Why Did You Save....(Spoilers)
So at the end of episode 2 you had a choice, Harvey or Selina? Why did you made that choice and what did you think of the outcome?
How will this effect future episodes?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
So at the end of episode 2 you had a choice, Harvey or Selina? Why did you made that choice and what did you think of the outcome?
How will this effect future episodes?
Comments
Harvey because he's my bro. bro-fists harvey
I feel like he'll go mad anyway though. The event will most likely be very traumatic for him bla bla bla and telltale will make him a villain no matter what. Only his appearance will differ. I hope I'm wrong though.
Selina because if there's 2 people Bruce Wayne cares about the most, it's Selina and Alfred. Tough luck, Harv.
I love Harvey too, though.
If I had to rank who I'd save over the other, it's Alfred > Selina > Harvey
Harvey, because I dislike catwoman and I am roleplaying a batman, that despises criminals.
I chose Selina because she looked like she was fucked. At least with Harv, you kinda know he'll become Two-Face then. With Selina, you wouldn't of known.
Seeing Harvey get his fucking face torn apart... Shit man.
God looking at the other result I really wish I saved Harvey.
Oh, and it'll probably result in getting Bruce's batdick wet, and Harvey maybe losing the election.
I chose Harvey, and while I still probably would have saved him over Selina if it wasn't for this, the main factor that played into my choice was what Harvey said when he was under the control of the drug. Despite the effects of the drug, he didn't say anything near as bad as Hill and it showed that he is genuinely concerned with helping Gotham and fighting against crime, and that he's not in it for his own personal gain.
Harvey Dent, can we trust him? I say yes we can, so that's why I chose him over Selina.
It partly because that Harvey is ultimately a civilian while Selina is a fighter and there was a higher chance that she can handle herself. Also, I was defying the mythos and for once, I want to at least try and prevent Harvey from becoming Two-Face.
I saved Selina because I thought she would actually die if I didnt.
I kinda assumed Harvey would be Two Face if you dont save him, but then I thought if I save Harvey that Selina would die, making the impact feel much different, and Id rather have them both alive, even if Harvey had to get his face burnt.
However, I will say its kinda disappointing that the outcome with Selina is no where near as bad as Harvey. Saving Harvey just has some idiot who cant aim a shot gun at point blank barley hit her. Who knows, maybe her arm is actually really messed up and now she can't help you out as much now. Im just hoping not saving Selina will have some sort of major impact so the choice doesnt become, "Well, you really should have saved Harvey because nothing changes if you save Selina."
I'm actually surprised you caught that, most people I've seen play just brushed that off without thinking of the implications. Heck, even I didn't my first playthrough.
I saved Selina because i was thinking with something else that's not my head. Now i have to live with the Consequences.
I saved Selina because she was already injured and had 3 armed dudes coming at her, while Harvey was just a little roughed up and only had Penguin attacking him
Really? I can see why (wasn't the subtitles not showing when Harvey was talking? Or at least it wasn't for me)
Saved Harvey
I knew Selina would be able to handle herself
I saved Harvey. Even if I am trying to take his girl, if there's a chance I could prevent Harvey from becoming a villain, I'll take it.
Harvey, i gotta protect him from turning two faceeeed!!! and he's my bestie lol (even tho he's looking sus rn i'll have his back) . Selina is just in it for your "pretty face" and money..also for the fame because Bruce is looking "sexy scandalous" right now in the media..pretty much looking criminal himself almost (which turns her on) and she only want him for that, which it superficial anyway (i hate the way she throws herself at Bruce) lol besides ik she could hold her own ..i accidentally didnt even allow her to help me at the beginning when we teamed up as Bat and Cat, but that should be good enough to get her off my back - business only. And why fall for someone who was playing your friend and admitted to it like he was nothing???
yea i was paying attention to the subtitles to make sure my fave characters (Harv and Vicki) would be ok lol Harvey is definitely strong under the influence and held his own in words..maybe because of his body mass? I super adore Harv and even trusted him over my money to help him even when the press didn't want Bruce with interfering with Harvey's election anymore
this is infact THE BEST BAT GAME because i was actually able to save Harvey Dent i'm so happy!
I saved Harvey because I wanted to see if you could prevent Two Face, and lo and behold.
Now hopefully that sticks
Harvey. It was a tough choice, but the ultimate goal of Batman is to keep Gotham safe. Harvey is the best hope for that. Even if a possible love interest could be at risk, I feel that Gotham's security is what Batman would choose.
Selina cuz i am thinking my penis.
I don't know how you could miss that, it was clear as day what he was saying and no one else was talking in that scene.
To me it was just background noise, I guess wasn't paying attention enough.
I actually completely stopped walking on the support beam to hear the whole thing.
On the silent playthrough
Bruce chose for me (Default)
So I'm making a separate playthrough (starting from the choice part)
Makes sense to be default choice.
Looking forward to seeing Harvey in action foras long as possible
Saved Selina: She already got enough damage, plus she helped Batman, and I ship them both! Also, I think it will make the game more interesting if Two-Face were born.
Okay...
That's what motivated me into saving Harvey after thinking about who to save. I really want to see how Telltale does with Harvey still being Harvey without becoming Two-face.
Though, there's something I'm curious to know. Now that Hill has been gunned down by Penguin, does this mean that Harvey will become the new Mayor once he checks out from the infirmary? Or is there some detail I'm overlooking?
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
When the choice came up, it was an easy one for me. Instantly chose Harvey. He's become my second favorite character in the game, he's been a good friend, he really does want what's best for Gotham, and I wanted to prevent him from becoming Two-Face.
Plus, when you're a hero, saving the civilian over another hero just makes more sense. We know that Catwoman can manage by herself.
...And in general, I've just never really been a fan of Catwoman. So yeah, easy decision for me. :P
I saved Selina, I felt indebted to her for helping me and thought she could be a valuable ally throughout the series. Also I had a feeling if I helped Harv the outcome would have been him still becoming Two-Face.
I saved Harvey. He was less likely to be able to defend himself, unlike Catwoman who I was pretty sure could handle those thugs. It's what I believe Batman would have done.
Maybe I'm being naive, but I actually didn't expect Harvey to become Two-Face because of Penguin. This game has honestly had a lot of surprises for me.
Saved Selina because she was up against guys with guns
Saved Selina, she's a badass. But in hindsight, I should have flipped a coin
I did that for who to give the intel in episode 1
Got Vicky 2/3 times
So i picked her.
In this however, there's a default choice, so i let Bruce make the choice.
I was thinking along the lines of it being the fate of Harvey Dent here, where a coin flip seems fitting somehow...
I didn't betray him for Hill, and said it was still cool for him to cash my checks, so I'm hoping he'll come around. Right, Dent? Heh, old buddy? Shit...
Harvey because he's my friend and I like him more. Also, I didn't want him to become Two-Face (even though I know that's what he becomes in canon). I like Selina too, but just not as much, and I thought she could take care of herself and be fine xD
Same thing here
I wish that all of the voices in my head could have an account so I could like this comment fifty times. Maaaan, that scene when he was drugged was just beautiful. I never thought I would describe someone getting drugged using words with such positive connotations, but here I am today.
I saved Harvey.
I couldn't bear the thought of him becoming Two-Face.
I've grown to care about him more than any of the other characters in the game, which kinda surprises me, since I didn't give a shit about him before.
Despite this, though, I almost chose Selina over him, as it seemed to be more logical to not piss her off.
I came this close to hitting the button to save her, but then I heard Harvey's scream of terror, and chose him.
That scream was honestly harrowing to me.
I didnt listen to my dick. I saved Harvey because he is the best thing for Gotham.