It's pointless to discuss the amount though. In my experience there are far more Jane sympathizers, but maybe i just feel that way because I had the ending where I left with Kenny.
Whether or not there actually are more of either is not a argument I'm going to make, my poin was just that you can clearly hear both sides.
Because the person you replied to originally was talking about who was primarily responsible.
Now, it wasn't all the Kenny fans' fault, b… moreut they are the most hateful group on here when faced with another opinion, and they're the main people trying to invalidate our choices.
It's relevant because you replied to a post which talked about it.
There is no "right" or "wrong", but there IS a better and worse. For your Clem, no, but for the player, yes.
The Kenny ending sequence has feels and a hard decision.
The Jane ending sequence has a hard, impacting decison.
The alone ending is the logical ending.
Which one is worse, for my Clem, the Kenny/Jane, but as a person watching the endings, being alone was the weakest. No choices, or even DIALOGUE.
It's pointless to discuss the amount though. In my experience there are far more Jane sympathizers, but maybe i just feel that way because I… more had the ending where I left with Kenny.
Whether or not there actually are more of either is not a argument I'm going to make, my poin was just that you can clearly hear both sides.
Firstly, Jane is always prepared for danger, and secondly being in wellington could totally be as dangerous. There are guns all around.
You're just assuming specific things. You're being prescriptive where you should be descriptive.
They don't seem to listen to anyone else for the most part and just insult loads of characters people like just because they aren't Kenny.
It's SO childish.
The game is made to show that pretty much every choice is the right one. Every ending is coerent and make you feel that you did a good thing. So no,there's not really any best ending. We can talk about how some endings are more sad than others,but not "better".
Well here's my take on the whole 'Family' thing you were talking about, when you let them in, it's not the fact that they have the gun that was worrying Clem, if you saw at the gate, the Dad looked like he was reaching back for something until you accepted him in, when you do, he's not longer alert and stops, but Clem notices that the gun was there and is worried that he was going to pull it if she turned them away.
...and a family arrives.You turn them down,the dad looks mad,and you see he has a gun.If you let them in,once again the camera zooms on the … moregun he has.Jane and Clem make eye contact and Jane follows him.Clem could be in danger,while I totally trust Wellington.The ending where she is alone is the less safe option for your Clem.
Well here's my take on the whole 'Family' thing you were talking about, when you let them in, it's not the fact that they have the gun that … morewas worrying Clem, if you saw at the gate, the Dad looked like he was reaching back for something until you accepted him in, when you do, he's not longer alert and stops, but Clem notices that the gun was there and is worried that he was going to pull it if she turned them away.
I am convinced the Jane ending is the evil ending while alone is neutral and Kennny is good. Seriously, the Kenny endings adjust way better than the others
I shot Kenny too, and I was conflicted for a while because I think that the endings of Kenny, compared to the ones of Jane, are just SO much… more better and emotional. The endings of Jane look really... dull to me. However I am convinced that I did the right thing, even if it was incredibly sad and heartbreaking.
It's not about knowing him from season 1 (wich helps because there is clearly a bond) it's about Kenny being the person that cared THE MOST out of anyone for Clementine (as of season2) he would kill or die for Clementine. People call him insane , i say he has short temper (he always had, it's just intensified now) he was right about Arvo , he was right about Jane. Because you see, It wasn't just a test , it was her plan to kill Kenny without Clementine hating her. At any point she could have revealed the truth about AJ but she didn't. She wanted to be alone with Clem and go south. At this point , i'll take him over anyone , anyday.
I add that 85% who saved Kenny are TeamMustache fans that have the reason of "knowing him from season 1"....
I know, Jane did a fucking s… moretupid thing and she was an asshole for that thing, but now don't come here and write that she was fucking wrong!! Kenny was broken!! There is not take it anymore! Imagine if someone had killed the baby; he would come out of his head ... and god knows what he would do .... (just think of Arvo)... and then, he wanted to die... so, being sorry for Kenny and respecting other opinions, and knowing that however final with Kenny is the best, i chose Jane.
I add that 85% who saved Kenny are TeamMustache fans that have the reason of "knowing him from season 1"....
I know, Jane did a fucking s… moretupid thing and she was an asshole for that thing, but now don't come here and write that she was fucking wrong!! Kenny was broken!! There is not take it anymore! Imagine if someone had killed the baby; he would come out of his head ... and god knows what he would do .... (just think of Arvo)... and then, he wanted to die... so, being sorry for Kenny and respecting other opinions, and knowing that however final with Kenny is the best, i chose Jane.
No offense, but your argument here has taken a turn for the hypocritical, You're saying respect other's opinions on the matter and that no choice is correct, yet you keep bashing Kenny's fans constantly, not to say I'm a Kenny fan because he was off the rails, but regardless, your argument is invalid here.
They don't seem to listen to anyone else for the most part and just insult loads of characters people like just because they aren't Kenny.
It's SO childish.
Does the fact that, as far as Kenny knows, Jane accidentally lost the baby justify murdering her?
In my game, that is not what happened, I didn't want them to kill each other, but nobody listens to Clementine. The thing though is, Jane started this, she hid the baby and acted like it was dead to fight Kenny. So in my game, she is dead.
Does the fact that, as far as Kenny knows, Jane accidentally lost the baby justify murdering her?
Sure, if she did it on purpose, that would be more understandable. But as far as he knew, it was an accident.
No offense, but your argument here has taken a turn for the hypocritical, You're saying respect other's opinions on the matter and that no c… morehoice is correct, yet you keep bashing Kenny's fans constantly, not to say I'm a Kenny fan because he was off the rails, but regardless, your argument is invalid here.
There is no "85% who saved kenny" - if you're talking about endgame statistics then you've forgotten that there are 5 endings not 2 and they… more are calculated separately so:
15% with jane and family (my playthrough)
x with jane without family
x with kenny - left kenny
x with kenny - stayed with kenny
x alone
I am convinced the Jane ending is the evil ending while alone is neutral and Kennny is good. Seriously, the Kenny endings adjust way better than the others
Firstly, Jane is always prepared for danger, and secondly being in wellington could totally be as dangerous. There are guns all around.
You're just assuming specific things. You're being prescriptive where you should be descriptive.
Does the fact that, as far as Kenny knows, Jane accidentally lost the baby justify murdering her?
In my game, that is not what happe… morened, I didn't want them to kill each other, but nobody listens to Clementine. The thing though is, Jane started this, she hid the baby and acted like it was dead to fight Kenny. So in my game, she is dead.
When I say I think the decision of the Kenny fans is wrong for MY clementine, I still respect that it's a valid one. I just think it's wrong for MY clementine, but that's fine for theirs.
As I say, discussing the situation is fine, it's awesome. But I NEVER state my opinion as fact, and NEVER say that my ending was the only good one and everyone's is stupid. Which is what the thread is directed against. Such as, saying Lee would hate you if you shoot Kenny.
No offense, but your argument here has taken a turn for the hypocritical, You're saying respect other's opinions on the matter and that no c… morehoice is correct, yet you keep bashing Kenny's fans constantly, not to say I'm a Kenny fan because he was off the rails, but regardless, your argument is invalid here.
The choice between Kenny and Jane is morally grey.
Kenny threw the first punch and tried to kill Jane for accidentally (as far as he was told) losing the baby. That's not morally good, that's at the edge of morally neutral.
Nope... If we can call good evil and neutral (that they are not) they will be like these:
Good ---> Kenny
Good / Evil ---> Jane and Invite Family in / Jane and leave Family
Neutral ---> Alone
I am convinced the Jane ending is the evil ending while alone is neutral and Kennny is good. Seriously, the Kenny endings adjust way better than the others
Comments
It's pointless to discuss the amount though. In my experience there are far more Jane sympathizers, but maybe i just feel that way because I had the ending where I left with Kenny.
Whether or not there actually are more of either is not a argument I'm going to make, my poin was just that you can clearly hear both sides.
yeah right, you vvent vvith bonnie and mike
There is no "right" or "wrong", but there IS a better and worse. For your Clem, no, but for the player, yes.
The Kenny ending sequence has feels and a hard decision.
The Jane ending sequence has a hard, impacting decison.
The alone ending is the logical ending.
Which one is worse, for my Clem, the Kenny/Jane, but as a person watching the endings, being alone was the weakest. No choices, or even DIALOGUE.
I don't know how long you've been on this forum, but trust me, Kenny supporters are the biggest, loudest group here.
Of course you can hear both sides, but that doesn't mean both sides have equal numerical support, which this comment chain is about.
Ok, vvhile you believe in that, me and Kenneth and the baby are gonna be vvalkin, k?
TeamJane
XD
vvatever Tiny Tim :P
< Speaks Russian >
kinda like Kenny XD
The game is made to show that pretty much every choice is the right one. Every ending is coerent and make you feel that you did a good thing. So no,there's not really any best ending. We can talk about how some endings are more sad than others,but not "better".
Well here's my take on the whole 'Family' thing you were talking about, when you let them in, it's not the fact that they have the gun that was worrying Clem, if you saw at the gate, the Dad looked like he was reaching back for something until you accepted him in, when you do, he's not longer alert and stops, but Clem notices that the gun was there and is worried that he was going to pull it if she turned them away.
I couldn't believe you can just let kenny Kill Jane and then shoot immediately kenny afterwards.
speak american you ruskie shitbird
shoots you in the shoulder vviff trader Mike and betch Bonnie, giving u a flashback
oh no, the flash back feels, duck is gonna die zzzzzzz
Funny, that
Food....food....place....no lie......food
You're wrong.
call this a house, it isn't even built yet ARRGHH!!
[punch the ruskie]
Well, Jane noticed the gun, and I think with her Clem is safe.... she's the best
I am convinced the Jane ending is the evil ending while alone is neutral and Kennny is good. Seriously, the Kenny endings adjust way better than the others
I hate when people say my choice to shoot Kenny was wrong. No such thing. I made the choice i felt was right.
It's not about knowing him from season 1 (wich helps because there is clearly a bond) it's about Kenny being the person that cared THE MOST out of anyone for Clementine (as of season2) he would kill or die for Clementine. People call him insane , i say he has short temper (he always had, it's just intensified now) he was right about Arvo , he was right about Jane. Because you see, It wasn't just a test , it was her plan to kill Kenny without Clementine hating her. At any point she could have revealed the truth about AJ but she didn't. She wanted to be alone with Clem and go south. At this point , i'll take him over anyone , anyday.
sorry , doubleplost
No offense, but your argument here has taken a turn for the hypocritical, You're saying respect other's opinions on the matter and that no choice is correct, yet you keep bashing Kenny's fans constantly, not to say I'm a Kenny fan because he was off the rails, but regardless, your argument is invalid here.
There are jerk fans on both sides. I'm a kenny fan.
In my game, that is not what happened, I didn't want them to kill each other, but nobody listens to Clementine. The thing though is, Jane started this, she hid the baby and acted like it was dead to fight Kenny. So in my game, she is dead.
Its not his fault, he has PTSD like me.
No, it's according to me xD
Nope... If we can call good evil and neutral (that they are not) they will be like these:
Good ---> Kenny
Good / Evil ---> Jane and Invite Family in / Jane and leave Family
Neutral ---> Alone
K.
Yes but if you kill Kenny you are useless
What? Um no.
In every game Jane says it was an accident, I believe.
Let me guess:
You just had a 'I don't understand what you're saying but I know it's bullshit' moment.
omg wtf a Kenny fan is disrespecting the opinion of another
Shocking McShocking.
No, it isn't.
When I say I think the decision of the Kenny fans is wrong for MY clementine, I still respect that it's a valid one. I just think it's wrong for MY clementine, but that's fine for theirs.
As I say, discussing the situation is fine, it's awesome. But I NEVER state my opinion as fact, and NEVER say that my ending was the only good one and everyone's is stupid. Which is what the thread is directed against. Such as, saying Lee would hate you if you shoot Kenny.
trolololol
Uh, no.
No, no.
The choice between Kenny and Jane is morally grey.
Kenny threw the first punch and tried to kill Jane for accidentally (as far as he was told) losing the baby. That's not morally good, that's at the edge of morally neutral.
Similarly, Jane is very morality neutral.
Neither decision is 'morally good'.
That's because the writers love Kenny, not because it's actually the good ending.