Jane, a real nice change from a year and a half ago.

    I love it. ;.;

    Flog61 posted: »

    So much love for Jane, a real nice change from a year and a half ago.

  • Yeah its the jane forums these days

    Flog61 posted: »

    So much love for Jane, a real nice change from a year and a half ago.

  • Kenny started the fight? Really? ok...

    No, the only thing Kenny knew was that AJ was not with Jane and that was enough to drive him crazy (of course, other previous factors also i

  • edited February 2016

    Jane did play a dangerous game but she didn't think it was that dangerous. She claims that she had no idea that Kenny would go that far. So Jane after all didn't though that there would be a fight to the death. Kenny provoked that fight, not Jane.

    Oh come on! Jane knew what was going to happen and knew he would go that far despite what she said. She told Clem to "stay out of it your gonna see what he really is". She knew he'd go for her. He threw the first punch but she was asking for the fight because there wouldn't have even been one in the first place if she hadn't done what she did and we all know it and no one would have died

    No, the only thing Kenny knew was that AJ was not with Jane and that was enough to drive him crazy (of course, other previous factors also i

  • I dunno. Kenny and Jane should die at the hands of the villain in season 3. That would make the game much more emotional and people would get more attached to it. But, hopefully Jane and Kenny do have different dialogues and have their own respective death. Sorta like Carly/Doug, but like Kenny is beaten to death and Jane is executed with a bullet to the head, or vice versa. However, they shouldn't be killed off for cheap thrills (Ex; Luke, Tyreese from the show, and Omid)

    But I do see the possibility of them NOT returning at all in season 3. Considering there were like 6 endings in total?

  • The fight is Kenny's fault and only his. Jane did put them in that situation but as I meantioned anyone else would let Jane explain (which would cause no fight). Kenny in particular, after hearing that if he attacked her she would fight back, instigates a fight anyways!

    It's like you said right there, Jane put them in that situation, it was her fault the whole thing happened and i said this in another post.

    Kenny threw the first punch, yes he lost his temper big time but when you don't trust someone you're not going to listen to them explain plus she lied saying it was an accident making him believe AJ was dead which only made things even worse for his state of my mind. You can tear Kenny apart for seeing him as the villian here all you want but if Jane hadn't done what she did then nothing would have happened and no one would have died and posting pics of the scene isn't going to change people's minds (at least not mine) about Kenny who I don't think is a monster or a villain as you think. That's the opinion i have.

    First of all, when did Jane provoke Kenny? "You're gonna see what he really is" First of all, when Jane comes back without the b

  • Ohhh yes, because that erases all that he's done wrong. That's not how it works if you murder someone it wont just fade away

    it doesn't erase it no, but it's like you are ignoring anything good he ever did and always pointing out the negatives, never anything good which comes down to being biased. Everyone in the apocalypse is a murderer. Clem determinantly shooting Kenny in the head after he kills Jane is straight up murder even if there was a reason for it, Jane killing the Russian is even if it was to save someone, it's still murder, Alvin killing someone was cold blood murder, Carver's killings, Lilly shooting Carley, Danny St John or Lee killing Jolene? I don't see any negative comments on all those but of course since it's Kenny being discussed, suddenly, he's a god damn Nazi as Lilly would say

    But Jane could have told him AJ was alive, but she didn't say a word because she DID want Clem to shoot him. Exactly, she trusted th

  • but it's like you are ignoring anything good he ever did and always pointing out the negatives

    I'm well aware of the good things Kenny did but they are not that much, and they surely don't make (for me) up all the shitty things he has done.

    which comes down to being biased

    Well I'm sorry to hear you say that, I've been trying to not be biased. I'm not hatting Kenny because I want to, I hate him because I truly think he is a terrible person, so... no I don't think I'm being biased about this.

    Everyone in the apocalypse is a murderer.

    That is very wrong. Everyone in the apocalypse is a killer, not a murderer. Murderers are people who kill without plausible reasons, such as being angry, evil, etc.

    Clem determinantly shooting Kenny

    It was to defend another person, my Clem did not want Kenny to die she did it because Kenny pushed her to do it.

    Jane killing the Russian

    It was to defend another person.

    Alvin killing someone was cold blood murder

    We don't know all the details about that, but if he killed him in cold blood as Carver says, then yes it is murder.

    Carver's killings

    That's murder for sure.

    Lilly shooting Carley

    Murder.

    Danny St John or Lee killing Jolene

    Murder.


    My point being - not everyone in the ZA is a murderer.

    I don't see any negative comments on all those but of course since it's Kenny being discussed, suddenly, he's a god damn Nazi as Lilly would say

    Well that's not exactly true, Lilly gets a lot of hate, same thing with the St. John brothers.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Ohhh yes, because that erases all that he's done wrong. That's not how it works if you murder someone it wont just fade away it does

  • Sigh I'm gonna explain this again.

    What if another person was in Kenny's position? There would be no fight. But Kenny on the other hand jumps to a murder attempt. Him and his anger caused the fight.

    You can tear Kenny apart for seeing him as the villian here all you want

    Thank you for ýour premission.

    posting pics of the scene isn't going to change people's minds

    Ok Dan, I've explained this to you many times before: we are in a forum! People post their opinions and use arguments to support their opinions (that's why I used the screenhots). If my arguments aren't going to change people's minds, yours surely wont as well yet you're still debating.

    dan290786 posted: »

    The fight is Kenny's fault and only his. Jane did put them in that situation but as I meantioned anyone else would let Jane explain (which w

  • edited February 2016

    I'm well aware of the good things Kenny did but they are not that much, and they surely don't make (for me) up all the shitty things he has done.

    That's fine, i've no problem with that but was just pointing out that it was all negative and saying there's not many good things he did is your opinion which i disagree with obviously which is why it sounds biased. I'm not intending to say that you are but just sounded like it to me that's all.

    I hate him because I truly think he is a terrible person

    Ok that's fine and what i'm about to say is not in anyway trying to change your mind, but do you think that Kenny feels bad deep down of all the bad things he did? Do you think he's that evil without a conscience that he liked doing everything bad he did? Something he said in this image here (sorry it's very small, please let me know if you can't see it)

    photo image.png

    That line to me shows that he regrets all the bad things he did, everything Clem had to witness. An evil, psychotic person wouldn't give a damn and i know it doesn't change the fact he's done bad things but it's enough to redeem himself, at least it's enough for me.

    That is very wrong. Everyone in the apocalypse is a killer, not a murderer. Murderers are people who kill without plausible reasons, such as being angry, evil, etc.
    It was to defend another person, my Clem did not want Kenny to die she did it because Kenny pushed her to do it.

    I actually said when Clem shot Kenny in the head "after" he killed her not before. Clem shooting him before she died, yes, that was to defend her but if you let him kill Jane and then shoot him, that's murder, shes not defending anyone then.

    Thing is IronWoodLover, I want people to understand that I don't like or agree with "everything" Kenny ever did, i know he acted like an asshole several times and there were decisions he made that i didn't always agree with but I am extremely forgiving which you could say makes me a naive person but it's who i am, i still care and want to stand by people who may not be nice to me all the time but i see the good side of that person as well. I always trusted him in my playthrough and that's how my Lee and Kenny were. And im sorry but i just cannot hate the guy like most (on these forums anyway) do. He's done bad things, but so has everyone.

    I guess im one of these people who will always have sympathy for him the way he lost his family all at once in such a devastating way and what that does has an everlasting effect as i've also had a different terrible experience of loss before. Maybe it is also because i have an attachment to a season 1 character who's been around since the start, it's the same for me and the tv show with Rick, Daryl and Carol, you grow to love these characters.

    So there you go, it's how i feel and just wish some people on this site would understand. Thanks for reading.

    but it's like you are ignoring anything good he ever did and always pointing out the negatives I'm well aware of the good things Ken

  • What if another person was in Kenny's position? There would be no fight. But Kenny on the other hand jumps to a murder attempt. Him and his anger caused the fight.

    Sigh
    And i'll say it again also.

    There wouldn't have been any fight in the first place if Jane hadn't done what she did. She knew how he'd react, she knew he would attack her. She may not have been responsible in throwing the first punch, no, but she is to blame for causing the fight to happen by setting him off knowing his temper would get the better of him.

    Ok Dan, I've explained this to you many times before: we are in a forum! People post their opinions and use arguments to support their opinions (that's why I used the screenhots). If my arguments aren't going to change people's minds, yours surely wont as well yet you're still debating.

    I wasn't implying that you shouldn't post pics to support your opinions. That's fine but i was saying that if you are doing it to try and change some people's minds (i am not saying you are doing this by the way) but if you were then it's not going to change everyone's views. You did say to whoever your post was to that "i hope you've finally seen him for what he really is" which to me sounds like you are trying/hoping to change that person's opinion which is the whole reason i said what i did about the screenshots.

    Sigh I'm gonna explain this again. What if another person was in Kenny's position? There would be no fight. But Kenny on the other hand j

  • I cried when Noah died. And my Jane is dead. Dead, dead, dead. I did not cry for her.

    AronDracula posted: »

    Noah's death is the most gruesome death I have ever seen a Walking Dead franchise, no one would like to die like this.

  • Seven , I think.

    remorse667 posted: »

    I dunno. Kenny and Jane should die at the hands of the villain in season 3. That would make the game much more emotional and people would ge

  • Ok, I never cared for Noah, he was such a useless character but man, his death was bruta and omg I hated Jane since episode 4, I had been waiting for her to die.

    VicMasina posted: »

    I cried when Noah died. And my Jane is dead. Dead, dead, dead. I did not cry for her.

  • I think Clem abandoning her would be a fitting choice, as Jane has always taught her to run when the going gets tough. I let Kenny kill her but I'd abandon her if I had the chance.

  • I like how you think my friend

    Don't worry, she won't die in Season 3. Seeing as she already did in Season 2.

  • 10/10 input gg man really contributed to thread

    k

  • probably shot or being bitten

  • Maybe in the most ironic way.
    Jane preaches that you should leave others behind. What if, in return, she gets left behind?

    It'll reinforce the message that no one is safe for long but at least you have better chances when someone has your back.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.