Carley was pushing Lilly's buttons from the time we saw them, carley calling kenny " boss" when they had only just met him was just a dig at… more Lilly .
Carley couldn't even work out how to put batteries in a radio , and threatened lee to tell the group about his past or she would
It was a situation where someone had a secret deal with the bandits leading to the destruction of the place they called home for 3 months that Lilly was largely in control of. Lilly was trying to pinpoint who the person was, either ben or carley.
I know how much was lost. She used the traitor card to go after Carley, there's a reason she doesn't accuse Doug, she clearly hated Carley from the get-go, the face she makes when Carley calls Kenny boss tells you all you need to know.
When carley said those choice words to her face, shefigured it was her.
When Carley said those choice words, Lilly got angry and butthurt and she couldn't take what she was dishing out. Swearing doesn't mean your guilty.
Should she have shot her? I don’t know.
Answer would be a big fat no. She had no evidence or reason to kill her in cold blood.
How do you deal with a rat that sells out your own group?
Maybe find out who the rat is before taking precaution and not shoot someone just for calling you a bad word.
It was a situation where someone had a secret deal with the bandits leading to the destruction of the place they called home for 3 months th… moreat Lilly was largely in control of. Lilly was trying to pinpoint who the person was, either ben or carley. When carley said those choice words to her face, shefigured it was her. Should she have shot her? I don’t know. How do you deal with a rat that sells out your own group?
My problems with lilly are largely based off of TFS lilly, but in S1 she is still one of my favorite characters.
Carley was pushing Lilly's buttons from the time we saw them, carley calling kenny " boss" when they had only just met him was just a dig at Lilly .
Boss could've been a nickname she gave Kenny since he was giving out orders, during the 3 months, Carley never gave Lilly attitude so I doubt she meant offense when she called someone boss. Let's just say you're right, does that justify her being murdered?
Carley couldn't even work out how to put batteries in a radio
And Lilly couldn't even watch supplies properly when an idiot like Ben stole it from under her nose. Everybody's got flaws, doesn't mean Carley should've died because she can't work batteries.
and threatened lee to tell the group about his past or she would
Seriously???!!! Did you pay attention when you played the game? All Carley said that she knew his past and "if" he was trouble then there would be a problem but other than that she said she'd keep Lee's secret and did she rat you out within the 3 months? no, but your friend Lilly did but apparently Carley's the bitch in this scenario?
Carley was pushing Lilly's buttons from the time we saw them, carley calling kenny " boss" when they had only just met him was just a dig at… more Lilly .
Carley couldn't even work out how to put batteries in a radio , and threatened lee to tell the group about his past or she would
There s something that really bothers me when people say that Lily isnt redeemable... Its true she s probably done horrible things and already did horrible things during the time we havent seen her but if Negan and the Joker can be redeemed then i dont see how its impossible for Lily to get redeemed in this game.
There s something that really bothers me when people say that Lily isnt redeemable... Its true she s probably done horrible things and alrea… moredy did horrible things during the time we havent seen her but if Negan and the Joker can be redeemed then i dont see how its impossible for Lily to get redeemed in this game.
There s something that really bothers me when people say that Lily isnt redeemable... Its true she s probably done horrible things and alrea… moredy did horrible things during the time we havent seen her but if Negan and the Joker can be redeemed then i dont see how its impossible for Lily to get redeemed in this game.
There’s a dialogue option where Lee can suggest it was carley who did it. Carley speaking up to Lilly is the equivalent of a suspect mouthing off a cop who is trying to get information. Carley wasn’t making the situation any better and was making it harder for lilly to pry Ben for evidence. This isn’t about preferring lilly or carley as characters, but Carley didn’t care about losing the motor inn anywhere near as much as Lilly was. Having a betrayer in the group is like treason in the military, it’s not something you can just hold off for later. I have no evidence for this but I think after shooting carley, lilly was gonna lay off of ben. I wholeheartedly believe that Lilly, despite having beef with carley, figured it was her who was responsible for the bandit attack.
It was a situation where someone had a secret deal with the bandits leading to the destruction of the place they called home for 3 months th… moreat Lilly was largely in control of. Lilly was trying to pinpoint who the person was, either ben or carley.
I know how much was lost. She used the traitor card to go after Carley, there's a reason she doesn't accuse Doug, she clearly hated Carley from the get-go, the face she makes when Carley calls Kenny boss tells you all you need to know.
When carley said those choice words to her face, shefigured it was her.
When Carley said those choice words, Lilly got angry and butthurt and she couldn't take what she was dishing out. Swearing doesn't mean your guilty.
Should she have shot her? I don’t know.
Answer would be a big fat no. She had no evidence or reason to kill her in cold blood.
How do you deal with a rat that sells out your own group?
Maybe find out wh… [view original content]
Like her dislike her I fucking love it! It makes her so much fun to discuss.
Honestly Lilly has to be one of my favotite characters of all time it's not because I defend her character at every given oppertunity or that I like her that much as a person but it's because the way she is written. I was against the idea of her being the villian in S4 but fuck it I love her as villian and hope to see her backstory soon or else it will kind of fall flat and her backstory matters to me if the game allows me to kill her or not.
I never liked it though that Telltale put all her work in the background and not show it on screen, I do understand from a writing's point of view because when Carley says ''Try helping someone for once'' against Lilly we should have a option to defend her.
There’s a dialogue option where Lee can suggest it was carley who did it.
I'm aware there is a dialogue to kiss up to Lilly but that doesn't make her guilty.
Carley speaking up to Lilly is the equivalent of a suspect mouthing off a cop who is trying to get information. Carley wasn’t making the situation any better and was making it harder for lilly to pry Ben for evidence.
Cops question suspects, they don't threaten someone to falsely point the finger at someone they dislike, that is what Lilly was doing, she was fingerpointing. Watch the scene again, she accused Carley first even going as far as to insult her family, then pushed Ben to point the finger at her, what was she supposed to do when a bully is harassing her and pressuring a scared teen into fingering her for something she didn't do? don't tell me even you wouldn't have lost your temper if someone was doing that to you.
This isn’t about preferring lilly or carley as characters, but Carley didn’t care about losing the motor inn anywhere near as much as Lilly was.
We didn't know how Carley felt about losing the motor inn, we can't assume she didn't give a rats ass just because she never showed it. Did it justify Lilly shooting her dead?
Having a betrayer in the group is like treason in the military, it’s not something you can just hold off for later.
But that doesn't mean the person in charge should shoot anyone over an insult, he/she would get the death penalty.
I have no evidence for this but I think after shooting carley, lilly was gonna lay off of ben. I wholeheartedly believe that Lilly, despite having beef with carley, figured it was her who was responsible for the bandit attack.
Then why didn't she accuse Doug? it was more of a vendetta than finding the culprit. Even if she did lay off Ben, the damage was done.
There’s a dialogue option where Lee can suggest it was carley who did it. Carley speaking up to Lilly is the equivalent of a suspect mouthin… moreg off a cop who is trying to get information. Carley wasn’t making the situation any better and was making it harder for lilly to pry Ben for evidence. This isn’t about preferring lilly or carley as characters, but Carley didn’t care about losing the motor inn anywhere near as much as Lilly was. Having a betrayer in the group is like treason in the military, it’s not something you can just hold off for later. I have no evidence for this but I think after shooting carley, lilly was gonna lay off of ben. I wholeheartedly believe that Lilly, despite having beef with carley, figured it was her who was responsible for the bandit attack.
Comments
You think Carley disliking Lilly makes it justifiable for Lilly to murder her?
This season’s storytelling is pretty good so far, even great.
It has better writing to say the least...screw IGN!
No,just stating what a bitch Carley was
Nyeh...
Hell yeah.
According to Lilly's fanbase, the answer would be yes.
I know how much was lost. She used the traitor card to go after Carley, there's a reason she doesn't accuse Doug, she clearly hated Carley from the get-go, the face she makes when Carley calls Kenny boss tells you all you need to know.
When Carley said those choice words, Lilly got angry and butthurt and she couldn't take what she was dishing out. Swearing doesn't mean your guilty.
Answer would be a big fat no. She had no evidence or reason to kill her in cold blood.
Maybe find out who the rat is before taking precaution and not shoot someone just for calling you a bad word.
Boss could've been a nickname she gave Kenny since he was giving out orders, during the 3 months, Carley never gave Lilly attitude so I doubt she meant offense when she called someone boss. Let's just say you're right, does that justify her being murdered?
And Lilly couldn't even watch supplies properly when an idiot like Ben stole it from under her nose. Everybody's got flaws, doesn't mean Carley should've died because she can't work batteries.
Seriously???!!! Did you pay attention when you played the game? All Carley said that she knew his past and "if" he was trouble then there would be a problem but other than that she said she'd keep Lee's secret and did she rat you out within the 3 months? no, but your friend Lilly did but apparently Carley's the bitch in this scenario?
There s something that really bothers me when people say that Lily isnt redeemable... Its true she s probably done horrible things and already did horrible things during the time we havent seen her but if Negan and the Joker can be redeemed then i dont see how its impossible for Lily to get redeemed in this game.
Because she's not on Kenny's side, if you wanna generalize it into some tangible shape.
Where Not Too Far Gone.
-Rick Grimes
There’s a dialogue option where Lee can suggest it was carley who did it. Carley speaking up to Lilly is the equivalent of a suspect mouthing off a cop who is trying to get information. Carley wasn’t making the situation any better and was making it harder for lilly to pry Ben for evidence. This isn’t about preferring lilly or carley as characters, but Carley didn’t care about losing the motor inn anywhere near as much as Lilly was. Having a betrayer in the group is like treason in the military, it’s not something you can just hold off for later. I have no evidence for this but I think after shooting carley, lilly was gonna lay off of ben. I wholeheartedly believe that Lilly, despite having beef with carley, figured it was her who was responsible for the bandit attack.
Like her dislike her I fucking love it! It makes her so much fun to discuss.
Honestly Lilly has to be one of my favotite characters of all time it's not because I defend her character at every given oppertunity or that I like her that much as a person but it's because the way she is written. I was against the idea of her being the villian in S4 but fuck it I love her as villian and hope to see her backstory soon or else it will kind of fall flat and her backstory matters to me if the game allows me to kill her or not.
I never liked it though that Telltale put all her work in the background and not show it on screen, I do understand from a writing's point of view because when Carley says ''Try helping someone for once'' against Lilly we should have a option to defend her.
I'm aware there is a dialogue to kiss up to Lilly but that doesn't make her guilty.
Cops question suspects, they don't threaten someone to falsely point the finger at someone they dislike, that is what Lilly was doing, she was fingerpointing. Watch the scene again, she accused Carley first even going as far as to insult her family, then pushed Ben to point the finger at her, what was she supposed to do when a bully is harassing her and pressuring a scared teen into fingering her for something she didn't do? don't tell me even you wouldn't have lost your temper if someone was doing that to you.
We didn't know how Carley felt about losing the motor inn, we can't assume she didn't give a rats ass just because she never showed it. Did it justify Lilly shooting her dead?
But that doesn't mean the person in charge should shoot anyone over an insult, he/she would get the death penalty.
Then why didn't she accuse Doug? it was more of a vendetta than finding the culprit. Even if she did lay off Ben, the damage was done.