Who do you think are the most underrated and overrated characters in all of the games?

13468911

Comments

  • Overrated:
    Kenny
    Carver
    Pete
    Carley

    Underrated:
    Gabe
    Alvin
    Doug
    Arvo

  • Plus the whole group falls apart once Pete dies and every member of the Cabin Group is dead within a week.

    Well, two/three/four weeks, but whatever.

    Rock114 posted: »

    I'll say that Pete in Season 2 was pretty underrated. That guy was the closest thing Season 2 had to a "Lee" type character. Not necessarily

  • Pete

    Which one?

    CunningFox posted: »

    Overrated: Kenny Carver Pete Carley Underrated: Gabe Alvin Doug Arvo

  • edited January 2017

    The one from The Walking Dead Season 2.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Pete Which one?

  • Overrated Doug....thinks he is such hot shit.

  • edited February 2017

    I think his popularity comes from being a fun little alternative to Carley.

    Overrated Doug....thinks he is such hot shit.

  • Carver is underrated, and his ideology. Also Carlos. And that cool jacket of Clems, which can heal wounds.

  • edited January 2017

    I think Becca is underrated and I'm outraged that she isn't an avatar option.
    I guess Lily would be one that I wish got more attention, too. Her emotion when she talks about her dad almost made me tear up, and I hated Larry's guts. But I tried to help Lily just because of that.

    As for overrated, I actually don't know if any characters are overrated.
    Telltale writes good characters. They just don't use them that well. I. E. too much (Kenny) or too little (Chuck or Pete)

  • I think Becca is underrated and I'm outraged that she isn't an avatar option.

    Are any of the 400 Days characters an option?

    Telltale writes good characters. They just don't use them that well. I. E. too much (Kenny) or too little (Chuck or Pete)

    Agreed. I still maintain that Arvo/the Russians would've been a great/decent character(s) had they actually developed them properly, for example.

    Louche posted: »

    I think Becca is underrated and I'm outraged that she isn't an avatar option. I guess Lily would be one that I wish got more attention, to

  • I think Becca and Shel are the only 400 days characters who don't have an avatar

    DabigRG posted: »

    I think Becca is underrated and I'm outraged that she isn't an avatar option. Are any of the 400 Days characters an option? Te

  • Overrated:
    Nate, Eddie, Wyatt, Christa, Omid, Lilly, Carver, Luke, Jane, Lee, Clem, the St. John's, Molly

    Underrated:
    Katjaa, Edith, Sarah, Becca, Shel, The Stranger, Vince

    Anyone else I feel like they are either in the middle or I don't care enough about them to judge. I also purposely left out new season 3 characters since it isn't over yet.

  • edited January 2017

    Overrated
    Kenny (um yeah yikes to the extreme)
    Luke (I liked him at first, but then I realized how boring his character is)
    Clementine (imo, season 1 clem was the best clem)

    Underrated
    Sarah (<3)
    Arvo (eh. he's not really as bad as y'all think he is)
    Duck (literally have no idea as to why SO many people found him annoying like?????? tell me)
    Doug (prefer him over carley)
    Katjaa (beautiful)
    Satria (beautiful 2)
    Nick (a realistic character)
    Shel + Becca (idk i really love these two)
    Norma (I actually really liked norma. it's a shame that she's treated as a villain when we basically destroyed everything she worked so hard for : /)
    Lilly (honestly my favorite character out of the entire series)
    Rebecca + Alvin (never really see anyone talk about these two)
    Edith (season 3, why did you destroy her)

  • Well, that sucks. Shel definitely deserves that honor over Victor.

    Louche posted: »

    I think Becca and Shel are the only 400 days characters who don't have an avatar

  • Overrated

    • Luke (he's a cool guy and I like him, but he gets way too much attention and his death did not faze me at all).
    • Nick

    Underrated

    • Ben
    • Rebecca
    • Lilly
    • Mark
    • Matthew
  • IMO Season 1 Clem is who's overrated. I liked her well enough, but compared to Seasons 2 & 3 there's not really that much depth to her.

    Auruo posted: »

    Overrated Kenny (um yeah yikes to the extreme) Luke (I liked him at first, but then I realized how boring his character is) Clementine (i

  • edited January 2017

    Overrated: Lee

    Underrated: Kenny

    (yes, this is a joke post)

  • That's not surprising given their "alternatives/competition".

    Also almost every play through I've seen, people obsess over both of them too.

  • Kenny is by far the most overrated character there is.

  • Overrated:

    • Kenny
    • Luke
    • Nick
    • Javier
    • David

    Underrated:

    • Sarita
    • Edith
    • Christa
    • Randy
    • Patricia
    • Gill
    • Carlos
  • On these forums, I'm starting to find him underrated...

    El chapo posted: »

    Kenny is by far the most overrated character there is.

  • Hmm, I'm kinda curious, how can you say that Randy and Gill are underrated characters if they literally have no development at all and a determinant 5-minute cameo?

    Overrated: * Kenny * Luke * Nick * Javier * David Underrated: * Sarita * Edith * Christa * Randy * Patricia * Gill * Carlos

  • Why did you name them and NOT Patricia?

    Hmm, I'm kinda curious, how can you say that Randy and Gill are underrated characters if they literally have no development at all and a determinant 5-minute cameo?

  • Eh...I wanna say it evens out a bit, but I guess can sorta agree.

    El chapo posted: »

    Kenny is by far the most overrated character there is.

  • edited February 2017

    Overrated:
    1. Carley (there will be a joke)
    2. Rebecca (shes pregnant and...thats about it. I'm missing some characterisation)
    3. Luke (till episode 3 I thought he would be a secret pedophile, which is NOT good in terms of developing a good character)

    Underrated:
    1. Doug (get the joke? Still, good guy)
    2. Ben (he may be, well, Ben, but he has interesting character development. And one single awesome scene)
    3. Chuck (hes what my apocalypse partner should be: a bit rough, but caring, friendly and helpful)

  • Arvo

    lolno

    CunningFox posted: »

    Overrated: Kenny Carver Pete Carley Underrated: Gabe Alvin Doug Arvo

  • I didn't notice that Patricia was in the list, otherwise I would've named her too.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Why did you name them and NOT Patricia?

  • CarLeeForeverCarLeeForever Banned
    edited February 2017

    Double-post, ignore.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Why did you name them and NOT Patricia?

  • Okay, just wanted to make fun of that. "Oh, Randy and Gil are SO ovverated, but dat Patricia? Mm-mm-MMN!" :lol:

    I didn't notice that Patricia was in the list, otherwise I would've named her too.

  • I personally really do not like him.

    On these forums, I'm starting to find him underrated...

  • He's psychotic.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Eh...I wanna say it evens out a bit, but I guess can sorta agree.

  • edited February 2017

    A lof of people here don't.

    I respect your opinion btw
    El chapo posted: »

    I personally really do not like him.

  • More like rabid and volatile, but sure.

    El chapo posted: »

    He's psychotic.

  • I find a lot of people really do like him, just players in general too not just people from the forums, I belong to the 15% of people that don't like him and that like Jane, but I believe this choice comes down to people's personalities and how they view his pros and cons, obviously.

    i also respect yours.

    A lof of people here don't. I respect your opinion btw

  • Rabid? Bro he doesn't have rabies how can you suggest he's rabid?

    DabigRG posted: »

    More like rabid and volatile, but sure.

  • The fact that he looks like a pitbull gettin ready to bite at times.

    El chapo posted: »

    Rabid? Bro he doesn't have rabies how can you suggest he's rabid?

  • Ahh right, yeah he's an asshole

    DabigRG posted: »

    The fact that he looks like a pitbull gettin ready to bite at times.

  • Overrated

    Luke, I don't understand why everyone loved him so much. He was annoying and boring.

    Nate, creepy as hell

    Underrated

    Katjaa and Sarita, you think they would be more popular with how popular Kenny is but sadly no. Most of his other fans don't care about them.

    Carlos

    Alvin

  • edited February 2017

    Carly. ( She was simply a great character, and I'm sorry that we didn't get to have her around for longer than we did.)

    Chuck. - ( In the short time Chuck was apart of the group, he contributed quite a bit with his upbeat spirit, and his willingness to sacrifice himself for Clementine.)

    Alvin. - ( He may not have been an assertive type of Man, like Kenny was for example, but when push came to shove, he was definitely a Pillar of Strength.)

    Pete - ( I say that because of how short a time he was around in the game. We never really got to see what he could do, or how he could help the group, especially when Kenny was going through his loss of Sarita.

    Pete was assertive, yet he was also a calm voice of reason. He wasn't somebody who went off half-cocked, but he thought about the situation, and how best to respond to it, before he made a move.

    And in a survival situation, that's how you have to be, you have think about every move that you make before you make it, as it could have lasting repercussions.

    By his own admission, Pete was also an expert at reading people. And that is a skill that is invaluable.

  • Ah, so just underrrated characters?

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    Carly. ( She was simply a great character, and I'm sorry that we didn't get to have her around for longer than we did.) Chuck. - ( In th

  • Okay then, let's see how things have changed since the newest episode

    Overrated
    Tripp

    Underrated
    Kate
    Dr. Lingard
    Joan?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.