Thats it. Even if it wasnt Kenny, the person would get mad and try to kill Jane. Imagine if it was Alvin, what would he have done to Jane? Or Carlos if Jane did something to Sara? Lee with Clementine? There is no way Jane was in the right, she had the stupid ideia, she provoked him with his family, she made him mad
Kenny has lost so much, just like clementine (Obviously many others too) Kenny made a promise to raise AJ "The right way" and he intended to… more keep this promise....now if it was Lee who was in the situation and you played as him you'd lose control over yourself emotionally just thinking about the fact that clementine is gone (Which she isnt) but in the end I'm sure many...maybe even all would kill the one who killed our beloved clementine. My point is in the end many think Jane was In the right but in reality she just reflected who SHE really was as a character. Just my thoughts on the concept.
I'm with my man Lee on this one. Clem surviving on her own, and by that I mean with A.J. which is technically even worse, isn't likely. It's gonna take at least 2 semi-capable or 1 really capable person to make it, and I'm gonna get some heat for this, but Clem is only semi-capable. Don't get me wrong, she's tough as nails but she's only about 2 and half feet tall, has little girl muscles and a 1st grade education. What if she gets sick or badly hurts herself? A.J. isn't gonna nurse her back to health. I mean in All That Remains she only made it about 8 hours on her own before needing someone else's help.
Theres not a lot of realistic things in a zombie apocalypse.
Realistically populations would die off faster than they have been and lone … moresurvivors would gain a great chance at surviving as time passed. It's already been a year and a half or more for her with Lee and Christa, so if we want realistic then most the zombies have decomposed to a non threat level or they've been bashed in.
So yeah realistically Clem could survive much better by herself.
People sure do like the line "just to prove a point." She was showing to Clem what would happen if AJ was ever under Clem's care and Kenny would find out that something happened. She selflessly decided to take the risk of Kenny trying to kill her so that a relatively small girl wouldn't have to, later in life.
Interesting thought, but I'm not sure it has the same dynamic. Jane doesn't care about A.J. and Kenny knows it, Clem knows it, Jane knows, and even A.J. probably knows it, so him vanishing mysteriously under Jane's care is a hell of a lot more suspicious than, say Clem tripping and dropping him thus provoking a very different reaction.
And not only is there their relations to A.J. but Kenny himself. If someone you trust (Clem) say it was an accident you're probably going to trust them whereas someone you don't trust as far as you can throw them (Jane) says it was an accident your bulls*t detector is probably going off.
Lets see. She left an infant in an abandoned car in the middle of a snowstorm during the zombie apocalypse just to prove a point.
Pe… moreople sure do like the line "just to prove a point." She was showing to Clem what would happen if AJ was ever under Clem's care and Kenny would find out that something happened. She selflessly decided to take the risk of Kenny trying to kill her so that a relatively small girl wouldn't have to, later in life.
Understandably, Kenny(under the impression that she let an infant die) wasn't very fond of that.
Wasn't very fond of that, and attempted to kill her twice before she even fought back. She was saying that it was an accident, but he was so blinded—no pun intended—by rage that he didn't listen.
She could have said that he was fine and they could all go on their merry way or split up but everyone would live.
Staying with Kenny, Clem and AJ meant that that would've happened even… [view original content]
A thought occurred to me and I'm not sure if anyone's brought it up yet. Hypothetical; Kenny and Jane fight, Jane dies, Kenny and Clem cry for awhile and move onward Wellington bound since Clem still needs to be safe. So... Where's A.J.? He's still in the back of the car freezing to death because the only person who knew he was there is dead. It's only by dumb luck you find him after siding with Kenny. Jane didn't set up a backup to let Clem/Kenny know A.J.'s relatively okay incase she died meaning she didn't just stake her own life on Clem killing Kenny, but A.J.'s too. I know she didn't care about him, but that's just cold. Eh, no pun intended.
That's a fresh perspective on the matter for sure. It has—somewhat—changed my view on the subject, making Kenny being suspicious over Jane after the baby disappeared—somewhat—more understandable. I sincerely appreciate it.
People sure do like the line "just to prove a point." She was showing to Clem what would happen if AJ was ever under Clem's care and Kenny w… moreould find out that something happened. She selflessly decided to take the risk of Kenny trying to kill her so that a relatively small girl wouldn't have to, later in life.
Interesting thought, but I'm not sure it has the same dynamic. Jane doesn't care about A.J. and Kenny knows it, Clem knows it, Jane knows, and even A.J. probably knows it, so him vanishing mysteriously under Jane's care is a hell of a lot more suspicious than, say Clem tripping and dropping him thus provoking a very different reaction.
And not only is there their relations to A.J. but Kenny himself. If someone you trust (Clem) say it was an accident you're probably going to trust them whereas someone you don't trust as far as you can throw them (Jane) says it was an accident your bulls*t detector is probably going off.
Well realistically Clem wouldn't keep AJ. It's not like she can breast feed the baby or find baby food anywhere around.
Idk about you guys but in reality it's already been two years. If most of the walkers aren't already dead then most the ppl are. So she could survive for a good time until she gets legit sick. Which if it didn't happen before it won't randomly happen. And if it does, she has a gun.
I'm with my man Lee on this one. Clem surviving on her own, and by that I mean with A.J. which is technically even worse, isn't likely. It's… more gonna take at least 2 semi-capable or 1 really capable person to make it, and I'm gonna get some heat for this, but Clem is only semi-capable. Don't get me wrong, she's tough as nails but she's only about 2 and half feet tall, has little girl muscles and a 1st grade education. What if she gets sick or badly hurts herself? A.J. isn't gonna nurse her back to health. I mean in All That Remains she only made it about 8 hours on her own before needing someone else's help.
Comments
Thats it. Even if it wasnt Kenny, the person would get mad and try to kill Jane. Imagine if it was Alvin, what would he have done to Jane? Or Carlos if Jane did something to Sara? Lee with Clementine? There is no way Jane was in the right, she had the stupid ideia, she provoked him with his family, she made him mad
I'm with my man Lee on this one. Clem surviving on her own, and by that I mean with A.J. which is technically even worse, isn't likely. It's gonna take at least 2 semi-capable or 1 really capable person to make it, and I'm gonna get some heat for this, but Clem is only semi-capable. Don't get me wrong, she's tough as nails but she's only about 2 and half feet tall, has little girl muscles and a 1st grade education. What if she gets sick or badly hurts herself? A.J. isn't gonna nurse her back to health. I mean in All That Remains she only made it about 8 hours on her own before needing someone else's help.
Interesting thought, but I'm not sure it has the same dynamic. Jane doesn't care about A.J. and Kenny knows it, Clem knows it, Jane knows, and even A.J. probably knows it, so him vanishing mysteriously under Jane's care is a hell of a lot more suspicious than, say Clem tripping and dropping him thus provoking a very different reaction.
And not only is there their relations to A.J. but Kenny himself. If someone you trust (Clem) say it was an accident you're probably going to trust them whereas someone you don't trust as far as you can throw them (Jane) says it was an accident your bulls*t detector is probably going off.
A thought occurred to me and I'm not sure if anyone's brought it up yet. Hypothetical; Kenny and Jane fight, Jane dies, Kenny and Clem cry for awhile and move onward Wellington bound since Clem still needs to be safe. So... Where's A.J.? He's still in the back of the car freezing to death because the only person who knew he was there is dead. It's only by dumb luck you find him after siding with Kenny. Jane didn't set up a backup to let Clem/Kenny know A.J.'s relatively okay incase she died meaning she didn't just stake her own life on Clem killing Kenny, but A.J.'s too. I know she didn't care about him, but that's just cold. Eh, no pun intended.
That's a fresh perspective on the matter for sure. It has—somewhat—changed my view on the subject, making Kenny being suspicious over Jane after the baby disappeared—somewhat—more understandable. I sincerely appreciate it.
You are both horrible people, ice puns are not cool.
Well realistically Clem wouldn't keep AJ. It's not like she can breast feed the baby or find baby food anywhere around.
Idk about you guys but in reality it's already been two years. If most of the walkers aren't already dead then most the ppl are. So she could survive for a good time until she gets legit sick. Which if it didn't happen before it won't randomly happen. And if it does, she has a gun.