That's almost funny to even think they could have survived UNDER water for hours. They treaded water for hour's which is entirely possible due to the presence or AIR.
Luke was trapped under the ice, under water an no matter how your scene play's out, we all see him sink down.
A lot of people have survived what Luke's situation was with even worse injuries than just a gunshot wound in his leg. What boggles me is how come that walkers was strong enough to pull him under by his good leg, but Luke wasn't strong enough to get it out of its reach?
yes, he is dead. besides who can survive being pulled beneath a frozen river with temperatures below zero degrees (without wearing any warm … moreclothing). and he was already dead because his foot was very weak and couldnt even knock out the ice on top of the river. Sorry luke fans,he aint that lucky.
Protagonist doesn't necessarily mean playable, just means that he's one of the more prominent characters in the season. To add to that he had been there since S2Ep1 and was the only person other than Clementine who had been around for that long.
a major protagonist
We never played as Luke...?
and then like a background character (jane) becomes the main character?
… more After Episode 3, Jane was never a background character. She's one of the most developed in the season.
wtf ...... failure story goodbye
ok.
We never played as Luke...?
Protagonist doesn't necessarily mean playable, just means that he's one of the more prominent characters… more in the season. To add to that he had been there since S2Ep1 and was the only person other than Clementine who had been around for that long.
No I'm sure he's alive. We only just saw him be dragged down to the bottom of a freezing cold lake by a walker. I'm sure he had some gay aqua man powers though. He's fiiinnne.
You know, if kenny can magically escape an alleyway with walkers coming from both sides, then luke should be able to survive the frozen lake… more and get real lucky too dammit, yea I'm still in denial and will probably always be in denial about luke's 'death'
Well you could actually say he was more crucial than the rest of the cabin group. He guides you on your view of Jane and Kenny.
'Jane seems like the kind of person who gets tempered by hardship y'know. But when I look at Kenny now, he just, he seems broken and broken people get reckless.'
a major protagonist
He wasn't.
who was crucial to the story
He wasn't more than the rest of the cabin group.
who… more was definitley established as a main character
You mean like Lee, Katjaa, Duck and Carley/Doug?
was just killed off no biggie??
Yes. Like Omid, Carley/Doug and Katjaa. And Rebecca. And Alvin.
and then like a background character (jane) becomes the main character?
First off, I don't think you understand what a main character is. Basically, in Season 2 it where the cabin group, Kenny, Jane, Mike and Carver.
Second, I don't like Jane, but she sure wasn't a background character.
Third, she can't become the main character, since that's still Clementine.
im so lost. i totally thought this whole thing with season 2 was about luke or kenny.
What made you think that in-game? Sure, there were hundreds of 'Luke vs Kenny' threads, but it was never really estab… [view original content]
They didn't know what to do with Luke, so they killed him, i think the Kenny/Jane choice initially was Luke/Kenny, but like everybody expected that they changed it.
I agree with all of this! I'm actually hoping that Job J Stauffer or someone else from Telltale will see all of our complaints and get so annoyed that they bring Luke back!
If you listen very, very closely...you might juuuust hear Job J Stauffer weeping in his office at finding yet another 'wtf Luke, why you dea… mored man' thread while on his coffee break XD
But I can relate to the things said here. I've kinda talk the subject into the ground so I won't go into it too much. But yeah, there's a reason why the finale disappointed me because everything before just seemed kinda meaningless. I do like the effort they made on Jane in the attempt to make us like her in such a short frame of time, but sadly I just saw it as too much too late. After establishing all the stuff with Luke and Kenny for so long and building that up, an outcome with them would've made the game for me. Jane just didn't quite live up to that, even despite all the back story they crammed into the last two episodes with her, she still felt like a lesser character compared to Clem, Kenny and Luke, and that's why having her in that role unfortunately… [view original content]
Yes you, sitting at your desk with your cup of cappuccino and your Adventure Time T-shirt with the ketchup stain on it. You know what we want, and we can be very, very, persuasive. So you would be wise to give into our demands...
Otherwise your childhood cuddle buddy, Mister Piggy Winkle gets it!
I agree with all of this! I'm actually hoping that Job J Stauffer or someone else from Telltale will see all of our complaints and get so annoyed that they bring Luke back!
At least, I can hope right?
[Eerie sci-fi horror music]
Hello Job.
Yes you, sitting at your desk with your cup of cappuccino and your Adventure Time T-shirt w… moreith the ketchup stain on it. You know what we want, and we can be very, very, persuasive. So you would be wise to give into our demands...
Otherwise your childhood cuddle buddy, Mister Piggy Winkle gets it!
You have 24 hours to comply.
Hugs & Kisses
-Lilac
...Think that'll do it Simply? o.o
Yes indeed, Job. You want to know what happened to Simply's childhood friend 'The Snuggle Pumpkin Princess' when she failed to hand over her last slice of pizza to me last week through the mail?
Pure horrors Job, pure horrors await your precious Mister Piggy Winkle if you don't give Luke back to us alive and well...
Yes indeed, Job. You want to know what happened to Simply's childhood friend 'The Snuggle Pumpkin Princess' when she failed to hand over her… more last slice of pizza to me last week through the mail?
Pure horrors Job, pure horrors await your precious Mister Piggy Winkle if you don't give Luke back to us alive and well...
[waves arms spookily ] Bewaaaaare!
Comments
That's almost funny to even think they could have survived UNDER water for hours. They treaded water for hour's which is entirely possible due to the presence or AIR.
Luke was trapped under the ice, under water an no matter how your scene play's out, we all see him sink down.
LUKE IS DEAD!!!
A lot of people have survived what Luke's situation was with even worse injuries than just a gunshot wound in his leg. What boggles me is how come that walkers was strong enough to pull him under by his good leg, but Luke wasn't strong enough to get it out of its reach?
he died so hard he might as well be alive
Reality is what you make it, man.
Protagonist doesn't necessarily mean playable, just means that he's one of the more prominent characters in the season. To add to that he had been there since S2Ep1 and was the only person other than Clementine who had been around for that long.
Ah, I see.
No I'm sure he's alive. We only just saw him be dragged down to the bottom of a freezing cold lake by a walker. I'm sure he had some gay aqua man powers though. He's fiiinnne.
He'll be back, have you seen Encino man ?
Rather unlikely :P
There's a difference between Kenny's situation and Luke's.
Kenny was in a situation that has been shown to be managable in both the comics and the show.
Tyreese in the comics clears out a whole gym of walkers all by himself with nothing but a gun without ammo.
In the show, he uses a hammer and kills dozens of walkers without being bit.
Hell, even Lee's herd scene wasn't much different from Kenny's, other than that he had more space.
Plus, and it's very likely that happened, Kenny could have just pulled himself through a window or open a door, he's in an alleyway afted all, right?
But Luke was doomed as soon as he fell in. His leg was shot, and you can't fight a walkef underwater. Not really.
That was his demise.
He wasn't.
He wasn't more than the rest of the cabin group.
You mean like Lee, Katjaa, Duck and Carley/Doug?
Yes. Like Omid, Carley/Doug and Katjaa. And Rebecca. And Alvin.
First off, I don't think you understand what a main character is. Basically, in Season 2 it where the cabin group, Kenny, Jane, Mike and Carver.
Second, I don't like Jane, but she sure wasn't a background character.
Third, she can't become the main character, since that's still Clementine.
What made you think that in-game? Sure, there were hundreds of 'Luke vs Kenny' threads, but it was never really established in the game itself.
How?
wtf ...... failure thread
Bye.
Well you could actually say he was more crucial than the rest of the cabin group. He guides you on your view of Jane and Kenny.
'Jane seems like the kind of person who gets tempered by hardship y'know. But when I look at Kenny now, he just, he seems broken and broken people get reckless.'
[Luke gives you the cold shoulder]
No he developed Gils and evolved, haven't you watched that episode of Futurama. GOD
Luke is obviously still a merman.
They didn't know what to do with Luke, so they killed him, i think the Kenny/Jane choice initially was Luke/Kenny, but like everybody expected that they changed it.
Those are the most alive eyes I've ever seen! This just confirms that he is alive ;D
I mean he didn't... actually die... right?
I agree with all of this! I'm actually hoping that Job J Stauffer or someone else from Telltale will see all of our complaints and get so annoyed that they bring Luke back!
At least, I can hope right?
[Eerie sci-fi horror music]
Hello Job.
Yes you, sitting at your desk with your cup of cappuccino and your Adventure Time T-shirt with the ketchup stain on it. You know what we want, and we can be very, very, persuasive. So you would be wise to give into our demands...
Otherwise your childhood cuddle buddy, Mister Piggy Winkle gets it!
You have 24 hours to comply.
Hugs & Kisses
-Lilac
...Think that'll do it Simply? o.o
We need something more, just... just a little something else...
Pleaaasseeee Job? Pleaaaseeeeee?
LIES! Sits in corner rocking back and forth with a picture of luke, You'll come back, wont you?
If not for us and Clementine, do it for Mister Piggy Winkle, Job...or I'll be forced to remove stuffing from his left leg too and you don't want that.
You better listen to her Job, she's deadly serious...
Believe me;(
Yes.
He was colder than a rock.
Nah, he's just chillin' out at the bottom of this lukewarm lake.
pls stahp ;_;
Yes indeed, Job. You want to know what happened to Simply's childhood friend 'The Snuggle Pumpkin Princess' when she failed to hand over her last slice of pizza to me last week through the mail?
Pure horrors Job, pure horrors await your precious Mister Piggy Winkle if you don't give Luke back to us alive and well...
[waves arms spookily ] Bewaaaaare!
Sorry :<
SNUGGLE PUMPKIN PRINCESS
YOU MONSTER. How could you?!
JOB, Look what you've done to me!
Haha you do know I was joking right? I can take a joke c;
She likely means Celsius
not everyone uses Fahrenheit xD
I was joking too. And I'm actually not sorry at all. :>
Ohhh well... this is awkward.
I don't know how to answer that, so I'm gonna post a gif with Luke and Clem. Don't mind me.
Good choice man. Good choice. If anyone else thinks otherwise then, well...
Don't mind me...
Wow. A picture of ice. How wonderful, just what I wanted!
Wait... Here you go.
Much better
Definitely didn't ask for that ;_;
Here is the bigger question, does anyone even care? Luke been dead for months now.