Well Ep 3 shows that Kenny truly was superior. Lilly went mad and turns out Kenny was right after all. The motel was certainly not safe, the bandits could have attacked at any time.
Well Ep 3 shows that Kenny truly was superior. Lilly went mad and turns out Kenny was right after all. The motel was certainly not safe, the bandits could have attacked at any time.
I would have to disagree here. Lilly "went mad" because Kenny was wrong from the very beginning, especially about the Larry situation. He drove her to this state, so it's all on him in my book. His entire "protect my family before everybody else" not only backfired but it also cost the lives of others and the well-being of the entire group.
I would have to disagree here. Lilly "went mad" because Kenny was wrong from the very beginning, especially about the Larry situation. He drove her to this state, so it's all on him in my book. His entire "protect my family before everybody else" not only backfired but it also cost the lives of others and the well-being of the entire group.
I wouldn't say it was Kenny that really unhinged her so much as her father during in front of her. And how was Kenny wrong? If Larry died, then turned, then everyone was dead. EVERYONE. No one to save Katjaa and Duck and no one to warn Lilly/Doug and Ben. Is it really worth risking the lives of everyone to possibly save one guy who had a heart attack?
Not sure what other wrong decisions you think Kenny made.
I wouldn't say it was Kenny that really unhinged her so much as her father during in front of her. And how was Kenny wrong? If Larry died, then turned, then everyone was dead. EVERYONE. No one to save Katjaa and Duck and no one to warn Lilly/Doug and Ben. Is it really worth risking the lives of everyone to possibly save one guy who had a heart attack?
Not sure what other wrong decisions you think Kenny made.
He could've waited a bit, give her a chance to finish with the CPR. He, however, hurried because his family's lives were at stake, so he didn't care. When I performed the CPR I'm pretty sure Larry's mouth moved. I'm not saying he could've been saved for sure, but he definitely wasn't dead! Kenny stripped her of the most powerful motivator in life... hope! He could've been more tactful like my Lee was. However, he only saw a chance to tip the scales to his side by finishing Larry the moment he could. He has always been the one that is really power-hungry, the one bossing Lee around. Lilly was always trying to care for the group and she continued doing that even after her father died. We'll see how much will Kenny care for the rest in ep 4.
He could've waited a bit, give her a chance to finish with the CPR. He, however, hurried because his family's lives were at stake, so he didn't care. When I performed the CPR I'm pretty sure Larry's mouth moved. I'm not saying he could've been saved for sure, but he definitely wasn't dead! Kenny stripped her of the most powerful motivator in life... hope! He could've been more tactful like my Lee was. However, he only saw a chance to tip the scales to his side by finishing Larry the moment he could. He has always been the one that is really power-hungry, the one bossing Lee around. Lilly was always trying to care for the group and she continued doing that even after her father died. We'll see how much will Kenny care for the rest in ep 4.
Was his lip moving because he was alive or reanimating? I'll admit she was looking out for the group before her father died, but after... nah. Shooting people in the face isn't helping anyone (if they aren't bandits).
He could've waited a bit, give her a chance to finish with the CPR. He, however, hurried because his family's lives were at stake, so he didn't care. When I performed the CPR I'm pretty sure Larry's mouth moved. I'm not saying he could've been saved for sure, but he definitely wasn't dead! Kenny stripped her of the most powerful motivator in life... hope! He could've been more tactful like my Lee was. However, he only saw a chance to tip the scales to his side by finishing Larry the moment he could. He has always been the one that is really power-hungry, the one bossing Lee around. Lilly was always trying to care for the group and she continued doing that even after her father died. We'll see how much will Kenny care for the rest in ep 4.
Sorry don't agree. Yes his family was in danger but they were short of time aswell. How long did it take the guy who died from blood loss to turn and then attack Katjaa? They could have literally had seconds before he turned. And there's no time to slowly ease Lilly away from her dad. And you think Kenny enjoyed killing Larry? Did you not see his face after killing him? He was completely horrified at what he had to do. Also his lips moving could have meant he was reaminating.
Also Kenny is obviously not power-hungry because he plans to leave the group and go with his family. He obviously doesnt want to lead some powerful group.
Was his lip moving because he was alive or reanimating? I'll admit she was looking out for the group before her father died, but after... nah. Shooting people in the face isn't helping anyone (if they aren't bandits).
I guess he could've held that salt-lick for 5 more seconds so we can know the answer to your question He could've put one salt-lick on Larry's legs so that he couldn't move in case he turns. Then wait with another in case Larry indeed turns. He wasn't trying to save lives there, he just wanted it to be over... he saw the chance and he took it. My Lee will never forgive him that.
About Lilly, well shooting the traitor would help the group. In my opinion Carley looked guilty as hell. For a minute I even thought she was the traitor...
How would you react if Carley was indeed the traitor?
@Wrighty he wants them all to leave with him, not just his family. What if Larry was indeed alive? We all waited to see if Duck's gonna make it although he was doomed. He had slimmer chance for survival than Larry and we all let that kid stay around Clem and Katjaa... Oh I forgot, it's Kenny's family so it's justified to wait...
my save carley page if you bothered to look at it was created during the wait for ep3, so it is in no way a petition page, it is purely a carley fan page in line with save doug..
but thanks to lilly saving is no longer an option..
my save carley page if you bothered to look at it was created during the wait for ep3, so it is in no way a petition page, it is purely a carley fan page in line with save doug..
but thanks to lilly saving is no longer an option..
I'm sorry, my mistake. I thought you were making a petition forcing Telltale to bring Carley back in the game.
Team Kenny. how the fuck can you be with lilly after she...
Spoilers!
Stole the RV. REALLY? That was a hit in the crotch. What if the group couldn't get the train started? The game would be them running and finding shelter. I'm not about to play that, Kenny Is a hero, He Survived his wife and kid dying, He helped Lee out of a jam a few times. He's A baws. While Lilly gives no fuck about anyone but herself and her father.
TEAM KENNY ALL THE WAY!
I guess he could've held that salt-lick for 5 more seconds so we can know the answer to your question He could've put one salt-lick on Larry's legs so that he couldn't move in case he turns. Then wait with another in case Larry indeed turns. He wasn't trying to save lives there, he just wanted it to be over... he saw the chance and he took it. My Lee will never forgive him that.
About Lilly, well shooting the traitor would help the group. In my opinion Carley looked guilty as hell. For a minute I even thought she was the traitor...
How would you react if Carley was indeed the traitor?
@Wrighty he wants them all to leave with him, not just his family. What if Larry was indeed alive? We all waited to see if Duck's gonna make it although he was doomed. He had slimmer chance for survival than Larry and we all let that kid stay around Clem and Katjaa... Oh I forgot, it's Kenny's family so it's justified to wait...
In his position he was still able to bite Lilly or Lee, maybe both. He couldn't take
time to think it over anyway, if he was turning then Kenny couldn't just stick the salt lick on his legs and pull away two people at the same time. Also big differences between Laary and Duck. And he was again probably thinking of his family.
Duck is a small child, Larry is a huge man. More dangerous as a walker.
The group were in a reasonably large store with Duck. The group were in a very confined space with Larry.
The group had weapons around Duck. No weapons around Larry.
Ect
And I still would have kicked out and hated Lilly if Carely was the traitor. Just because she was guilty doesn't mean you get to just execute her on the spot. And just because Ben was the traitor doesn't mean he has to die, he wAs afraid and made a mistake. Nope, Lilly would still be phyco.
In his position he was still able to bite Lilly or Lee, maybe both. He couldn't take
time to think it over anyway, if he was turning then Kenny couldn't just stick the salt lick on his legs and pull away two people at the same time. Also big differences between Laary and Duck. And he was again probably thinking of his family.
Duck is a small child, Larry is a huge man. More dangerous as a walker.
The group were in a reasonably large store with Duck. The group were in a very confined space with Larry.
The group had weapons around Duck. No weapons around Larry.
Ect
And I still would have kicked out and hated Lilly if Carely was the traitor. Just because she was guilty doesn't mean you get to just execute her on the spot. And just because Ben was the traitor doesn't mean he has to die, he wAs afraid and made a mistake. Nope, Lilly would still be phyco.
So let me get this straight! You would kill that psycho Lilly because she killed a group member, but the traitor who almost got all of you killed by dealing with the bandits behind your back is worth livin'?
If Kenny was doing the right thing he should've taken care of Duck right away, just like he did with Larry. Duck was more of a thinking bomb than Larry was. The old man still had some chance, while Duck was doomed.
So let me get this straight! You would kill that psycho Lilly because she killed a group member, but the traitor who almost got all of you killed by dealing with the bandits behind your back is worth livin'?
He wa just a stupid kid who thought his friends were in danger. They probably scared him into doing it and I wouldn't kill a person who made a honest mistake. Living with the guilt is probably punishment enough.
Duck could have maybe bit one person before Larry or Lee or Carely or Doug who by the way have weapons could kill him. Larry could have devoured all three because he is huge and they had no weapons.
I thought you were gonna make me watch Lee and Kenny fight to troll me. :P
One middle aged women, one girl and a homeless guy with no weapons have low odds I agree. The group in the shop was a lot bigger and more prepared.
He wa just a stupid kid who thought his friends were in danger. They probably scared him into doing it and I wouldn't kill a person who made a honest mistake. Living with the guilt is probably punishment enough.
Duck could have maybe bit one person before Larry or Lee or Carely or Doug who by the way have weapons could kill him. Larry could have devoured all three because he is huge and they had no weapons.
I thought you were gonna make me watch Lee and Kenny fight to troll me. :P
One middle aged women, one girl and a homeless guy with no weapons have low odds I agree. The group in the shop was a lot bigger and more prepared.
When they were hiding in the shop, there were no lethal objects around, except for guns and they couldn't use them obviously because the streets outside were crawling with walkers. He was a threat back then, but we let him live.
Now when we all knew he was bitten, why take him on the train with us? Why didn't they finish him right after they stopped the RV? I guess he couldn't bring himself to do it! Nobody knew how long was Duck gonna last, so he was a ticking bomb. Kenny's very eager to kill and abandon other people, but when it comes to his own, he can't do it.
Don't justify him, just admit that he is a selfish bastard
When they were hiding in the shop, there were no lethal objects around, except for guns and they couldn't use them obviously because the streets outside were crawling with walkers. He was a threat back then, but we let him live.
Now when we all knew he was bitten, why take him on the train with us? Why didn't they finish him right after they stopped the RV? I guess he couldn't bring himself to do it! Nobody knew how long was Duck gonna last, so he was a ticking bomb. Kenny's very eager to kill and abandon other people, but when it comes to his own, he can't do it.
Don't justify him, just admit that he is a selfish bastard
If my son was bitten, I couldnt go "Okay Lee, take him to the woods and headshot him" I doubt many could. And this was Kenny who obviously loves his family greatly. He was in pure shock and was grasping at straws to save him. Of course it's different if a family member is bitten. And Katjaa is a vet, maybe she could make a difference, like she said we know nothing about the disease. Don't call him a hypocrite for not being able to immediately kill his son.
And why couldn't they shoot in the shop, the gates were closed and the walls would slightly muffle the sound. If they didn't hear the TVs they wouldn't hear the shot. Also doesn't Carley shoot a walker to save Clem?
Yeah and later the walkers that were attracted by the shot entered the shop and killed Carley/Doug.
Well, he killed Larry in an eye-blink. Maybe we should've let Lilly kill his son then. Eye for eye...
Even if they did, it still wouldn't be enough for me. Larry had a chance to survive, no matter how slim it was... Duck had NONE at all. It's wouldn't be the same.
You seem to forget that Larry was Lilly's father. It was her family that Kenny didn't hesitate to destroy, but he couldn't finish off his own. Why shouldn't I call him a hypocrite. That's what he is
Yeah and later the walkers that were attracted by the shot entered the shop and killed Carley/Doug.
Well, he killed Larry in an eye-blink. Maybe we should've let Lilly kill his son then. Eye for eye...
Even if they did, it still wouldn't be enough for me. Larry had a chance to survive, no matter how slim it was... Duck had NONE at all. It's wouldn't be the same.
You seem to forget that Larry was Lilly's father. It was her family that Kenny didn't hesitate to destroy, but he couldn't finish off his own. Why shouldn't I call him a hypocrite. That's what he is
Amen. Just add Kenny next to Ben :P
the context changes the situation, so it isnt hypocrisy, your a fool and a fanboy if you can see the difference
Yeah and later the walkers that were attracted by the shot entered the shop and killed Carley/Doug.
Well, he killed Larry in an eye-blink. Maybe we should've let Lilly kill his son then. Eye for eye...
Even if they did, it still wouldn't be enough for me. Larry had a chance to survive, no matter how slim it was... Duck had NONE at all. It's wouldn't be the same.
You seem to forget that Larry was Lilly's father. It was her family that Kenny didn't hesitate to destroy, but he couldn't finish off his own. Why shouldn't I call him a hypocrite. That's what he is
Amen. Just add Kenny next to Ben :P
Sorry I thought the walkers were attracted by the burglar alarm. :P
Kenny only had a small time to decide what to do, he could reanimate any second. Duck however was not even dead, he was still alive and surrounded by big people with guns. Duck had a huge chance, thankfully Larry was wrong. Larry also had a chance but it was tiny and the risks were huge.
And sorry but Kenny had to make the Larry choice quickly. He had time for Duck and he told Lee, basically asking him to be careful and showing that he cares for him and Clem. Again can't make any father make the choice to kill his son quickly. And he told Lee, so they were ready for him turning. Also If Kenny didn't make the call, I would kill Duck. Thank god Kenny is smart
but you constant warping of what happened and overly biased opinion is annoying
Don't you think that from my point of you, you look overly biased? I don't mind that because I love good discussions. If you do not like it what are you doing in a Team Lilly vs Team Kenny thread? Go to Team Kenny forever thread or something.
Wrighty, I cannot agree, I'm sorry. But Larry situation in ep 2 is exactly the same as Duck in ep 3. Duck could've died any second and reanimated. Nobody really knows how this work. He would kill somebody that's why I believe that clip I showed you is put in the game in the first place. Duck was even a bigger danger than Larry.
You say that you can't force a dad to kill his son. Well, yeah but he didn't hesitate with Larry. I feel that you don't really care about him so that's why you can't see why it is almost the same. What if Clem shot and was either dying/ or being saved and Kenny dropped a salt-lick on her head just because she MIGHT turn. Would you feel the same as you feel now?
Don't you think that from my point of you, you look overly biased? I don't mind that because I love good discussions. If you do not like it what are you doing in a Team Lilly vs Team Kenny thread? Go to Team Kenny forever thread or something.
Wrighty, I cannot agree, I'm sorry. But Larry situation in ep 2 is exactly the same as Duck in ep 3. Duck could've died any second and reanimated. Nobody really knows how this work. He would kill somebody that's why I believe that clip I showed you is put in the game in the first place. Duck was even a bigger danger than Larry.
You say that you can't force a dad to kill his son. Well, yeah but he didn't hesitate with Larry. I feel that you don't really care about him so that's why you can't see why it is almost the same. What if Clem shot and was either dying/ or being saved and Kenny dropped a salt-lick on her head just because she MIGHT turn. Would you feel the same as you feel now?
thats what i mean by context, the first and most important thing is that she is a child, as a child she had less muscle less strength, she also has much more potential life in her, this changes the situation enough so that the decision to kill a child for the protection of others is an entirely different decision than to kill a massive old man with a heart condition
Don't you think that from my point of you, you look overly biased? I don't mind that because I love good discussions. If you do not like it what are you doing in a Team Lilly vs Team Kenny thread? Go to Team Kenny forever thread or something.
Wrighty, I cannot agree, I'm sorry. But Larry situation in ep 2 is exactly the same as Duck in ep 3. Duck could've died any second and reanimated. Nobody really knows how this work. He would kill somebody that's why I believe that clip I showed you is put in the game in the first place. Duck was even a bigger danger than Larry.
You say that you can't force a dad to kill his son. Well, yeah but he didn't hesitate with Larry. I feel that you don't really care about him so that's why you can't see why it is almost the same. What if Clem shot and was either dying/ or being saved and Kenny dropped a salt-lick on her head just because she MIGHT turn. Would you feel the same as you feel now?
I agree Duck is a danger but not as much as Larry, I've already posted why so I won't bother. Agree to Disagree.
Clem wouldn't be as much as a threat as Larry but I would stand and watch and feel horrible. In a enclosed space, she is really dangerous. Also there are people outside the meat locker who need me to live and I can't risk letting them die (Kat and Duck)
Don't you think that from my point of you, you look overly biased? I don't mind that because I love good discussions. If you do not like it what are you doing in a Team Lilly vs Team Kenny thread? Go to Team Kenny forever thread or something.
Wrighty, I cannot agree, I'm sorry. But Larry situation in ep 2 is exactly the same as Duck in ep 3. Duck could've died any second and reanimated. Nobody really knows how this work. He would kill somebody that's why I believe that clip I showed you is put in the game in the first place. Duck was even a bigger danger than Larry.
You say that you can't force a dad to kill his son. Well, yeah but he didn't hesitate with Larry. I feel that you don't really care about him so that's why you can't see why it is almost the same. What if Clem shot and was either dying/ or being saved and Kenny dropped a salt-lick on her head just because she MIGHT turn. Would you feel the same as you feel now?
How was Duck a bigger danger? They were locked in a meatlocker with a possible 300 pound monster. Honestly, I tried to save Larry, but I don't think Kenny was wrong in killing him. If Larry gets up and starts moving around, that salt lick is a hell of a lot harder to kill him with and you can pretty much guarantee that everyone in the meatlocker is dead.
thats what i mean by context, the first and most important thing is that she is a child, as a child she had less muscle less strength, she also has much more potential life in her, this changes the situation enough so that the decision to kill a child for the protection of others is an entirely different decision than to kill a massive old man with a heart condition
As far as I've seen all walkers have same strength and agility, despite age or gender. I would even guess that a child walker will be quicker than an old guy. Anyway, it's all walkers to me.
Wrighty, I'm against neglecting one person's family for another's. You clearly didn't wanted to help Lilly and Larry and that's your right. But you can't convince me that's correct. In the meat locker situation Katjaa and Duck could've already been dead, you have no reason to believe they are alive. Kenny likes two think they are, of course, but he doesn't have a proof. Lilly, however, needed you right there right away.
Why I chose Lilly? She needed me and I couldn't have let my misunderstandings with Larry cloud my judgement of what's right and wrong.
Okay, fellas, let's agree to disagree until somebody else joins the conversation. We are turning this into a private chat
skepticalguy90, it was a risk I was willing to take, just as I allowed Katjaa and Kenny to take their time with Duck. You can check the clip as well
As far as I've seen all walkers have same strength and agility, despite age or gender. I would even guess that a child walker will be quicker than an old guy. Anyway, it's all walkers to me.
Wrighty, I'm against neglecting one person's family for another's. You clearly didn't wanted to help Lilly and Larry and that's your right. But you can't convince me that's correct. In the meat locker situation Katjaa and Duck could've already been dead, you have no reason to believe they are alive. Kenny likes two think they are, of course, but he doesn't have a proof. Lilly, however, needed you right there right away.
Why I chose Lilly? She needed me and I couldn't have let my misunderstandings with Larry cloud my judgement of what's right and wrong.
Okay, fellas, let's agree to disagree until somebody else joins the conversation. We are turning this into a private chat
skepticalguy90, it was a risk I was willing to take, just as I allowed Katjaa and Kenny to take their time with Duck. You can check the clip as well
Ok, i gotta go to bed now anyway. I shall just leave with this
I honestly had nothing against Lilly or Larry at that moment. I was really angry when Larry left me for dead but I understand. Nothing against Lilly either (at that moment). I honestly weighed up the situation, evaluated the dangers and made my choice. Same with Ducks situation. I felt the dangers were different and admittedly I was touched at the time that Kenny told me. He could have said nothing and killed us all. But he didn't.
In conclusion, Kenny is awesome and honest and cool. :P
See y'all tomorrow.
As far as I've seen all walkers have same strength and agility, despite age or gender. I would even guess that a child walker will be quicker than an old guy. Anyway, it's all walkers to me.
Nature would disagree with dead people rising and being able to move at all but...
yes but i still am able to suspend my disbelief about zombies, but i believe that in the fictional world that the walking dead is set, zombies are normal physical beings that are bound by the laws of physics and no magic is involved
yes but i still am able to suspend my disbelief about zombies, but i believe that in the fictional world that the walking dead is set, zombies are normal physical beings that are bound by the laws of physics and no magic is involved
Well, yeah. The laws of physics dictate that children would move faster than a 90 kilos 50-60 old guy.
Comments
All right then.
I would have to disagree here. Lilly "went mad" because Kenny was wrong from the very beginning, especially about the Larry situation. He drove her to this state, so it's all on him in my book. His entire "protect my family before everybody else" not only backfired but it also cost the lives of others and the well-being of the entire group.
haha thanks!
I wouldn't say it was Kenny that really unhinged her so much as her father during in front of her. And how was Kenny wrong? If Larry died, then turned, then everyone was dead. EVERYONE. No one to save Katjaa and Duck and no one to warn Lilly/Doug and Ben. Is it really worth risking the lives of everyone to possibly save one guy who had a heart attack?
Not sure what other wrong decisions you think Kenny made.
He could've waited a bit, give her a chance to finish with the CPR. He, however, hurried because his family's lives were at stake, so he didn't care. When I performed the CPR I'm pretty sure Larry's mouth moved. I'm not saying he could've been saved for sure, but he definitely wasn't dead! Kenny stripped her of the most powerful motivator in life... hope! He could've been more tactful like my Lee was. However, he only saw a chance to tip the scales to his side by finishing Larry the moment he could. He has always been the one that is really power-hungry, the one bossing Lee around. Lilly was always trying to care for the group and she continued doing that even after her father died. We'll see how much will Kenny care for the rest in ep 4.
Was his lip moving because he was alive or reanimating? I'll admit she was looking out for the group before her father died, but after... nah. Shooting people in the face isn't helping anyone (if they aren't bandits).
Sorry don't agree. Yes his family was in danger but they were short of time aswell. How long did it take the guy who died from blood loss to turn and then attack Katjaa? They could have literally had seconds before he turned. And there's no time to slowly ease Lilly away from her dad. And you think Kenny enjoyed killing Larry? Did you not see his face after killing him? He was completely horrified at what he had to do. Also his lips moving could have meant he was reaminating.
Also Kenny is obviously not power-hungry because he plans to leave the group and go with his family. He obviously doesnt want to lead some powerful group.
I guess he could've held that salt-lick for 5 more seconds so we can know the answer to your question
About Lilly, well shooting the traitor would help the group. In my opinion Carley looked guilty as hell. For a minute I even thought she was the traitor...
How would you react if Carley was indeed the traitor?
@Wrighty he wants them all to leave with him, not just his family. What if Larry was indeed alive? We all waited to see if Duck's gonna make it although he was doomed. He had slimmer chance for survival than Larry and we all let that kid stay around Clem and Katjaa... Oh I forgot, it's Kenny's family so it's justified to wait...
but thanks to lilly saving is no longer an option..
I'm sorry, my mistake. I thought you were making a petition forcing Telltale to bring Carley back in the game.
Spoilers!
Stole the RV. REALLY? That was a hit in the crotch. What if the group couldn't get the train started? The game would be them running and finding shelter. I'm not about to play that, Kenny Is a hero, He Survived his wife and kid dying, He helped Lee out of a jam a few times. He's A baws. While Lilly gives no fuck about anyone but herself and her father.
TEAM KENNY ALL THE WAY!
In his position he was still able to bite Lilly or Lee, maybe both. He couldn't take
time to think it over anyway, if he was turning then Kenny couldn't just stick the salt lick on his legs and pull away two people at the same time. Also big differences between Laary and Duck. And he was again probably thinking of his family.
Duck is a small child, Larry is a huge man. More dangerous as a walker.
The group were in a reasonably large store with Duck. The group were in a very confined space with Larry.
The group had weapons around Duck. No weapons around Larry.
Ect
And I still would have kicked out and hated Lilly if Carely was the traitor. Just because she was guilty doesn't mean you get to just execute her on the spot. And just because Ben was the traitor doesn't mean he has to die, he wAs afraid and made a mistake. Nope, Lilly would still be phyco.
So let me get this straight! You would kill that psycho Lilly because she killed a group member, but the traitor who almost got all of you killed by dealing with the bandits behind your back is worth livin'?
P.S I disagree about the Larry/Duck difference... a walker is a walker and that's it. This is what could've happened with duck around - watch from 2:18 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0_E9v68mKc&feature=youtu.be
If Kenny was doing the right thing he should've taken care of Duck right away, just like he did with Larry. Duck was more of a thinking bomb than Larry was. The old man still had some chance, while Duck was doomed.
He wa just a stupid kid who thought his friends were in danger. They probably scared him into doing it and I wouldn't kill a person who made a honest mistake. Living with the guilt is probably punishment enough.
Duck could have maybe bit one person before Larry or Lee or Carely or Doug who by the way have weapons could kill him. Larry could have devoured all three because he is huge and they had no weapons.
I thought you were gonna make me watch Lee and Kenny fight to troll me. :P
One middle aged women, one girl and a homeless guy with no weapons have low odds I agree. The group in the shop was a lot bigger and more prepared.
I wouldnt kill a man because he was a liability, just make him leave.
When they were hiding in the shop, there were no lethal objects around, except for guns and they couldn't use them obviously because the streets outside were crawling with walkers. He was a threat back then, but we let him live.
Now when we all knew he was bitten, why take him on the train with us? Why didn't they finish him right after they stopped the RV? I guess he couldn't bring himself to do it! Nobody knew how long was Duck gonna last, so he was a ticking bomb. Kenny's very eager to kill and abandon other people, but when it comes to his own, he can't do it.
Don't justify him, just admit that he is a selfish bastard
If my son was bitten, I couldnt go "Okay Lee, take him to the woods and headshot him" I doubt many could. And this was Kenny who obviously loves his family greatly. He was in pure shock and was grasping at straws to save him. Of course it's different if a family member is bitten. And Katjaa is a vet, maybe she could make a difference, like she said we know nothing about the disease. Don't call him a hypocrite for not being able to immediately kill his son.
And why couldn't they shoot in the shop, the gates were closed and the walls would slightly muffle the sound. If they didn't hear the TVs they wouldn't hear the shot. Also doesn't Carley shoot a walker to save Clem?
Oh and NEVER!! :P
Well, he killed Larry in an eye-blink. Maybe we should've let Lilly kill his son then. Eye for eye...
Even if they did, it still wouldn't be enough for me. Larry had a chance to survive, no matter how slim it was... Duck had NONE at all. It's wouldn't be the same.
You seem to forget that Larry was Lilly's father. It was her family that Kenny didn't hesitate to destroy, but he couldn't finish off his own. Why shouldn't I call him a hypocrite. That's what he is
Amen. Just add Kenny next to Ben :P
the context changes the situation, so it isnt hypocrisy, your a fool and a fanboy if you can see the difference
Learn to respect other people's opinion, kid. I might argue with people and defend my beliefs but I'm not calling anybody names.
but you constant warping of what happened and overly biased opinion is annoying
Sorry I thought the walkers were attracted by the burglar alarm. :P
Kenny only had a small time to decide what to do, he could reanimate any second. Duck however was not even dead, he was still alive and surrounded by big people with guns. Duck had a huge chance, thankfully Larry was wrong. Larry also had a chance but it was tiny and the risks were huge.
And sorry but Kenny had to make the Larry choice quickly. He had time for Duck and he told Lee, basically asking him to be careful and showing that he cares for him and Clem. Again can't make any father make the choice to kill his son quickly. And he told Lee, so they were ready for him turning. Also If Kenny didn't make the call, I would kill Duck. Thank god Kenny is smart
Don't you think that from my point of you, you look overly biased? I don't mind that because I love good discussions. If you do not like it what are you doing in a Team Lilly vs Team Kenny thread? Go to Team Kenny forever thread or something.
Wrighty, I cannot agree, I'm sorry. But Larry situation in ep 2 is exactly the same as Duck in ep 3. Duck could've died any second and reanimated. Nobody really knows how this work. He would kill somebody that's why I believe that clip I showed you is put in the game in the first place. Duck was even a bigger danger than Larry.
You say that you can't force a dad to kill his son. Well, yeah but he didn't hesitate with Larry. I feel that you don't really care about him so that's why you can't see why it is almost the same. What if Clem shot and was either dying/ or being saved and Kenny dropped a salt-lick on her head just because she MIGHT turn. Would you feel the same as you feel now?
thats what i mean by context, the first and most important thing is that she is a child, as a child she had less muscle less strength, she also has much more potential life in her, this changes the situation enough so that the decision to kill a child for the protection of others is an entirely different decision than to kill a massive old man with a heart condition
I agree Duck is a danger but not as much as Larry, I've already posted why so I won't bother. Agree to Disagree.
Clem wouldn't be as much as a threat as Larry but I would stand and watch and feel horrible. In a enclosed space, she is really dangerous. Also there are people outside the meat locker who need me to live and I can't risk letting them die (Kat and Duck)
How was Duck a bigger danger? They were locked in a meatlocker with a possible 300 pound monster. Honestly, I tried to save Larry, but I don't think Kenny was wrong in killing him. If Larry gets up and starts moving around, that salt lick is a hell of a lot harder to kill him with and you can pretty much guarantee that everyone in the meatlocker is dead.
Watch from 2:18 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0_E9...ature=youtu.be
As far as I've seen all walkers have same strength and agility, despite age or gender. I would even guess that a child walker will be quicker than an old guy. Anyway, it's all walkers to me.
Wrighty, I'm against neglecting one person's family for another's. You clearly didn't wanted to help Lilly and Larry and that's your right. But you can't convince me that's correct. In the meat locker situation Katjaa and Duck could've already been dead, you have no reason to believe they are alive. Kenny likes two think they are, of course, but he doesn't have a proof. Lilly, however, needed you right there right away.
Why I chose Lilly? She needed me and I couldn't have let my misunderstandings with Larry cloud my judgement of what's right and wrong.
Okay, fellas, let's agree to disagree until somebody else joins the conversation. We are turning this into a private chat
skepticalguy90, it was a risk I was willing to take, just as I allowed Katjaa and Kenny to take their time with Duck. You can check the clip as well
Ok, i gotta go to bed now anyway. I shall just leave with this
I honestly had nothing against Lilly or Larry at that moment. I was really angry when Larry left me for dead but I understand. Nothing against Lilly either (at that moment). I honestly weighed up the situation, evaluated the dangers and made my choice. Same with Ducks situation. I felt the dangers were different and admittedly I was touched at the time that Kenny told me. He could have said nothing and killed us all. But he didn't.
In conclusion, Kenny is awesome and honest and cool. :P
See y'all tomorrow.
physics would disagree
Nature would disagree with dead people rising and being able to move at all but...
yes but i still am able to suspend my disbelief about zombies, but i believe that in the fictional world that the walking dead is set, zombies are normal physical beings that are bound by the laws of physics and no magic is involved
Well, yeah. The laws of physics dictate that children would move faster than a 90 kilos 50-60 old guy.
i was more focused on the strength part