No one wants to die. I think she told her to stay out of it to not get hurt, but in the end she was panicking and didn't want to die. I don't blame her for not telling him AJ is safe, it would have made him MORE angry for tricking him.
Maybe she wanted to die? No, wait, she was asking Clem to help, despite telling her not to get involved, despite all she had to do was tell Kenny that AJ was still alive to get him to stop. Holy crap, Jane became a complete idiot all of a sudden.
Yeah , i did listen to Kenny but not Jane, wanna know why? Because he made good points, and she didn't , all she says was :hurrr i'm sorry i… more TOTALLY didn't expect him to get this mad if i spent the whole day picking on him , talking shit about his past , then i pretend like i got one of the two things he cares about the most killed.
And as i said before , she had a good chance of stopping what happened , but didn't.
The idea of Clementine getting shot and shooting back just persuaded me , Clem can't defend and offense I know for sure Jane wouldn't want that for the baby and Clem.You fully persuaded me I just want Jane to survive and the place that she want is Howe's , If only Jane went to Wellington.If want Jane I have to get Howe's.Oh well.
I know going with Jane will indirectly lead her to survive with her , they were just returning to the hardware store to grab the load of supplies and go.I think if they stay in Howe's for a while after all of their options will be over I guess they can go back to Wellington.I think Jane knows perfectly that Wellington is a safe haven , she just thought that because of the baby they won't find it in time.
That means both of us know that Howe's is temporary , right?
One. If Howe's is such a great place, then how come it's abandoned? Where are the rest of the 400 Days crew? What happened to the guards? We… morere they overwhelmed? Did they leave Howe's for good? Why would they if they still had all that security and safety, all that food and weaponry? If it was such a good place to stay, why didn't they stay? How come it isn't already occupied with survivors before Clem and Jane showed up? You'll probably just say that the herd chased them away, or killed them all. If true, would the same happen to Clem and Jane? Would they, too, be overwhelmed? Where would they go with a swarm of walkers infesting the hardware store? They'd be trapped. If a band of survivors came, would they too be equipped with equal firepower to the arsenal at Howe's? It's still putting Clem in danger, either way. Walkers and scavengers, Clem would have to deal with that. Clementine would have to be shot at, and she'd also be the one shootin… [view original content]
The idea of Clementine getting shot and shooting back just persuaded me , Clem can't defend and offense I know for sure Jane wouldn't want t… morehat for the baby and Clem.You fully persuaded me I just want Jane to survive and the place that she want is Howe's , If only Jane went to Wellington.If want Jane I have to get Howe's.Oh well.
I know going with Jane will indirectly lead her to survive with her , they were just returning to the hardware store to grab the load of supplies and go.I think if they stay in Howe's for a while after all of their options will be over I guess they can go back to Wellington.I think Jane knows perfectly that Wellington is a safe haven , she just thought that because of the baby they won't find it in time.
That means both of us know that Howe's is temporary , right?
Correct. I'd like to add that Jane kept provoking Kenny the whole time up until their fight. Remember how she kept antagonizing him in the car? She intentionally pushed him over the edge.... and HE knew that, that's why he reacted so violently. I don't think he'd ever do that to someone he cares about. Jane even compared him to Carver (the guy who'd make a father hit his daughter). She went out of her way to demonize him.
Jane is like a typical government. Trying to make it look like she's in the right, no matter the cost.
I think he'd be mad (a lot of people would be), but I don't think he'd go as far as he did with Jane, or hit her or anything. He'd probably … morejust how he reacted to the Sarita situation.
The reason he flipped out on Jane was because he thought she killed the baby, because she didn't want it around in the first place. I don't agree with how he reacted to Jane, but I can kind of understand why he would think that way. He knows that Clem wouldn't kill the baby.
Correct. I'd like to add that Jane kept provoking Kenny the whole time up until their fight. Remember how she kept antagonizing him in the c… morear? She intentionally pushed him over the edge.... and HE knew that, that's why he reacted so violently. I don't think he'd ever do that to someone he cares about. Jane even compared him to Carver (the guy who'd make a father hit his daughter). She went out of her way to demonize him.
Jane is like a typical government. Trying to make it look like she's in the right, no matter the cost.
You chose Jane, which makes sense the first time in the heat of the moment, but did you stick with her?
In all cases, going alone in the end has to be considered the true ending since we don't know exactly where Clem is, and for all we know, the timeline of that last scene maybe after something happens to Jane's ending or Kenny's ending in S3.
I add that 85% who saved Kenny are TeamMustache fans that have the reason of "knowing him from season 1"....
I know, Jane did a fucking s… moretupid thing and she was an asshole for that thing, but now don't come here and write that she was fucking wrong!! Kenny was broken!! There is not take it anymore! Imagine if someone had killed the baby; he would come out of his head ... and god knows what he would do .... (just think of Arvo)... and then, he wanted to die... so, being sorry for Kenny and respecting other opinions, and knowing that however final with Kenny is the best, i chose Jane.
Speaking of descriptive, Jane is prepared for danger against walkers, not humans. She buzzed the hell out when she stabbed Burricko I believe, and stashed her blade away when confronting Kenny. She's not prepared at all to take on the living, but for the case of Clem's safety, we don't know what she will do if trouble ensues.
Her wits and knowledge on survival only imply to walkers.
Firstly, Jane is always prepared for danger, and secondly being in wellington could totally be as dangerous. There are guns all around.
You're just assuming specific things. You're being prescriptive where you should be descriptive.
You chose Jane, which makes sense the first time in the heat of the moment, but did you stick with her?
In all cases, going alone in the … moreend has to be considered the true ending since we don't know exactly where Clem is, and for all we know, the timeline of that last scene maybe after something happens to Jane's ending or Kenny's ending in S3.
Oh, it has nothing to do with disrespect. It's just a fact that Telltale favors one ending, that being the Wellington one.
With that I mean:
It's the only ending that has real feels, other than killing Kenny in the Howe arc.
It's longer than most of the others.
It's better written (just my opinion).
It contains Wellington, which played a quiet big, but subtle role this whole Season.
It gives Kenny a chance to redeem himself, even for all those who later doubted Kenny did the right thing (which he, fair enough, didn't, but you get the idea). It actually pays off not to kill Kenny.
It's the only ending where Clem is 100% safe. No, with Jane she isn't, Howe's was completley surprised by the herd, and they were 20+ people. Just look at Wellington's walls.
For me, and I'm sure for Nick Breckon too, this is the ending. I'm not saying in any way your endings or decisions are wrong, but even from an objective point of view this is the better ending, simply because Breckon clearly wrote way longer on it.
The other endings are just endings, especially the 'Clem alone' ending is ridiculously short and boring. The Jane endings are better, but I still just see them as endings, not as something as special as Season 1 or Season 2 Wellington ending.
When people get a non-Kenny ending, they regret it and feel unsatisfied.
When they see what could have happened if they stuck with Kenny, they feel even worse.
When people get a Kenny ending, they don't regret it for a second.
The two Kenny endings are the Good Endings, in every sense of the phrase. They are more rewarding, cathartic, emotional, powerful, complete on every level imaginable.
If you didn't stick with Kenny? You failed. You lost the game. More than that you failed Clementine...and Lee.
You quit. You gave up. You got duped. You got railroaded into a bad ending.
I understand if this makes you mad or bad or sad, but just remember...you can rewind at any time and make it right.
Comments
No one wants to die. I think she told her to stay out of it to not get hurt, but in the end she was panicking and didn't want to die. I don't blame her for not telling him AJ is safe, it would have made him MORE angry for tricking him.
I don't think this argument should continue, I've had the same debate with like four different people. Let's just agree to disagree.
false that
really
so first you fuck up by thinking the post you're replying to is anti-jane
then you say false that
that dOESN'T MAKE SENSE OK
The idea of Clementine getting shot and shooting back just persuaded me , Clem can't defend and offense I know for sure Jane wouldn't want that for the baby and Clem.You fully persuaded me I just want Jane to survive and the place that she want is Howe's , If only Jane went to Wellington.If want Jane I have to get Howe's.Oh well.
I know going with Jane will indirectly lead her to survive with her , they were just returning to the hardware store to grab the load of supplies and go.I think if they stay in Howe's for a while after all of their options will be over I guess they can go back to Wellington.I think Jane knows perfectly that Wellington is a safe haven , she just thought that because of the baby they won't find it in time.
That means both of us know that Howe's is temporary , right?
Jane never believed in Wellington, dude. I don't think she'd want to go back-tracking after going all the way back to Howe's just to look for it.
You never know.
Correct. I'd like to add that Jane kept provoking Kenny the whole time up until their fight. Remember how she kept antagonizing him in the car? She intentionally pushed him over the edge.... and HE knew that, that's why he reacted so violently. I don't think he'd ever do that to someone he cares about. Jane even compared him to Carver (the guy who'd make a father hit his daughter). She went out of her way to demonize him.
Jane is like a typical government. Trying to make it look like she's in the right, no matter the cost.
You chose Jane, which makes sense the first time in the heat of the moment, but did you stick with her?
In all cases, going alone in the end has to be considered the true ending since we don't know exactly where Clem is, and for all we know, the timeline of that last scene maybe after something happens to Jane's ending or Kenny's ending in S3.
Speaking of descriptive, Jane is prepared for danger against walkers, not humans. She buzzed the hell out when she stabbed Burricko I believe, and stashed her blade away when confronting Kenny. She's not prepared at all to take on the living, but for the case of Clem's safety, we don't know what she will do if trouble ensues.
Her wits and knowledge on survival only imply to walkers.
Because I felt that she deserved forgiveness.
Oh, it has nothing to do with disrespect. It's just a fact that Telltale favors one ending, that being the Wellington one.
With that I mean:
It's the only ending that has real feels, other than killing Kenny in the Howe arc.
It's longer than most of the others.
It's better written (just my opinion).
It contains Wellington, which played a quiet big, but subtle role this whole Season.
It gives Kenny a chance to redeem himself, even for all those who later doubted Kenny did the right thing (which he, fair enough, didn't, but you get the idea). It actually pays off not to kill Kenny.
It's the only ending where Clem is 100% safe. No, with Jane she isn't, Howe's was completley surprised by the herd, and they were 20+ people. Just look at Wellington's walls.
For me, and I'm sure for Nick Breckon too, this is the ending. I'm not saying in any way your endings or decisions are wrong, but even from an objective point of view this is the better ending, simply because Breckon clearly wrote way longer on it.
The other endings are just endings, especially the 'Clem alone' ending is ridiculously short and boring. The Jane endings are better, but I still just see them as endings, not as something as special as Season 1 or Season 2 Wellington ending.
When people get a non-Kenny ending, they regret it and feel unsatisfied.
When they see what could have happened if they stuck with Kenny, they feel even worse.
When people get a Kenny ending, they don't regret it for a second.
The two Kenny endings are the Good Endings, in every sense of the phrase. They are more rewarding, cathartic, emotional, powerful, complete on every level imaginable.
If you didn't stick with Kenny? You failed. You lost the game. More than that you failed Clementine...and Lee.
You quit. You gave up. You got duped. You got railroaded into a bad ending.
I understand if this makes you mad or bad or sad, but just remember...you can rewind at any time and make it right.