If the ending was

the originally planned Luke vs Kenny, which one would you save?

«13

Comments

  • Still would've picked Kenny.

  • Still Kenny

  • Wasn't it Kenny's voice actor that said that it was always meant to be Kenny vs. Jane, not Kenny vs. Luke? Either way, I'd still pick Kenny.

  • edited July 2015

    I can't see Luke playing the same plan as Jane did, and I can't really come up with a good justification for Kenny reasoning to want to kill Luke.

    Unless the Kenny vs Luke event goes down the road where both of them are in grave danger and you have to choose who to save.

    As for the choice, I would have chosen Luke.

  • Luke.

    Other people I'd rather save than Kenny are a Velocirapor hopped up on cocaine, an ISIS sympathizer, John Malkovich in like 90% of his films, Anton Chigurh, and Dick Cheney.

  • Depends on the circumstances. With Kenny trying to kill Jane I knew I had to stop him, but if it'd been a choice of running to save one or the other before walkers got at them for example, I'd be split.

    If it was Kenny trying to stab Luke like he did to Jane, then my decision wouldn't have changed, I'd of saved Luke like I saved Jane. For a decision on saving one or the other from zombie munching death, I still would've gone for Luke because I'd agree and have more trust in him [and he isn't so scary when he gets mad ^_^'] but I would've kept a separate save file for a Kenny outcome because I'd want to know how that'd go down too ;.; boat.

    But Jesus no baby hiding poop, it was stupid enough with Jane and there's no way Luke'd hide A.J.

  • What about a single kernel of corn? That'd be a tough choice for me.

    Luke. Other people I'd rather save than Kenny are a Velocirapor hopped up on cocaine, an ISIS sympathizer, John Malkovich in like 90% of his films, Anton Chigurh, and Dick Cheney.

  • The possibilities are endless.

    Flog61 posted: »

    What about a single kernel of corn? That'd be a tough choice for me.

  • Kenny. Luke and Jane didn't interest me and in later episodes actually got on my nerves.

  • I would definitely have chosen Luke, considering he's my favorite TWD S2 character

  • Depends on how it went down.

  • Luke he was cool. Kenny I couldn't get away from fast enough.

  • I'd spam the button to shoot Kenny if Luke were there instead of Jane.

  • It wouldn't have to be the same plan, Luke could be planning to leave with Clementine and the baby and leave Kenny. If they really wanted to show him being insane and unstable and have him attack Luke to stop it, leaving it to escalate from there. That would have been a much better way, instead of "lol bby not ded but u think it ded and that i kiled it, that makes u insane in the membrane"

    RichWalk23 posted: »

    I can't see Luke playing the same plan as Jane did, and I can't really come up with a good justification for Kenny reasoning to want to kill

  • I was never a fan of Luke or Jane so Kenny.

  • Kenny. Duh.

  • Even though Luke and Kenny were often at odds, I can't see Luke intentionally pushing Kenny's buttons. As for the question... Even though I like both characters, I'm going to have to say Kenny.

  • Wow, ridiculous! So if it was a member of ISIS or Osama Bin Laden and Kenny, you'd pick one of them over Ken right?

    Luke. Other people I'd rather save than Kenny are a Velocirapor hopped up on cocaine, an ISIS sympathizer, John Malkovich in like 90% of his films, Anton Chigurh, and Dick Cheney.

  • edited July 2015

    Put it like this. If Hitler, an ISIS member, and Kenny were chained up and I had two bullets in a gun, I'd shoot Kenny twice.

    dan290786 posted: »

    Wow, ridiculous! So if it was a member of ISIS or Osama Bin Laden and Kenny, you'd pick one of them over Ken right?

  • DeltinoDeltino Moderator
    edited July 2015

    It's a comedic exaggeration

    I'm officially declaring myself an officer of the fun police

    Stop it right now, before I am forced to arrest one of you for aggravated entertainment

    Oh yeah, I'm also going to abuse my new-found powers by posting this:

    Alt text

    dan290786 posted: »

    Wow, ridiculous! So if it was a member of ISIS or Osama Bin Laden and Kenny, you'd pick one of them over Ken right?

  • Always Luke.

  • Yes every one knows by now you have a irrational over the top hatred for a fictional character, get over it already you sound like a broken tape recorder.

    Luke. Other people I'd rather save than Kenny are a Velocirapor hopped up on cocaine, an ISIS sympathizer, John Malkovich in like 90% of his films, Anton Chigurh, and Dick Cheney.

  • get over it already

    Nah, I think I'll continue to stay under it.

    Yes every one knows by now you have a irrational over the top hatred for a fictional character, get over it already you sound like a broken tape recorder.

  • ^This guy gets it.

    Deltino posted: »

    It's a comedic exaggeration I'm officially declaring myself an officer of the fun police Stop it right now, before I am forced to arre

  • Suit yourself, it's just a little pathetic.

    get over it already Nah, I think I'll continue to stay under it.

  • Suit yourself

    Alt text

    Suit yourself, it's just a little pathetic.

  • Luke, for sure.

  • What's that? You're talking into my bad ear, sweetheart.

    Suit yourself

  • Alt text

    I know.

    What's that? You're talking into my bad ear, sweetheart.

  • Yeah, I think we could continue this pointless childish reply chain but thankfully I just remembered I dont use the internet as a dumping ground for my inner asshole, so have a nice day.

    I know.

  • Alt text

    Yeah, I think we could continue this pointless childish reply chain but thankfully I just remembered I dont use the internet as a dumping ground for my inner asshole, so have a nice day.

  • edited July 2015

    Depends on how it led up to it.

  • It would depend on the situation. Kennys my favourite character but I shot him because he was about to kill Jane (which was really hard for me by the way!)

  • Luke. It wouldn't even be a question.

    The season 2 finale choice is considered a "hard" choice only by those who legitimately liked Kenny, and came to like the other season 2 characters too. For those who didn't like Kenny since season 1, well...the choice to side with Kenny or not was already basically made in season 1, so it wasn't hard. In other words, it could be said that season 2 was a better game to you (with harder decisions) if you liked Kenny, but if you didn't like him, season 2 was a more mediocre game with not so tough decisions.

  • edited July 2015

    If I disagreed with Kenny, I'd kill Kenny. If I disagreed with Luke, I'd kill Luke. I didn't stop Kenny from killing Jane because she had technically put the illusion over him that AJ had died, and AJ was all Kenny had left. Think of it this way,I'll give you an example, if Kenny tried to kill Charles if he had murdered his Wife and Duck, would you kill Kenny?

  • Lol i dont think your serious but if you are, hating Kenny more than Hitler or ISIS makes you look like an idiot, sorry!

    Put it like this. If Hitler, an ISIS member, and Kenny were chained up and I had two bullets in a gun, I'd shoot Kenny twice.

  • photo image_5.jpg

    Put it like this. If Hitler, an ISIS member, and Kenny were chained up and I had two bullets in a gun, I'd shoot Kenny twice.

  • DeltinoDeltino Moderator

    Okay, I legitimately can't tell if you actually believe him, or if you're just playing along too

  • I'd shoot Kenny over Luke.

    Kenny is the direct or indirect cause of so many characters deaths throughout both seasons. He's irrational, dangerous, selfish and hypocritical. Not to mention a broken man, something that he himself admits.

    Luke may not be perfect but he is far more competant and helpful, he's also compassionate to people that AREN'T a member of his family unlike Kenny.

    I'd love to hear to why people think Kenny is the better choice. A lot of people have a nostalgic connection to Kenny in Season Two and therefore have more of an attatchment to him although what people seem to forget is that the guy was a complete jerk in Season One.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.