Kenny or Jane ?

Which choice did you choose, guys ?

Tagged:
«13

Comments

  • I looked away.

  • That means you can look at the spoiler !

    Soloboiii posted: »

    I looked away.

  • Shot Kenny and Stood up to Jane. Then rewound after reading up on the other possible endings so that both would be dead.

  • edited March 2018

    I shot Kenny the first time i played the game,his last words made me cry then i realised the Baby was alive,i was pissed,i didn't forgive her for what she did but i still went with Jane.

    Second time I played the game differently,choose to let Kenny kill Jane, and decided to stay at Wellington that ending made me cry even more lmao.
    And honestly i'm glad i did after what happened to him in season 3.

    I also really like the ending where they both end up dead i don't know why..I guess it's because i had enough of this shit between Kenny and Jane always fighting.

  • Shot Kenny. A shame the choice only came after he single handedly destroyed the group from within.

  • I let Kenny kill jane then i shot Kenny.

  • edited March 2018

    Am I the first to say I chose Kenny? How dare you all betray our lord and saviour like this
    Jk but for real now, I couldn't choose Jane. Kenny goes apeshit crazy, but he's been with me from the start. I know the ratonal decision is to shoot him probably, but I just couldn't do it

  • I didn't thought about how Kenny was with us since the beginning when he was on top of Jane with a knife,Season 2 really wanted you to hate Kenny and they did a good job with this.

    Timcanpy posted: »

    Am I the first to say I chose Kenny? How dare you all betray our lord and saviour like this Jk but for real now, I couldn't choose Jane. Ke

  • Kenny, as I trusted no one else, after Amid the Ruined. Didn't even look away. I wanted to see that cunt die on screen.

  • Killed Jane, stayed with Kenny.

  • Watched Kenny kill Jane, then stayed with Kenny even after we got to Wellington and he happily took care of the kids for more than two years.

  • You know what, might as well point out that on my second playthrough, I let Kenny kill Jane and then went into Wellington.

  • The Walking Dead: The Enemy Within

    Shot Kenny. A shame the choice only came after he single handedly destroyed the group from within.

  • Chose Jane, she did more for Clem and AJ in a shorter span of time than Kenny ever had and he caused unnecessary friction that tore the group apart and there really was no reason for him to reappear.

  • edited April 2018

    I've noticed that a lot of people love one and hate the other. I loved both of them. The season 2 finale hit me hard. Here is my philosophy on this topic.

  • Jane all the way. Kenny destroyed the group and everyone hated him.

  • Kenny may have destroyed the group but I still love him and I simply didn't like Jane. I let Kenny stab her.

  • edited April 2018

    Well, one of them were, anyway

    Veeeee posted: »

    I've noticed that a lot of people love one and hate the other. I loved both of them. The season 2 finale hit me hard. Here is my philosophy on this topic.

  • I let Kenny kill Jane and then entered Wellington.

  • If writing off the characters you hate as poorly written characters makes you feel better, go for it.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Well, one of them were, anyway

  • The other way around is the usual process, dude.

    Veeeee posted: »

    If writing off the characters you hate as poorly written characters makes you feel better, go for it.

  • Not my Clementine.

    Jane all the way. Kenny destroyed the group and everyone hated him.

  • Jane. Kenny is too predictable. We get lots of "father figure stories" but very few "older sister/really not a good mother" types

  • We get lots of "father figure stories" but very few "older sister/really not a good mother" types

    Agreed.

    Louche posted: »

    Jane. Kenny is too predictable. We get lots of "father figure stories" but very few "older sister/really not a good mother" types

  • And of course, it was squandered. I mean, it knew it would be but I didn't expect them to treat her so callously.
    (I still suspect it was written by a kenny fan)

    DabigRG posted: »

    We get lots of "father figure stories" but very few "older sister/really not a good mother" types Agreed.

  • I mean, it knew it would be
    but I didn't expect them to treat her so callously.

    . * BoomBoomCHECKCHECKDaBoomCHECK *

    (I still suspect it was written by a kenny fan)

    Well, considering it was sexto-written by Nick Breckon...

    Louche posted: »

    And of course, it was squandered. I mean, it knew it would be but I didn't expect them to treat her so callously. (I still suspect it was written by a kenny fan)

  • edited April 2018

    I really like both of them. They both have some serious flaws, but it's there flaws in combination to their strengths that makes them such memorable characters. I tend to find myself arguing on Jane's behalf on these forums but that's mostly because there are more people demonizing her and idolizing Kenny. If it was the other way round I would be defending Kenny more often.

  • edited April 2018

    "I promise I won't ever leave you again"
    leaves Clem two weeks later
    also traumatizes her even further

    Thanks, Nick. :sweat:

    DabigRG posted: »

    I mean, it knew it would be but I didn't expect them to treat her so callously. . * BoomBoomCHECKCHECKDaBoomCHECK * (I still suspect it was written by a kenny fan) Well, considering it was sexto-written by Nick Breckon...

  • What's funny about that is that it was also sexto-written by Pierre Shorette, which may or may not prove my assessment.

    Louche posted: »

    "I promise I won't ever leave you again" leaves Clem two weeks later also traumatizes her even further Thanks, Nick.

  • In english, please

    DabigRG posted: »

    What's funny about that is that it was also sexto-written by Pierre Shorette, which may or may not prove my assessment.

  • The guy who wrote Jane's material before and after her outright Shilling, respectively..

    Louche posted: »

    In english, please

  • edited April 2018

    Whatever. I just don't like the feeling that anyone that picked Jane was flat-out told "ha! you picked wrong! look! see, she's a terrible person!" in season 3. I mean, maybe if it actually amounted to something, but it's not like we get clementine having bitter scathing comments about how Jane let her down or anything.

    DabigRG posted: »

    The guy who wrote Jane's material before and after her outright Shilling, respectively..

  • Not quite sure about your sentence structure there, but okay.

    Louche posted: »

    Whatever. I just don't like the feeling that anyone that picked Jane was flat-out told "ha! you picked wrong! look! see, she's a terrible pe

  • edited April 2018

    I chose to shoot Kenny. While I didn't believe he was a monster, the poor man just couldn't handle heartbreak (or really any sort of intense emotion) and the apocalypse was obviously never going to let up on him, so in a way I ended up killing him out of mercy.

    I didn't stay with Jane though cause fuck that bitch

  • them's fighting words

    DabigRG posted: »

    Not quite sure about your sentence structure there, but okay.

  • Stayed with Kenny, I never owned Jane anything.

  • I'm with you on that. I think someone mentioned there's parallels with putting down the dog in episode one.
    It's not a bad ending, but the reason I don't like it is simply because Jane relents way too easy. She goes through all that trouble just to let Clem walk off? WHAT??! It's really dumb.

    Cocoa2736 posted: »

    I chose to shoot Kenny. While I didn't believe he was a monster, the poor man just couldn't handle heartbreak (or really any sort of intense

  • Okay, looking back at what you actually said, I think I get that. Sorry bout that.

    Louche posted: »

    them's fighting words

  • I think someone mentioned there's parallels with putting down the dog in episode one.

    Oh, whaddya know! I have occasionally viewed shooting Kenny as putting down a an extremely sick dog your friend owned for a good while.

    Louche posted: »

    I'm with you on that. I think someone mentioned there's parallels with putting down the dog in episode one. It's not a bad ending, but the

  • I think someone mentioned there's parallels with putting down the dog in episode one.

    That's a nice analogy. I also would compare Kenny to Ben in some ways. Both had the best interests of their groups at heart but the two were in their own ways mentally unprepared for the hardships that came with the ZA. Ultimately the player is forced to decide on whether or not they should put both of them down for being detrimental to the group and if spared they can get pretty anticlimactic deaths afterwards.

    It's not a bad ending, but the reason I don't like it is simply because Jane relents way too easy. She goes through all that trouble just to let Clem walk off? WHAT??! It's really dumb.

    Clem still had the gun at that point IIRC. It wouldn't have been a good idea for Jane to continue pestering Clem after killing her old friend while Clem had a firearm. If I was given the option on my first playthrough I might've chosen to shoot her myself.

    Louche posted: »

    I'm with you on that. I think someone mentioned there's parallels with putting down the dog in episode one. It's not a bad ending, but the

Sign in to comment in this discussion.