'Book of the Stranger' Episode Discussion

124

Comments

  • I dont buy this idea that game of thrones is all about misery. The starks have had some good moments too. Plus they are due a victory, the remaining ones have got over there must do the right thing mentality

    Jon and Sansa reuniting. Its about time something good happened to the Starks Game of Thrones never does this. You know something bad is gonna happen. And soon...

  • LMAO i knew ive seen that kind of death before. oh man nice one.

    Clemenem posted: »

    Osha got Ethan'd

  • She was "far too much trouble"

    Clemenem posted: »

    Osha got Ethan'd

  • Hi, I have nothing against Emilia Clarke, instead I like her and she seems to be a very nice person. My disappointement is with the showrunners and the lack of character development, with what happened yesterday it seems like she is invincible and perfect, which is in contradiction with the tones of the story, who makes mistakes pays(or even dies) and everyone suffers the consequences of their wrong decisions. Dany had a development only in the first season and maybe in the second, but then she only becomes the one with the dragons who makes badass things. Stop.
    The only thing that distinguishes Daenerys from Viserys is that she has dragons and that she is immune from fire(it seems). I thought this season was about Dany returning down to earth, but I was wrong.

    JonDee013 posted: »

    Agreed. I'm not much of a Dany fan either, but I'm soo bored of the incessant hate on her character. And Emilia Clarke. It seems nothing she does is ever okay or justifiable.

  • My disappointement is with the showrunners and the lack of character development, with what happened yesterday it seems like she is invincible and perfect, which is in contradiction with the tones of the story, who makes mistakes pays(or even dies) and everyone suffers the consequences of their wrong decisions.

    Her story arc in season 5 is all about showing weakness after the parade of conquering she had done, and there were many downfalls for her (one being Ser Barristan dying). And they have put a big emphasis on showing the negative consequences of her decisions on Meereen, hell, the Sons of The Harpy are one big negative consequence of her not being able to control the Slaver's Bay. The high note ending of her flying away with Drogon might throw some off, but in truth season 5 was very much a season of struggling for Dany. And as we start this season she is at her lowest - forced as a slave to the Dothraki. So, did we need a couple episodes of the Dothraki raping her to make some people satisfied? She had a triumphant moment, yes, but that's the point because this is a turning point on her story, the start of the final act on her Slaver's Bay -storyline.

    Dany had a development only in the first season and maybe in the second, but then she only becomes the one with the dragons who makes badass things. Stop.

    No, you stop. And watch the seasons again. Season 3 was all about her becoming a conquerer, as it needed to be. Now, admittedly season 4 is a bit of an off-season for her, but it still is about her trying to move from conquerer to ruler. And about her season 5 I already talked, but if you want to see scenes that are not about "dragons and badass things", let me show you:

    enter link description here

    enter link description here

    enter link description here

    enter link description here

    And there is more.

    I thought this season was about Dany returning down to earth, but I was wrong.

    And do what? Meekly live her days as Dosh Khaleen? One can't win the Dothraki over with political savvy, so she showed power and created a spectacle to make herself look like a god. Because that's what the Dothraki respect, power.

    And if "returning down to earth" is what you expect her future to be in the books, I'm pretty sure you'll be disappointed. She is becoming the Dragon Queen, not backing out from it.

    Ace24_ posted: »

    Hi, I have nothing against Emilia Clarke, instead I like her and she seems to be a very nice person. My disappointement is with the showrunn

  • edited May 2016

    Take the character as she is; how she behave, how she thinks. You would think she would be more humble now. Not a single inch of her changed. The whole burning thing wouldn't happen so fast irl and they would simply kill her in revenge/get away by the window or whatever.

    Dothraki hate magic. On all those there, it's hardly believable none would step to kill her.

    In books she isn't a God immune to fire, she has more development because of the material so becoming the dragon queen isn't that sure, nor the coming down to Earth.. if she doesn't it means she will end somehow Mad Queen 2.0.

    My disappointement is with the showrunners and the lack of character development, with what happened yesterday it seems like she is invincib

  • I dont buy this idea that game of thrones is all about misery.

    It's not all misery, but it's mostly misery.

    The starks have had some good moments too.

    Sometimes I find it hard to believe that any good moments happen to the Starks anymore.

    I dont buy this idea that game of thrones is all about misery. The starks have had some good moments too. Plus they are due a victory, the remaining ones have got over there must do the right thing mentality

  • Would you be humble towards people who boast about raping you and giving you to their horses if you knew you have a way to shut those people up? As I said, she had many moments of uncertainty and doubting last season, this was NOT a moment for uncertainty and doubting. Just as much as this episode wasn't a moment for uncertainty and doubting for Sansa.

    Dothraki hate magic. On all those there, it's hardly believable none would step to kill her.

    Yes, they hate witches, however their own culture has superstition, gods, prophecies - and a great respect for power. A girl walking out of the flames unharmed is not just some witch, it's a god figure. Mirroring this, Jon had his god figure moment just couple episodes ago, also watched by amazed barbarians.

    In books she isn't a God immune to fire

    The immunity to fire isn't relevant in the big scheme of things - she is still seen by others as being almost a god. And being fireproof doesn't make one immortal, anyway. But as a character Dany is clearly in the books moving towards "Fire and Blood", from "Planting trees in Meereen". And to me it seems show Dany is going to the exact same direction, even if the route will be different.

    Euron posted: »

    Take the character as she is; how she behave, how she thinks. You would think she would be more humble now. Not a single inch of her changed

  • This is exactly what I mean. Take Cersei for example: She felt remorse for her actions, for Joffrey ("Sometimes I wonder this is the price for what we've done, for our sins") and she showed a complexity even if she is seen as one of the "villains". She payed her mistakes with her pride and honor, and her love for her children is genuine.
    Daenerys instead never showed an introspective side of her personality, even with Jorah, her closest and loyal friends, instead she seems to manipulate him and always considering herself superior(for example when they stole her dragons in Qarth). All the time she says "The throne is mine because I'm a Targaryen, I have dragons and an army" but she never thinks about her actions or accept genuine advises, and she wants to believe stories where her family is seen only in a good light(she reluctantly listened to Barristan about her father). A good ruler knows when to listen, a step she never made and I don't think she will ever make, she listens only to herself and refuses to admit her mistakes even to herself. The only thing she did was gaining power with force and burning people alive, with fear and not respect, not better than any other in game of thrones.

    Euron posted: »

    Take the character as she is; how she behave, how she thinks. You would think she would be more humble now. Not a single inch of her changed

  • she is still seen by others as being almost a god.

    Where is it mentionned in books? I never had this feeling while reading it or seen anything about it.

    Otherwise, I agree with your explanation Ace2'4 that's basically what I meant, but far better written.

    Would you be humble towards people who boast about raping you and giving you to their horses if you knew you have a way to shut those people

  • I have no examples to give from the top of my mind, it's just the general feeling I got from the books - especially in those chapters of someone traveling to her, Tyrion and Quentyn for example. Victarion of course doesn't fit this, to him she is just the "most beautiful woman in the world"... with dragons. And I don't mean that people literally think she is god, but you know, a mystical and powerful figure - especially those who have only heard the stories of her or seen her from afar probably have hard time of picturing her as just a human.

    Euron posted: »

    she is still seen by others as being almost a god. Where is it mentionned in books? I never had this feeling while reading it or see

  • Quentyn seeks her for her beauty aswell but not as a God, even if of course we have different perceptions while reading it.

    Tyrion doesn't care about her as I remember: he wanted to stay with Gryff and said he should go West instead of going to his "aunt"; Mormont captured Tyrion but he did not take the choice to go seek her.

    And Quentyn ended trying to steal her a dragon.

    So I didn't have this mystical vibe at all.

    I have no examples to give from the top of my mind, it's just the general feeling I got from the books - especially in those chapters of som

  • What I mean is the feeling on those chapters, not necessary Quentyn's or Tyrion's perception. How everyone talks about this mystical Mother of Dragons, what she has done, and the dragons of course.

    Or would you really say she is just some ordinary queen? Actually GRRM has made Targaryens in general to seem a bit mysterious to rest of the world. You know, they are mostly like everyone else, but still not quite - even without the dragons. Daenerys has just a bit more of that mysteriousness to her imo.

    Euron posted: »

    Quentyn seeks her for her beauty aswell but not as a God, even if of course we have different perceptions while reading it. Tyrion doesn'

  • Great episode. I'm sorry you guys but I still can't stand Daenerys. I just... CANT.

  • They're just valyrian, so the Westerners see them differently. But there're still valyrians in Essos (and some minors house in Westeros). If something caught the attention of people it's more the dragons which are supposed to be dead than the queen herself.

    Other than that, I didn't feel they were special. Except if we're talking about their consanguinity. :P

    What I mean is the feeling on those chapters, not necessary Quentyn's or Tyrion's perception. How everyone talks about this mystical Mother

  • Anyone else feeling that Ramsay's evilness is cranked up to eleven this season? I honestly hate this guy now, more than I ever did with Joffrey, at least he had an excuse that he had a spoiled upbringing and lack of father's presence. I hope that they are making him so insanely unlikable this Season just we can watch him die more painfully.

  • edited May 2016

    I dont see how hes any worse than his first season. Everything he did to theon that season. Season after hes hunting that chick with dogs Next season he marries sansa and now this season.

    Also hes more evil than joffrey but at least he does his own stuff not just order it like joffrey did. I have marginally more respect for him as a viillan, joffrey wa s abitch with too much power, ramsey is crazy and scary

    Anyone else feeling that Ramsay's evilness is cranked up to eleven this season? I honestly hate this guy now, more than I ever did with Joff

  • I love the Hound too but I don't believe for a second he's dead. Wait until Episode 7 and get hype....

    Well sah-ree, but I still can't forgive her for what she did to the Hound.

  • He even took a young child as a ward again too, first Ryon then Rickon.

    Clemenem posted: »

    Osha got Ethan'd

  • Hmm, well I guess we've just got a different reading on the matter, because I don't mean only like Targs being "foreigner" strange to others, but as them having a touch of magic in them, as in a reminiscence of the ancient times. This is a weird analogy, but kinda like direwolves are animals, but they are also something more.

    Euron posted: »

    They're just valyrian, so the Westerners see them differently. But there're still valyrians in Essos (and some minors house in Westeros). If

  • He is pretty much invisible and always manages to win. I am just sick of it

    I dont see how Ramsey has had plot armor apart from that one time when he fought Yara barechested. He sure didnt have any this week. He already knew Osha's trick and was ready for her. He just let her think she had the upperhand.

  • Just hold your breath... until episode 9 ;)

    He is pretty much invisible and always manages to win. I am just sick of it

  • If she didnt fight him, he would have killed her. He wasnt about to give up his prize. With Arya, it seemed more like choose the devil you know over the devil you dont. The reason I think Sansa chose Baelish over Brienne.

  • They had better not. Davos said himself he's not a fighter and I think Brienne has more of a beef with Melisandre.

    CunningFox posted: »

    I've got a bad feeling that Brienne and Davos are going to fight each other.

  • Maybe you think that because he doesnt have Theon to torture anymore so he is spreading his menace around more? Plus he doesnt have his father, as horrible as he is, to reign him in.

    Anyone else feeling that Ramsay's evilness is cranked up to eleven this season? I honestly hate this guy now, more than I ever did with Joff

  • i think people are just mad at the game.

    I dont see how Ramsey has had plot armor apart from that one time when he fought Yara barechested. He sure didnt have any this week. He already knew Osha's trick and was ready for her. He just let her think she had the upperhand.

  • Well, thats a way to look at it. I know a lot of people feel the way you do. From my perspective, this so called cameraderie between Arya and the Hound was almost as bad as her being all friendly with Tywin. At least she didnt forgive him completely so she wasnt that attached.

  • He is pretty much invisible and always manages to win.

    But thats not plot armor. To be honest ramsey looses plenty, he just doesnt get hurt all that much. Season 4 was his first real season and even then he wasnt that present. Season 5 he won a lot but his character was still in contention with his legitimacy questioned. They been setting up his demise all season.

    He is pretty much invisible and always manages to win. I am just sick of it

  • I'll lose it if Rickon dies. I've wanted him to come back for so long. Plus I can't get over how cool he looks!

    Osha :(

  • I found it interesting how in the letter to Jon, Ramsay repeatedly uses the term 'bastard'.

    I cannot wait for this battle!

  • He's justifiably more evil than Joffrey. I mean who's more evil, Roose Bolton or Cersei Lannister?

    Actually... That's kinda tough. I don't think Ramsey is more evil, I think they are very similar. The only difference is one was raised (and identified) as a bastard most their life until they reached power, while the other never knew what they were.

    Both were evil little shits, and if Joffrey had his way he woulda raped Sansa too, don't forget. One was just a bit older.

    And the whole, Flayed man being on your banner.. That probably adds some crazy points

    I dont see how hes any worse than his first season. Everything he did to theon that season. Season after hes hunting that chick with dogs Ne

  • I imagine that Ramsay will torture Rickon, no doubt about about. But it will make it all the more sweeter at the end of the battle Jon kills Ramsay. But then again, im taking a guess here and also it's Game of Thrones were talking about

    AgentZ46 posted: »

    I'll lose it if Rickon dies. I've wanted him to come back for so long. Plus I can't get over how cool he looks! Osha

  • I hope no more Starks dies. If Rickon dies, then the Stark name is essentially over. I have my doubts that Bran will return from beyond the Wall and become the new lord and father another heir to the Stark name.

    Well, then there is Jon, but there are the theories...

    AgentZ46 posted: »

    I'll lose it if Rickon dies. I've wanted him to come back for so long. Plus I can't get over how cool he looks! Osha

  • Second only to Rodrik, Osha is the closest to killing Ramsay

  • Meaning the both were not close at all? Ramsey baited both of them, neither had a chance

    Clemenem posted: »

    Second only to Rodrik, Osha is the closest to killing Ramsay

  • edited May 2016

    Do you know anyone who's had a better opportunity of doing so? The iron born soldiers who just stood there as he swung at them in season 4? Or Asha/Yara (whatever) who let him finish his taunting and allowing him to free his dogs (all the while she's a professional Axe thrower

    Meaning the both were not close at all? Ramsey baited both of them, neither had a chance

  • Plot armor is immune to previously established professional axe throwing.

    Clemenem posted: »

    Do you know anyone who's had a better opportunity of doing so? The iron born soldiers who just stood there as he swung at them in season 4?

  • The whole scene was just a disaster. Who the hell raids a stronghold with thousands of men with 50 soldiers and only stopped by dogs? Also, Ramsay blitzes armored, trained killers shirtless. What. The. Fuck?!?!

    Poptarts posted: »

    Plot armor is immune to previously established professional axe throwing.

  • I think that scene was over the top but several things

    1. I know they are ironborn but there is no proof they are that good at fighting, or better than ramsey

    2. They only had a few men as it was just Yara alone on the mission, Balon wouldnt support her

    3. They did run due to the dogs Yara went to rescue theon, when she saw he was gone mentally she gave up

    Clemenem posted: »

    The whole scene was just a disaster. Who the hell raids a stronghold with thousands of men with 50 soldiers and only stopped by dogs? Also, Ramsay blitzes armored, trained killers shirtless. What. The. Fuck?!?!

  • edited May 2016

    I know they are ironborn but there is no proof they are that good at fighting, or better than ramsey

    Actually, she mentions she personally selected the best killers on the islands to the dreadfort in Season 3 after Balon gets Theon's cock in a box and yet they don't even attempt to hit him

    They only had a few men as it was just Yara alone on the mission, Balon wouldnt support her

    All the more reason why it was a stupid scene and or idea to begin with...

    They did run due to the dogs Yara went to rescue theon, when she saw he was gone mentally she gave up

    She went to the North, risking her life and dozens of her men to storm a castle with thousands of armed men to save him. Not only does she not rescue him she loses a lot of her men in the process only to be chased away by two hounds. It was a bad scene and idea in itself and didn't make any sense writing or story wise as it accomplished nothing. You could argue that it was to show how far gone Theon was but every other one of his scenes in Season 4 displayed this.

    I think that scene was over the top but several things * I know they are ironborn but there is no proof they are that good at fighting,

Sign in to comment in this discussion.