Post your Episode 5 choices [MOD NOTICE: Contains Ep 5 spoilers]

124678

Comments

  • DeltinoDeltino Moderator
    edited July 2015

    Actually, I snooped around and managed to find a stream where they chose Rodrik. Skip to 3:05, if you think your heart can take it. Royland's the sentinel in this one, though.

    http://www.twitch.tv/nwotheroach/v/8011871

    ABigBadWolf posted: »

    Good, I was worried Rodrik was getting nothing compared to Asher's emotional scene. My sentinel's Duncan so that's what I'd get. Thank you so much. I'm still heartbroken...

  • Oh, thank you so much! My heart has already taken several beatings today because of this game (Arthur hit me hard -- I took the Glenmores with me but I doubt that saves him) so I think I can take one more.

    Deltino posted: »

    Actually, I snooped around and managed to find a stream where they chose Rodrik. Skip to 3:05, if you think your heart can take it. Royland's the sentinel in this one, though. http://www.twitch.tv/nwotheroach/v/8011871

  • Hey guys, does anyone know if Gryff still arrives on horseback in the final scene if Rodrik maims him in Episode 4?

  • I wonder too. I'm glad I maimed that piece of shit anyways.

    Harian96 posted: »

    Hey guys, does anyone know if Gryff still arrives on horseback in the final scene if Rodrik maims him in Episode 4?

  • My Rodrik acted honorable and only struck him a few times - now I know I'll get nothing for that... why am I even surprised, honor gets you no where in the Game of Thrones (Eddard Stark).

    I should have beaten his face into a mashed pulp....

    Killah posted: »

    I wonder too. I'm glad I maimed that piece of shit anyways.

  • edited July 2015

    Even though this isn't one of the main choices I am curious as to what happens with Danaerys if you let Beskha kill the slave master. Can anyone let me know by replying or pm? I let Beskha kill the master because she was a former slave who was delivering her justice so I figured we'd get the ability to persuade Dany that we were still following her orders by letting Beskha get her revenge.

  • edited July 2015

    How could YOU kill Asher?

    Well we dont know that, if we think about Carley and Doug: they both had important roles during 3 episodes, they were different in their own ways, and they died because the plot demanded it, not just because they were there occupying space (like sarah, nick, pete...).
    So yea im hopefull that TellTale wont just kill them of...

    Harian96 posted: »

    One of them (Rodrik/Asher) dies in Episode 5 - knowing Telltale if they continue with the story of the Forresters in Season 2, then the next

    • Didn't stab Ramsay
    • Killed Bloodsong
    • Told Tyrion the Truth.
    • Sparred Royland.
    • Told Asher to stay behind.
  • Also, does anyone have a clip where Duncan is the traitor? All the playthroughs from twitch that I saw had Royland being confronted by the fire.

  • edited July 2015

    http://www.twitch.tv/nwotheroach/v/8011871 at around 3:08 oh and Duncan is traitor further in

    sbk12345 posted: »

    Even though this isn't one of the main choices I am curious as to what happens with Danaerys if you let Beskha kill the slave master. Can an

  • edited July 2015

    what happens if you spare the traitor? @ranger563

    ranger563 posted: »

    Haven't played it but watched the stream. Gonna choose: * Try to stab Ramsey. * Kill Bloodsong. * Won't tell Tyrion. * Spare Royland. * Leave Rodrik behind.

  • I'll just wont play further then, i cant take even reading this ;-;

  • edited July 2015

    Grr why did I spoil myself lol. But anyways I'm kind of surprised who the traitor was.

  • Sadly I must be the one person that didn't get the glitch.

    glitchy season pass on x1

  • Haven't played yet, but these will be my choices:

    Didn't try to stab Ramsey.(why would i? He's canon.)

    Kill Bloodsong.(maybe I don't know who he is lol.)

    Will tell Tyrion.(He's my bro bro)

    Kill Royland.(No mercy for traitors)

    Leave Rodrik behind. (Definitely not leaving Asher considering he is my favorite character and the only reason I am playing the game.)

  • Yeah it sucked but it was obvious that he would die, since you have an option to bring him with you or not.

    kaza125 posted: »

    Finns death kinda sucked tbh

  • Where are the glenmores?

  • Ramsey says that he sent them back home.

    Where are the glenmores?

  • For me Rodrik isn't dying until he makes that baby

    Harian96 posted: »

    One of them (Rodrik/Asher) dies in Episode 5 - knowing Telltale if they continue with the story of the Forresters in Season 2, then the next

  • I just noticed we kill the guy who was sharpening his sword on the steps in episode 2. ALRIGHT! But 2 reasons why I didn't kill off Rodrik, One is he had the Forrester Sword, and 2 he hasn't made a baby with Eleana yet.

    ABigBadWolf posted: »

    So literally everything is the same? What about how Beshka is desperate when Asher stays behind? Does Rodrik get nothing? Not from Beshka, I mean, but in general. Thank you, by the way.

  • Theres some in here if you can find em.

    sbk12345 posted: »

    Also, does anyone have a clip where Duncan is the traitor? All the playthroughs from twitch that I saw had Royland being confronted by the fire.

  • he hasn't made a baby with Eleana yet

    oh my ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

    Valebread posted: »

    I just noticed we kill the guy who was sharpening his sword on the steps in episode 2. ALRIGHT! But 2 reasons why I didn't kill off Rodrik, One is he had the Forrester Sword, and 2 he hasn't made a baby with Eleana yet.

  • what minus the Ebbert look alike. Ima flay Gryff if I get the chance I WILL! BUT first Rodrik needs to make baby

    Grr why did I spoil myself lol. But anyways I'm kind of surprised who the traitor was.

  • Don't worry they are not all dead I hope

    Where are the glenmores?

  • Hey I have yet to go back and check but does Arthur or anyone die to Ramsay if you take the Glenmores to Highpoint?

  • I want both of them to live, either way theres that group of people who can resurrect people from the books. So its a 1/1000 chance but its a chance

    Harian96 posted: »

    My Rodrik acted honorable and only struck him a few times - now I know I'll get nothing for that... why am I even surprised, honor gets you no where in the Game of Thrones (Eddard Stark). I should have beaten his face into a mashed pulp....

  • All I want to know is who does Ramsay kill if you take the Glenmores to Highpoint

    sbk12345 posted: »

    Even though this isn't one of the main choices I am curious as to what happens with Danaerys if you let Beskha kill the slave master. Can an

  • I always hated that they never show next time on before the final episode.

    MarteenPyro posted: »

    I'm gonna cry at the previously part of ep6.

  • What happens if you take the Glenmores to highpoint, who does Ramsay kill, does he still kill Arthur because Id rather no replay the episode for that

    IR0NR4TH posted: »

    Just a little scratch, Ramsay doesn't feel a thing.

  • Just remember we get to kill the asshole who was sharpening his sword in Episode 2

    He takes on all the whitehills and then he gets shot with a crossbow in the chest, and then he continues killing Whitehills until he gets an

  • Do you not know who Ramsay is? You do NOT piss Ramsay off even by 1%

    The guy who streamed it was a big pussy. He didn't stab Ramsay. He chose Duncan as his Sentinel He showed restraint to Gryff He didn't b

  • Do you not know who Ramsay is? You do NOT anger Ramsay even by 1%

    The guy who streamed it was a big pussy. He didn't stab Ramsay. He chose Duncan as his Sentinel He showed restraint to Gryff He didn't b

  • HA! good one. Yea I kinda grabbed her, didn't bend, kept the sword, told him off, yea he deserves to kill me but he didn't! RODRIK WONT DIE UNTIL HE MAKE BABY END OF STORY!

  • well who was your sentinel?

    IR0NR4TH posted: »

    Didn't stab Ramsay Spared Bloodsong Told the truth to Tyrion Killed Duncan --I havent made my choice yet-- It's just so hard to make

  • Only reason one died was because they could have 2 perspectives of the story in one place.

    Then I guess Rodrik and Asher will both be dead in the end? Since they can't make 2 different "stories" or how to express it

  • So if you take the Glenmores to highpoint Asher still gets slit?

    IR0NR4TH posted: »

    Alive: Rodrik (determinant) Asher (determinant) Lady Forrester Talia Ser Royland (determinant) Duncan (determinant) Ortegryn Gared

  • Same here, early stuff comes out I spoil myself, but in this turn unlinked accounts that I don't bother to link I played this on. Man glitches can be..... wow

    GF1115 posted: »

    Lol when I saw the thread was some game - you know, guessing what choices wilk be in e5. When I realized its not... It was Too late. There should be a warning. But I dont mind cause i usually spoil myself.

  • Its not a carley and doug thing really Its the multiple character perspective. 2 characters telling a story in one location wouldn't work.

    Majda posted: »

    No, no, no Asher can't die. He's my favorite character and yes he most definitely will, like Carley and Doug lol

  • oh don't hide it, its a whole thread on the early episode release.

    I'll tell you, but in private. Send me a private message thing. I'll tell you the whole thing beginning to end.

  • They couldn't have 2 perspectives in one location.

    Then I guess Rodrik and Asher will both be dead in the end? Since they can't make 2 different "stories" or how to express it

Sign in to comment in this discussion.