The Telltale forums are now read only. Past posts will stay available to browse, but new posts and replies have moved to our official Discord.

Join the conversation on Discord
›

Did you kill or spare the soldier?

TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer
in Game Of Thrones

I'm talking about the soldier on Gared's farm.

I killed him for these reasons:

  1. He killed my family
  2. He lied about having a family after killing my family.
  3. It was technically self-defense.

Comments

  • TheFurryOneTheFurryOne

    Killed him. Fuck him.

  • LilyForresterLilyForrester

    Killed him for the fact that he said 'Please I have a family; after he killed Gared's family.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Exactly.

    LilyForrester posted: »

    Killed him for the fact that he said 'Please I have a family; after he killed Gared's family.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Aye!

    TheFurryOne posted: »

    Killed him. Fuck him.

  • ShadowHunter94ShadowHunter94

    I killed him without a second thought. Especially after he pulled the "I have a family" crap after he murders Gared's family

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Talk about cowardice!

    ShadowHunter94 posted: »

    I killed him without a second thought. Especially after he pulled the "I have a family" crap after he murders Gared's family

  • ShadowHunter94ShadowHunter94

    That's an understatement

    TheAutisticGamer posted: »

    Talk about cowardice!

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    I wasn't calling you a coward. I was calling that soldier a coward.

    ShadowHunter94 posted: »

    That's an understatement

  • ShadowHunter94ShadowHunter94

    I know, I was saying that calling the soldier a coward is an understatement. Calling him a coward is being generous

    TheAutisticGamer posted: »

    I wasn't calling you a coward. I was calling that soldier a coward.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Oh okay. But him not facing his death with ANY kind of dignity and lying about having a family after killing Gared's family kinda makes him a coward. That's just what I think.

    ShadowHunter94 posted: »

    I know, I was saying that calling the soldier a coward is an understatement. Calling him a coward is being generous

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer
    edited April 2016

    But I don't know what else to call him other than a craven. And a murderer.

    ShadowHunter94 posted: »

    I know, I was saying that calling the soldier a coward is an understatement. Calling him a coward is being generous

  • KingOfKingsOfKingsKingOfKingsOfKings

    Kill that fucker.

    Only thing I regret was not killing him like Britt- twisting the blade inside his guts and kicking him.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer
    edited April 2016

    That woulda been sweet!

    KingOfKingsOfKings posted: »

    Kill that fucker. Only thing I regret was not killing him like Britt- twisting the blade inside his guts and kicking him.

  • Wolfenus54Wolfenus54

    Killed him without thinking twice. He got what he deserved.

  • Lee Everett Lee Everett

    Killed him,He is more then likely lying about having a family, just so he can live and he is a Bolton. So fuck him!!!!

  • Brodester08Brodester08

    The real question is: who the fuck didn't kill him?

  • AnimateRat29AnimateRat29

    I didn't, plz don't yell at me, i killed him on one playthrough and spared in my other. I thought he could help later on in the story

  • EuronEuron

    I just saw "Saving private Ryan" the day before playing EP1.
    So basically, I killed him.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Indeed he did, brother.

    Wolfenus54 posted: »

    Killed him without thinking twice. He got what he deserved.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Well said, Lee :)

    Lee Everett posted: »

    Killed him,He is more then likely lying about having a family, just so he can live and he is a Bolton. So fuck him!!!!

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    That's understandable. It's YOUR game, you can make whatever choices what you like.

    AnimateRat29 posted: »

    I didn't, plz don't yell at me, i killed him on one playthrough and spared in my other. I thought he could help later on in the story

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Yeah, it does make more sense if you kill him.

    Unknown posted: » [view original content]
  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    Alright then.

    Euron posted: »

    I just saw "Saving private Ryan" the day before playing EP1. So basically, I killed him.

  • Lee Everett Lee Everett

    Thank you

    TheAutisticGamer posted: »

    Well said, Lee

  • A-IBRAHIM0702A-IBRAHIM0702 Banned
    edited April 2016

    I spared him

    Because "Gared the merciful"

    enter image description here

    It wasn't self defense. He was basically at my mercy. AND

    • I didn't know that they killed my sister or that I even had a sister in the first place.
    • I thought they were just bullying my father and wounded him when he fought back.

    BUT if I knew about it...

    enter image description here

    Both of them would'd ended up like this

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    That's fine. It's your game. You can make whatever choices you want.

    A-IBRAHIM0702 posted: »

    I spared him Because "Gared the merciful" It wasn't self defense. He was basically at my mercy. AND * I didn't know that they

  • RhysAndLeeRhysAndLee

    I killed him without thinking about it too much. All I knew at the time was that they were invading my farm and beat up my father, that was good enough for me.

  • VengefulKennyVengefulKenny

    Killed him because he played the "I have a family to take care of" card right after helping murder my own family. Guy was chickenshit.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    #Chickenshit

    VengefulKenny posted: »

    Killed him because he played the "I have a family to take care of" card right after helping murder my own family. Guy was chickenshit.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.