*Civil* Character Discussion for Kenny/Jane choice: The Megathread - Discussion only goes here now

1121314151618»

Comments

  • Arvo made the choice to go to the Observation Deck to hide medicine for whatever reason, it is relevant because he chose to hide the medicine there. Considering the group just escaped a full community of strangers who had weapons which injured Kenny, caused Carlos to die and determinantly got Alvin killed, do you think someone like Jane would just let a complete stranger, who can threaten her and tell her that he's in a group, leave with his gun, which he also pointed at her although that was reasonable since Arvo was startled by a stranger as well.

    How do we know there was an actual robbery if Clementine didn't steal the medicine? Do you believe that Jane got up the next morning, found Arvo's medicine supply and then completely forgot about it when she heard gunshots and thought the group was in trouble? Also, it's quite interesting how Arvo tried to hide the medicine and then told his group that it was stolen from him. Actions speak louder than words after all, allot of things don't match up, it can only make sense if Clementine did steal the medicine, otherwise, there are some plot holes.

    I'd say that Jane also cared about Luke to some extent, considering she seemed to feel very upset about his death.

    Aerie88 posted: »

    Blame Arvo for coming with a bag of medicine? No, Arvo would have no idea that anyone else was at the deck. Yes, one can ask the question "w

  • I like the new display pic @IronWoodLover, could stare at Daenerys/Emilia Clarke for hours haha

    I never gave it much thought to be honest... But I think I would include 'doing harm to another in order to feel good' in my defenition of it. I think it can be classified as both evil and immoral.

  • I don't know why, but she makes me feel inspired (and hyped as well!). I intend to keep it as my avatar until the new season debuts ̶a̶l̶t̶o̶u̶g̶h̶ ̶I̶'̶l̶l̶ ̶p̶r̶o̶b̶a̶b̶l̶y̶ ̶f̶a̶i̶l̶.

    dan290786 posted: »

    I like the new display pic @IronWoodLover, could stare at Daenerys/Emilia Clarke for hours haha

  • I found luke to be annoying also. From the moment I met him and he dropped clementine I hated him. Him being annoying, self centered, and an egotistical douche bag added on to that hate. I also feel as though he had an messiah complex. The incident with jane just made me want to see him drown and get shot in the leg over and over again. Every option towards him is a silent option. Which does nothing because you still talk to him and he still is a try hard in everything.

    MosesARose posted: »

    If we are talking about which to save; Kenny or Jane. I have to go with Jane. I liked Kenny in season 1, but season 2 he's more of a dick th

  • edited July 2016

    Glad to see I'm not the only one. It was like every time Clem turned around, there he was all up her ass. She could never get away from that guy.

    I found luke to be annoying also. From the moment I met him and he dropped clementine I hated him. Him being annoying, self centered, and an

  • Exactly. You're definitely not alone. And even when you didn't say anything to him instead of him getting the hint he douchely says I have a way of getting women to talk to me or something similar to that. That's a creep thing to say. There are bad implications in what he said. He was also a failure as a leader.

    MosesARose posted: »

    Glad to see I'm not the only one. It was like every time Clem turned around, there he was all up her ass. She could never get away from that guy.

  • To be fair, Luke only said, in a joking manner, that he is good at talking to women who don't want to talk to him. And Clementine is a kid, so I doubt that his expression had any obscene implication.

    I share the view that he isn't leader material though.

    Exactly. You're definitely not alone. And even when you didn't say anything to him instead of him getting the hint he douchely says I have a

  • Thank you for typing what he exactly said. I forgot and I personally don't think he should've said that but I can understand it being a joke and it technically having nothing to do with clementine.

    To be fair, Luke only said, in a joking manner, that he is good at talking to women who don't want to talk to him. And Clementine is a kid,

  • Actually, he said girls, not women, so while it lessens the creepiness of the comment—kind of—the degree in which it applies to Clem is higher. And sure, no pebbles!

    Thank you for typing what he exactly said. I forgot and I personally don't think he should've said that but I can understand it being a joke and it technically having nothing to do with clementine.

  • I wanted to leave both of them, however I knew that going with Kenny would leave me to wellington, so I let him kill jane, then went into Wellington by myself. Didn't really care about them both.

  • If he said girls then I stand by my first comment about this matter.

    Actually, he said girls, not women, so while it lessens the creepiness of the comment—kind of—the degree in which it applies to Clem is higher. And sure, no pebbles!

  • it's better to leave molly alone they might gonna ruined molly's character since i lost faith in season 2 writers

    TTG would have been better served if Jane had been Molly. The biggest problem with S2 was the lack of compelling background on new characters.

  • when you first meet him he is trying to hide a small bag in the trash can on the tower. when confronted you see that it is full of medicine and he says how he doesn't trust his group with the medicine as his sister needs the medicine. the gun gets taken no matter what, so you have a point there, though on the other hand his group have AK's and everyone seems to be able to get their hands on a gun without too much trouble. if his group was willing to fight another group of armed people over something as trivial as a gun then they were bound to get killed off sooner or later. combine that with the verbal confrontation at the beginning which eliminates the element of surprise and the bad shots that they must have been to not kill anyone in the fight and it becomes a wonder as to why they even were alive to have that fight.

    in other words it is a writing snafu either way you look at it.

    Aerie88 posted: »

    I don't recall Arvo every saying that he was hiding the supplies from his group. But regardless of his motives for hiding the medicine JANE

  • [removed]

    Aerie88 posted: »

    I don't recall Arvo every saying that he was hiding the supplies from his group. But regardless of his motives for hiding the medicine JANE

  • [removed]

    Aerie88 posted: »

    I don't recall Arvo every saying that he was hiding the supplies from his group. But regardless of his motives for hiding the medicine JANE

  • [removed]

    Aerie88 posted: »

    I don't recall Arvo every saying that he was hiding the supplies from his group. But regardless of his motives for hiding the medicine JANE

  • [removed]

    Aerie88 posted: »

    I don't recall Arvo every saying that he was hiding the supplies from his group. But regardless of his motives for hiding the medicine JANE

Sign in to comment in this discussion.